Showing posts with label LBO. Show all posts
Showing posts with label LBO. Show all posts

Friday, December 2, 2016

What Skyrocketing Valuations Mean for Buyers and Sellers | Axial



By  | 

Skyrocketing valuations are the topic du jour both from a buyer’s and a seller’s point of view.
For buyers, whether strategic or private equity, the current high values mean having to pay up for quality assets. From the sellers’ standpoint, timing is everything as they market their companies and prepare their financials to get to a desirable price point.
At the recent Axial Concord 2015, panelists discussed the state of company valuations today and what they mean for CEOs, investors, and M&A advisors.
The ABCs of Valuations
Before examining the implications of these elevated valuations, it’s worth looking at how companies get to the magic number.
Tom Courtney, president and managing director at The Courtney Group, says people use primarily five methodologies to determine a valuation: discounted cash flow analysis, publicly traded comparable companies, comparable merger & acquisition transactions, LBO analysis, and liquidation analysis. The most used in practice is the discounted cash flow analysis, projecting and discounting future cash flows by using the weighted average cost of capital.
Although the valuation of a company is most commonly based on discounted cash flow, when buyers look at the enterprise value in a specific transaction, it is actually determined by several factors.
One of these is the rising number of participants in the bidding process. Eighteen to 24 months ago, valuations in auctions coming in for businesses had a “high-low bid range of roughly 1X,“ says Adams Price, managing director at The Forbes M+A Group. “I would see offers coming in between 5X and 6X with five, six, maybe seven participants in the auction.  But, over the last eight months, we have seen closer to 15 to 20 groups that are bidding on the companies we are representing. The range of low-bid to high-bid can be 2X to 2.5X — there are really big ranges out there.”
The defining difference between those ranges is the level of risk.  For instance, there might be a lot more risk in a company with a higher enterprise value compared to a firm with a lower one.  “It really comes down to the specific transaction and what risk apportionment you are able to accomplish,” Price says.
Fits Like a Glove
Aside from considerations that include risk, strategic fit also matters. Sam Thompson, a senior managing director at Progress Ventures, says that a company can garner a high valuation when there is a strong alignment to a product team.  “A lot of the pre-transaction planning that we’re working on is about getting into and understanding who the target market is for that ultimate exit,” says Thompson.
The end result might not be a sale, but the process is more about firms “getting on the map and making sure that a product or management team has awareness of what the product is in the market, and how it differentiates itself. More often than not, there are multiple partnerships in the marketplace and when there are multiple acquirers, companies can start to dial up the valuation number.”
Industry Multiples
Panelists also discussed multiples in various industries. It is no surprise that the technology sector was singled out for having elevated multiples.
“If you look at overall multiples across the board, they peaked out in the fourth quarter in the 7Xs, and now have backed off and gone into the 6.5Xs,” says Forbes’ Price. “They are still pretty high for multiples, but they vary greatly between industries.” He describes the technology space as “very strong” with recent multiples getting up into the double digits.  “I’m not talking about the unicorns and companies that are growing at 200%. I’m talking about good companies that have consistent and high quality earnings, consistent growth over an extended period of time, and strong customer relationships with low churn.”  
Price says even private equity firms would sometimes allow their return rates to drop down into the single digits to be able to win these auctions. “That’s an example of an area that is very robust if not frothy.”
Thompson agreed that technology companies will likely see some of the higher multiples, particularly those that have Software as a Service (SaaS) platforms. “A lot of the companies that we’ve seen in the marketing technology services side, for instance, are looking at how they can switch over into a SaaS software platform to get themselves into a higher multiple range,” he says. However, it can be hard for firms to drive their multiples higher in the crowded technology marketplace. “Momentum is a big factor when it comes to multiples. Businesses we’ve been working with a flat growth trajectory find it hard to get the multiples up higher even if they are a fairly profitable business. Buyers want to see that there’s a hungry customer base that wants more of this technology and platform.”
Performance in the public market can drive valuations upward. “Publicly traded companies can use their stock as a currency,” Courtney says. “So there’s a big difference if a company trades for 10X or 30X earnings.”
Aside from industry differences, in this case, size also matters. For instance, companies with over $10 million of EBITDA are seeing higher multiples than those with less. “That’s the concept of EBITDA arbitrage,” says Forbes’ Price. “There are bands of EBITDA and as a company works its way up, the multiples go up as well. I’ve seen many private equity groups that rationalize it in their minds that they can use the arbitrage to get paid up on the backend. “
Efficient Capital
Supply and demand factors are key to how high valuations are going to be. “What it comes down to, more than anything, is supply and demand of capital in the market versus those companies that are available to invest in,” Price says. He cites the large amount of cash reserves on corporate balance sheets both domestically and internationally as well as the historically high private equity overhang. “There’s just a tremendous amount of money available in the marketplace and banks are also extremely aggressive right now in deploying money.”
Capital is deployed in an increasingly orderly fashion so that how much investors get back can be considered independently from valuations. “There is an increasing efficiency to the capital markets in organizing different tranches of capital so each of those has a different risk profile and rate of return requirement,” Courtney says. “As capital raising becomes more and more tranched out, I think there may be an opportunity to have investment coming in at lower rates of return that could yield higher multiples overall. In a sense, this would be getting closer to the efficient frontier of the capital markets.”
Prudence is King
Despite the abundance of money and a welcoming capital market, buyers are more discerning about the targets that they seek. Unlike previous boom periods, “we are finding that it’s pretty prudent money, particularly for companies that are in the middle-market and lower middle-market. It’s really more about having a very clear vision of where the company is going, and how that dovetails with the buyer’s opportunity,“ Price says. Acquirers might use an aggressive cash flow model, “but it’s a model that they tear down several times before they invest, particularly on the private equity side. So we tell our clients to articulate a clear message of growth that’s going to warrant the multiple they are trying to get.”
In short: Buyers are looking for quality. “When you hear about those big valuations, it is for those companies that are perfect,” Price says. These firms are great performers and can also “support, in the long term, the leverage necessary to be purchased at those higher valuations.”
Article LINK
For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Friday, November 11, 2016

