This blog provides useful information to business owners, those wanting to own a business, or individuals interested in commercial income properties. Topics include small and mid-market business sales, mergers, acquisitions, valuations, financing and consulting.
ByScott Bushkie, Cornerstone Business Services, Inc. |March 23, 2016
If you’re one of the several million baby boomers thinking about selling their company in the near future, you might be wondering how long the whole process will take and what to expect along the way.
If you have a focused advisor who is working the deal, expect two months of initial prep, 30 to 120 days for marketing, one month for negotiations, and roughly 60-90 days to handle due diligence, financing, and legal. Here’s the process in more detail:
Evaluation
2-3 weeks
As you begin to work with an M&A firm, your first step is to make sure your price expectations match what the market could actually bear. Your advisor will need about two to three weeks to recast your financials and do all the necessary research to put together an estimate of value.
If your expectations or financial needs don’t match up with a professional estimate, you should probably postpone a sale (or re-set your expectations). Ask your advisor how to improve your business value for sale at a later time.
Prep
4-6 weeks
Once you and your advisor agree on a target value, you’ll sign an engagement contract. For the next four to six weeks, your advisor will be putting together the marketing book (typically referred to as a Confidential Information Memorandum) and developing buyer lists.
You’ll be asked to provide a lot of information during this stage. The M&A team will interview you to understand your growth story and future potential. The goal is to create a document that will put your business in the best possible light while remaining informative and credible.
You’ll also be asked to talk about what you’re looking for in terms of a buyer and a future relationship with the business. Are you looking to keep some equity? Would you consider an employment contract? How concerned are you about protecting employee jobs? Your answers will help your advisor shape the target buyer list.
Marketing
1-4 months
Timing for the marketing phase will be your biggest unknown. Depending on the market and the nature of your business, this could typically take anywhere from 30 to 60 days on the short side to 90 to 120 days on the long side.
During this phase, your advisor will be contacting potential buyers from the list you’ve already reviewed. When talking to potential buyers, your advisor will be explaining the opportunity in very general terms, prequalifying their capability to complete a deal, and getting signed confidentiality agreements before releasing any specifics.
For larger deals, which typically generate a lot of interest, we can control the marketing timeline with specific deadlines to achieve multiple offers for you to compare all at once. With smaller deals, we’re more often addressing buyers individually, as they express interest. We’re still trying to usher multiple offers to the table at the same time, but it’s a less uniform process.
Negotiations
2-4 weeks
Once the indications of interest are in, you’ll work with your advisor to narrow down the top candidates, ideally three to five buyers. Then those parties will meet with you and tour the facility (after hours, when reasonable, to maintain confidentiality).
These visits and negotiations may take a couple of weeks, depending on how many buyers are involved. Then you’ll choose the one buyer who brings the best overall value (not always measured in dollars), and move forward to closing.
Closing
2-3 months
At this point, you have a signed letter of intent with one buyer and you’re working through financing and due diligence. A smaller business can close in 45 to 60 days, but a buyer will typically want 60 to 90 days for larger deals.
The sale isn’t complete, of course, until the final paperwork is signed. Any unexpected surprises can kick you back to the negotiation, marketing, or (worst case scenario) evaluation stages.
As a general rule, larger businesses will move through the marketing stage faster but will take longer in prep and final due diligence. Our shortest record here at Cornerstone is one month and 24 days from signed engagement to closing. Our longest sale, however, took two years, six months, and 28 days (the business was directly tied to commodity prices — which dropped the week after we went to market).
One final note: “Start” the sale process the same day you buy your company. Plan ahead so you can make informed decisions about business growth. Then, three to five years before you actually intend to sell, talk to an M&A advisor who will help you make the final preparations to increase value.
For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.
Being good at building a strong business doesn't mean you have the chops to structure and close a merger
By Gary Miller POSTED: 11/15/2015 12:01:00 AM MST
Barry O'Farrell taking to business owners (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
Many business owners are jumping on the bandwagon to sell their companies, trying to take advantage of the current hot market and the frothy multiples being paid by buyers. Combined with the baby boomer tsunami, more businesses are for sale today than ever before.
This trend creates a competitive environment in which buyers anxious to grow their businesses through acquisitions, as well as organic growth, are looking more closely at the quality and price-value relationship of any potential acquisition.
However, 80 percent of owners who put their businesses up for sale never close the transaction. Over years of observation, I have found there are eight basic reasons deals fall apart:
Value expectations too high. The top reason deals fail to close is a seller's unrealistic expectations about value.
Many business owners read and hear about companies or competitors selling their companies for very high sums and believe that their businesses are worth the same.
Unclear story elements. Business owners need to think like buyers. Attracting a buyer is like preparing for a beauty contest. Companies that show best win. Often, because of poor strategic planning, the business owner cannot articulate clearly the company's competitive advantages, its growth opportunities, its revenue potential, and its ability to produce significant returns on invested capital.
Quality of earnings. Audited financial statements confirm financial accuracy and help validate forecasted performance. Lack of clarity about key business drivers, sales pipeline backlogs, back office operations, and the consistency of growth and earnings inhibit a buyer's enthusiasm.
Length of time. Every deal has its own momentum and a life of its own. But time is the enemy of all deals. As the deal process drags on, buyers and sellers start to lose interest.
Material changes. Material changes in the business's operations can occur at any time. While these changes may be completely out of the seller's control — recession, loss of a large client, loss of a key employee — these changes can stop a deal from closing. However, if a material change occurs, the seller must disclose it promptly and fully to the potential buyer. Nothing will destroy a buyer's trust more quickly than the seller failing to be upfront about a material change in the business.
Renegotiating terms of the deal. Renegotiating the terms, conditions, structure, representations and warranties of a settled deal can be a deal killer. At the very least, backtracking components that have been previously agreed to kills momentum, adds time and causes deal fatigue. Worse, it fosters distrust and can call into question all other components of the deal structure previously negotiated.
Reaching for the last dollar. It is completely understandable that sellers who have put everything into their businesses want to get every dollar out. Often, the owner traps herself mentally by fixating on a specific price. Multimillion-dollar deals have been lost over a few thousand dollars. I recommend to clients that they should examine all components of the deal's structure — not just the final offering price.
Inadequate advisers. Selecting a quality deal team is critical. In my experience, owners who are very good at building successful businesses, often stumble in a sale.
Selling a business is a once-in-a-lifetime event for most owners. But most also have never sold a business and do not have the skills to complete a deal on their own, which increases the likelihood that they'll leave money on the table.
Gathering a team of skilled advisers can help. These aids should include an experienced mergers and acquisitions consultant to lead the transaction team; a skilled wealth management firm to help owners preserve their proceeds and to minimize tax obligations; a law firm with significant transaction experience; an accounting firm familiar with the tax implications of various deal structures; and a strong investment banking firm with deep industry experience, solid valuation expertise and keen negotiating and closing skills to get the deal done.
For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.
The industry of buying and selling internet businesses is undoubtedly growing as awareness of the asset class increases and more and more people seek the benefits of owning a website or internet business. As a result, there are waves of new buyers entering the marketplace each month, each with a diverse array of experience and skills, not always “online”, but one thing linking them – a universal motivation to find and acquire quality internet businesses for sale.
That being said, opportunities to acquire good websites are increasingly more difficult to come by and win due in part to the more competitive climate but also as the supply of internet businesses for sale is limited. New buyers can sometimes feel disadvantaged in uncovering and accessing acquisition opportunities compared to buyers that have established connections with sellers directly or through intermediaries.
Equally, when a buyer gains access to attractive targets, they might be disadvantaged in successfully bidding due to limited insight into the niche, being overly cautious as well as possible situational, legal and financial factors that provide an experienced buyer with leverage.
As a result, a prospective acquirer may not be able to move quickly enough in a transaction process compared to other bidders to successfully compete. Risk also exists for a buyer to overpay for a target or to lose the opportunity altogether due to under-bidding or adverse deal terms. It’s not only new buyers that are affected, seasoned investors who run many other businesses can also miss deals by having limited time on their hands to consummate a deal effectively.