Solving Exit Strategy Issues to Maximize Profit | Divestopedia

By , 
See Yazi's profile in our advisor directory.
Takeaway: Use these considerations and strategies as a "starter kit" toward higher profits when deciding to sell your business.
Solving Exit Strategy Issues to Maximize Profit
Source: Orla/Dreamstime.com
Many business owners experience various issues during the course of operating their business and decide to sell rather than continue on. The problem with this is most owners haven't taken the time to develop a feasible exit strategy. There are many options to developing a profitable exit strategy, but they all start with knowing what the financial state of your business is right now. This is important because you will need to use your financial records as part of your negotiating strategy and to determine what you could use as leverage.

Deciding If Selling Is the Right Option

Most owners fear that their business has too many problems to sell it. As a result, they rarely come up with good solutions or options to successfully exit out of the business. Some of the major problems that businesses face include: too much debt, high frequency of cash shortages; weak management team; and/or outdated assets.
However, does the business owner actually want to sell or is it that he/she'd rather just be profitable? Business owners want out of their business for several reasons, but to sell the business because it's not profitable may not be what the owner actually wants. The better solution would be to make the business profitable by implementing a great exit strategy.

Solutions to Common Issues Found Prior to Selling

One of the major areas that prevent business owners from addressing typical problems in their business is not knowing where they stand. The best way to determine this is to a) maintain current updated financial records and b) determine the value of your business.

Business Debt

Most buyers and accountants will evaluate your debt ratio and use it to determine how much of your assets are available to pay down the debt. To that end, business owners should have an understanding of their overall debt ratio and the debt-to-income ratio, which lets buyers know how much your monthly debt payments are. This number is then divided by your gross monthly income. It typically allows bankers and others key professionals to measure what your ability is to pay your bills on a monthly basis, including any outstanding loans that you may have. If the business is sold to a buyer and the debt is not paid down, he/she will consider the debt-to-income ratio when coming up with an offer price.