Due to these factors, some buyers are choosing to engage a qualified buy-side broker to execute a buy-side process of identifying, accessing and facilitating the successful closing of a deal on their behalf.
Buy-side brokerage is certainly not new but in the online business buying world it’s not entirely established yet. For buyers thinking about whether it makes sense for them, we’ve put together this guide covering what a buy-side broker does, what value they add, how much they cost and what a buyer should be think about when deciding which one to hire.
What Does a Buy-side Broker Do?
A buy-side business broker is there to work the buyer through the steps of a traditional business acquisition process. A good broker will lead the buyer through the stages, carrying out the hard work as well as educating and advising along the way. Each broker has their own process but broadly speaking it should fall within the scope of services outlined below.
1. Identification
The first phase of the buy-side process is to identify and engage acquisition targets. The main objective of this phase is to uncover and pre-qualify an acquisition target. A broker will typically identify and engage an acquisition target in one of two ways: (1) by direct outreach or (2) through sell side intermediaries.
Most brokers tend to opt for the 2nd option as they usually have experience with the listing agents (brokers), there is a more robust sale process and they have greater success in execution. Most buy-side brokers are paid on success (more on that below) so they are prudent with how they spend their time and don’t want to spend significant amounts of time in fruitless search with unmotivated sellers.
A good broker will take time to understand the buyer’s interests and objectives from the outsetto ensure they filter for the right type of businesses before presenting with a list of preliminary acquisition candidates. Oftentimes buyers will benefit from using a broker in “Identification” because of their pre-existing network and knowledge of business buyers, sellers and brokers. Many of the most attractive target opportunities are uncovered through such an established network.
2. Assessment
With a list of targets prepared and preferences made, the broker will proceed to engage the handful of candidates (or their representing brokers) and solicit information for review. The assessment stage is where a buy-side broker should first start to provide their value add to the buyer, by leveraging their knowledge and expertise to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of each target and arrive at a fair valuation for each.
One of the chief concerns of new buyers in the industry is “not knowing what they don’t know”, namely they don’t know what they should be looking out for when it comes to analyzing internet businesses for sale. It’s important to note that this extends just as much to business’ weaknesses as it does to its strengths and potential opportunities for growth. Working with a seasoned buy-side broker should mitigate this concern.
Initially the advisor will conduct preliminary due diligence before exhausting more effort on a valuation. The goal of this step is to better understand the target and its investment merits, as well as to identify any deal-breaking issues prior to committing substantial time, resources and expenses in exploring an acquisition.
Issues that can immediately cause the abandonment of a potential acquisition at this early stage include any materially negative trends in the target’s earnings and growth, pending legal litigation or potential lawsuits, lack of a sustainable and defensive competitive position, personnel turnover, customer concentration or retention concerns and other factors. The broker should also gain a reasonable level of comfort that the potential acquisition target is a strong strategic and person fit for the buyer.
Once the broker has completed their preliminary due diligence, it is necessary to arrive at a preliminary valuation. Most brokers will adopt a multiple-based methodology and a good buy-side broker will have access to a host of market data as well as precedent transactions they have been involved in to help anchor their valuation. This is a very important reason for using a buy-side broker as many inexperienced buyers are concerned about overpaying for an asset. Ensuring the broker has sufficient valuation expertise is vital to getting sound advice on fair valuation.
3. Negotiation
With agreement on an acquisition candidate and a valuation, the broker will take the lead in drafting a letter of intent (LOI). Based on their experience, they should advise the buyer on theoptimal structure of the consideration as well as the terms to attach, be they specific post-deal obligations, due diligence requirements or other checks relevant to the transaction.
An experienced buy-side broker will start to come to the fore in helping a buyer at this point.Getting the valuation right is half of the art in acquiring an internet business, the other half is getting the best execution and deal terms whilst still making it a win-win for the seller. This latter point cannot be underestimated and can make the difference between getting the deal done or not as well as getting a valuable deal done or not.