Business Valuation

Apart from having updated financial records that reflect your business’ current financial state, you also need to know what your business is worth. This is usually done through a process called a business valuation. It places an economic value on the business that reflects its current position as well as its future value. Most buyers will not even consider purchasing a business until they know what it is worth now and what it will be worth in the foreseeable future. Buyers will use this information to determine an offer price.
The following areas can be used as leverage when determining what price to sell your business for.
  • Physical assets (inventory and operating equipment)
  • Accounts receivables
  • Patents, copyrights and intellectual property
  • Improvements to various software systems, old equipment and other areas that improve operations
  • Outstanding management team
  • Established strategic alliances and JV partnerships

But First, Exit Strategy

Exit Planning Team

To come up with a well-thought-out exit strategy, form an exit planning team that is experienced with structuring deals, particularly deals that involve exit strategies for business owners that will prove to be mutually beneficial for all parties involved. The exit plan should include increasing the overall net worth of the business, among other factors.

Bringing on an Investor

Rather than selling the business outright, you could consider bringing on an investor who could take on part ownership to help get it to a profitable, healthy state. Typically, investors not only bring investment dollars, but they also bring expertise to the table. They work with others who are capable of improving the performance of the business.

Buyout

You could also offer a buyout as part of the exit strategy. What this means is that you could bring an investor on board for a certain period of time and, after the business is functioning at its maximum performance and is profitable, you could buy the investor out. This could be done by providing him/her with his/her initial principal investment, plus his/her ROI of 3 to 5% above prime, plus an additional flat amount for his/her efforts, such as 20% of the previous year’s profits. As an alternative, you could even make the investor a partner where he/she’d have part ownership in the business, offer a monthly salary, then offer to repay the initial investment, plus ROI after the business has been profitable for 3 to 5 years. This strategy allows you to keep the business (if that's what you want), while improving its performance with the assistance of the investor. However, if you are set on selling the business, you’ll have to work hard to highlight its previous financial performance and the future profitability of the business - also highlighting its worth.

Final Thought

There is no denying that selling your business is one of the most important decisions you have to make in your life. It is very essential you carefully consider and examine everything. Make sure that you are ready and well-prepared for any prospect that might come knocking on your door at any time. Try to spot problems facing your business and work back from there. The considerations and strategies described above should be a "starter kit" for you to walk in the right path toward higher profits. 

Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com.

Friday, November 4, 2016

What Type of Buyer Will Buy Your Business | Divestopedia

By ,  
Who Will Pay More for My Company - A Strategic or Financial Buyer?
Source: Denisismagilov/Dreamstime.com

What Will a Strategic Buyer Pay?

What is a valuation premium and who would pay one? By definition, a valuation premium is the amount paid that is higher than the average price. But if the market will ultimately determine the price, where do you start?

You start with the notional value. A notional value determination is one in absence of an open market transaction which is, in other words, the intrinsic or stand-alone value. The notional value of an enterprise does not include what a strategic acquirer can bring to the operations (i.e. with a distribution network or sales force). The notional value is determined through an extensive analysis of the company’s financial performance and market opportunities typically by applying a discounted cash flow (DCF) analysis and/or a public company market trading and acquisition comparable analysis.
The notional enterprise value is driven by earnings and earnings potential and the risk associated with generating those earnings. Earnings may be generated by levered or unlevered assets. Enterprise value consists of term debt and equity (assuming a normal level of working capital), so if there is debt in the company, it must be subtracted from enterprise value to get to equity value, which is the net amount a seller can expect to receive.
A premium is the amount a buyer will pay, over and above the notional value. However, the way that the purchaser itself is being valued is also a factor in this equation. Let me explain. Only in rare cases will a buyer pay a price that is dilutive to the acquiring company’s forecast earnings. An example of one of these rare, dilutive cases would be the acquisition of a technology. In this example, a patent may be acquired that doesn’t generate any direct revenues or is owned by a company that is presently losing money, but, ultimately, the company and patent are expected to be very profitable in the future. In cases like this, it may make sense to accept short-term dilution to earnings (i.e. an investment in future earnings) from an acquisition in anticipation of a large improvement in future combined earnings once the patent yields the expected profits.
Aside from rare dilutive examples, the norm, however, is that an acquisition needs to be accretive to the purchaser’s earnings. An example of an accretive acquisition is best illustrated by analyzing a publicly traded company. Let's say Company A trades at 12 times TTM EBITDA of $10M (i.e. an enterprise value of $120M) and the target is purchased at 7 times EBITDA of $1M (a price of $7M). The go forward enterprise now generates $11M (excluding synergies) and with a multiple of 12 (assuming the market likes the acquisition and views the pro-forma combined company as having similar prospects), the enterprise value is now $132M.
While the example is simplistic, the concept that I want to highlight is this: what if the notional value of this company is $5M? Perhaps during a divestiture process there would have been several expressions of interest at $5M, but the winning bidder had to pay more. Company A could have paid $10M (10 times EBITDA - as it trades at 12 times EBITDA) and it would still have been accretive. How much of a premium should Company A pay? This is the technical dance; the grey area between the intrinsic value and the value to a buyer.
So what will a strategic buyer pay? They will pay somewhere between the notional value and the value to the buyer. Creating a competitive bidding environment can persuade the winning buyer to pay more than the notional value and share some of the value to the buyer with the seller.