In formulating the LOI and in any subsequent negotiation and/or revision of the offer, the buy-side broker should advise on:
Consideration – what makes sense to pay upfront vs. deferred (e.g. seller financing) vs. performance-based (e.g. earn out). Each transaction is different with different dynamics that impact the advice given e.g. number of competing bids, size of deal and the motivation level of seller.
Deal terms – what are the requirements for post-sale training and potential consulting obligations, any specific seller representations required (e.g. keep certain links or content in place) and non-compete requirements.
Execution – what is the timetable for execution, how much time is required for due diligence and what are the specific checks and information required to get to closing.
A good buy-side broker will know that all three are as important as each other and advise on how to construct a package that provides overall value to both parties.
4. Due Diligence
With a LOI accepted, the deal will progress to due diligence (DD). The broker will have established their DD checklist for the business (specific to its operations) and will start reviewing the information provided by the seller against the prospectus or marketing materials initially presented and throughout the negotiating process to date.
For a buyer concerned about unknown unknowns, a buy-side broker can be a significant relief in this part of the process. Here the experience of the broker should really shine through and it is imperative they have a good deal of experience in order to know what to look for. That being said, the broker may also recommend the use of a 3rd party due diligence firm to support to verification which is certainly not a bad idea if the buyer doesn’t mind the extra cost for a 2nd opinion.
Due diligence is an extensive task and one not to be taken lightly. Here is often where otherwise experienced but time-strapped buyers think about employing an advisor to save them the time and effort of diligence. A broker or due diligence firm conducting this task on behalf of a buyer will be auditing all aspects of the business including (but not limited to) traffic, financials, the owner, operations, technical features and legal considerations.
With the work complete, the broker will report back with their findings, usually presented along a spectrum of materiality (i.e. things that matter and things that don’t). Invariably if an advisor looks hard enough, things come up in most deals but typically they are immaterial in the context of the purchase. If they are not (e.g. financials misrepresented), then the broker should use their experience to advise on whether they constitute grounds for revision of offer terms or termination all together.
5. Legal
Assuming the business has moved through due diligence successfully, attention will now focus on drafting the Asset Purchase Agreement (APA) for the transaction. Depending on the size of the transaction, the buyer may wish to combine the expertise of their buy-side broker and legal counsel. For smaller deals, many buyers are comfortable without legal counsel though it is important to realise that no broker can provide legal advice unless legally qualified to do so.
As discussed in section 3, the deal terms attached to the business are just as important as the consideration itself. A buy-side broker will likely take the lead on drafting the APA or reviewing the contract provided by the seller and they should be at the least advising upon:
Consideration – The size, structure, timing and form of the consideration for the assets. If there is an earn-out or seller financing the terms and timing of each payment should be made explicit. Likewise, holdback consideration should have very clear conditions attached to it that are ideally objective and verifiable in the case of conflict.
Non-compete – Most online business sales involve a non-compete agreement. A good broker will craft a definition that strikes a balance between protecting the buyer from competition and the seller from being able to pursue other non-competing business in the future.
Assets for transfer – A fully exhaustive list of the assets for transfer is essential.
Transition assistance – Agreeing the level of post-sale support given by the seller is something that should be done upfront and made explicit within the contract. The number of hours per week/month, response time and nature of communication should all be recorded. It is also wise to build in an agreement to make all relevant introductions to partners of the business.
Seller representations – What representations does the seller need to make to agree the deal? These can be representations over no debt/liens/pledges against the business, no previous or outstanding lawsuits, no knowledge of anything that would adversely impact the business, authority to sell all the assets advertised.
Naturally there will be more factors for consideration in the APA depending on the size and complexity of the business as well as the specific terms agreed. These are a starting point for reference and buyers should expect their counsel to cover these as well as any other ones pertinent to the deal.
6. Transfer
With the APA signed, the final step involves escrow and transfer. This is where some buy-side brokers differ in their offering. A full service advisor will support the buyer through the transferring of assets, review in inspection period and enforcement of any training or post sale obligations agreed in the contract.