What Will a Financial Buyer Pay?

Now that we have examined the logic that drives a strategic buyer, what logic drives a financial buyer?

First of all, what is a financial buyer? A financial buyer is one who is buying strictly for a financial return. Financial buyers include individual investors, who have either saved up or cashed out; institutional funds such as venture capital funds for early stage high growth opportunities; and private equity funds, which come in many varieties including leveraged buyout, growth capital, distressed and mezzanine funds. There are more than 40,000 private equity funds in North America ranging from individuals to multi-billion dollar funds such as BlackRock, Onex, Kohlberg and Kravis Roberts.
How does a financial buyer compete in a world with well capitalized strategic buyers? Two ways: leverage and portfolio tuck-in acquisitions.
If cheap credit is readily available (i.e. leverage), then financial buyers can be very competitive. Here is an example. Company A, a stable profitable company, generates $10M of TTM EBITDA per annum and a financial buyer is prepared to pay the notional value, let’s say it is 5 times EBITDA or $50M. In this case, assuming no growth, the financial buyer will expect an ongoing stream of EBITDA of $10M or a 20% return on capital per year.
Let’s say a strategic buyer is willing to pay 6 times EBITDA or $60M.... how does the financial buyer compete? In a word... leverage. By using 50% debt and 50% equity, the financial buyer can pay $65M and generate a similar risk-adjusted return on capital deployed. Here is how it works. The financial buyer secures $32.5M in debt financing (at 3.25 times EBITDA this will likely include subordinated term debt, or "sub-debt," as well as secured bank operating and capital loans) at a combined rate of 8% per annum. Now the company earns $7.4M after debt interest payments and the net capital (equity) used is only $32.5M, so the return on equity is now 22.8%, on a risk-adjusted basis close to the 20% originally targeted (one could argue that a higher risk adjusted return is required but the point is made). How did this come about? Secured debt is a cheaper (and tax deductible) form of capital than equity and adding debt to a capital structure, while it increases the risk, concentrates the return on equity and can improve equity value.
Another way a financial buyer can compete with a strategic buyer is to look for tuck-in acquisitions. Financial buyers typically look for opportunities where they can make additional acquisitions in the space to grow a platform company to a meaningful market position and enhance value by building a larger, stronger competitor. The financial buyer’s first acquisition in a sector will be for a target financial return, but with the foresight that subsequent acquisitions will build incremental value. In this case, a financial buyer becomes a strategic buyer. I said earlier that financial buyers buy strictly for a financial return, but in many cases financial buyers envision growth strategies that make them quasi strategic buyers.

So, Who Will Pay More?

Will a strategic buyer or a financial buyer pay more? I can think of examples where both financial buyers and strategic buyers have paid seemingly exorbitant sums for companies (for example, Goldman Sachs buying into Facebook at a $50 billion valuation - over 30 times run-rate revenues - and HP buying 3PAR for 11 times revenues), but if I were to look at the average transaction, I would say a strategic buyer generally pays more.

Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com.