Others prefer to stand back from the asset transfer and allow the buyer to coordinate the transfer and conduct the asset review independently. Some may provide some post sale strategic advice or give guidance on what to do after buying an online business.
Should I Use a Broker to Buy an Internet Business?
Throughout the process, it’s clear what kind of value add a good buy-side broker can provide to new and experienced buyers alike. To summarise those across the business acquisition process:
A buy-side broker will spend time with the buyer to fully understand their needs, interests and objectives for the acquisition of an online business
Buy-side brokers should have a large network of buyers, sellers and intermediaries with knowledge on who has the highest quality business for sale and who is best to work with
They will save the buyer time in searching and evaluating businesses for sale and provide a list of targets to pursue
They will understand the marketplace intimately and be best placed to opine on the strengths of the particular business models and niches they assess
They will have access to market transaction data as well as their own precedent deal information in order to ground their valuation in empirical data, ensuring the buyer doesn’t overpay
If they are experienced deal makers, they will know what to advise on consideration and deal terms as well as how to get leverage through the deal and post-sale
An independent party is usually helpful in keeping the emotion out of things, particularly in negotiation where that can have a costly impact on terms agreed or execution
They will have been involved in numerous due diligence exercises and know what to look for that may have gone wrong in the past (the unknown unknowns)
If they operate an end-to-end service, they will assist in the transfer of assets and review during escrow
Lastly, brokers invariably lead the transaction so that the buyer is only involved when they need to be saving time across all the steps in the purchase process
How Much Do They Cost?
In general a buy-side broker would be expected to charge between 5-15% of the total consideration of the sale. Their fee is typically success-based (contingent on completion of the deal) and they usually charge a small retainer up front to cover the initial costs of identification, assessment and submitting an LOI (negotiation). Some advisors will also charge a flat hourly rate similar to an attorney.
Is it worth it? That largely depends on two things: 1) how much a buyer knows already and 2) how much they think their time is worth. On point 2, if the opportunity cost of buying a business independently is significantly higher than the cost of hiring an advisor, it makes sense to do the latter.
On point 1, there is one important comparison above all that puts the cost of hiring a buy-side broker in perspective. It costs much less than the expensive mistakes that a poorly executed acquisition can cause.
How Do I Pick the Right Broker?
It’svery important pick the right buy-side broker. Knowledge, trust and a true alignment of interests are absolutely fundamental to the selection of a good advisor and to establish those, buyers should not be afraid quiz their prospective counsel heavily. Some considerations:
Reputation – Buyers should have the advisor provide them with references of other buyers they have worked with in the past and contact them independently to ensure they had a good experience.
Process – Look to deeply understand the process and services of the advisor. A good buyer’s broker will outline the exact services they will and will not provide at every stage. Work out which aspects of the process they are responsible for and crucially which they are not. Many brokers for example only transact on businesses the buyer locates first.
Experience – A good broker should prove their experience and quality right away. The initial consultation will be the centre point of this assessment and should delve deep into the buyer’s profile, financial situation, expectations, timeline, the process, market conditions and deal case studies (to name a few). Quiz them on their industry connections, precedent deals and specific expertise.
Personal fit – Work with someone likeable and trustworthy. If there is a bad sense from initial consultations then it’s probably best to avoid. That being said, it’s worth getting an advisor that gives isn’t afraid to give controversial advice. A ‘yes’ man seems positive at the start but can cost a buyer dearly post sale.
Final Thoughts
As the industry grows and formalizes it is likely that buy-side brokers will grow in prominence in the online business buying world as they have done offline. Buyers who fit the profile of someone who can benefit from buy-side counsel should not shy away from taking a serious look at hiring one despite the added expense.
That said, experience is absolutely vital. An experienced buy-side advisor will shine through all of the aspects of the process and offer bits of advice that save thousands of dollars more than you are paying them. Just think, the best advice you’ve received in life probably came from someone with a great deal of experience.
When it comes to buying a business, the philosophy is no different.
For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.