Showing posts with label business attorney. Show all posts
Showing posts with label business attorney. Show all posts

Friday, April 21, 2017

Three Rules for Involving Attorneys in a Small Business Sale

Eric J. Gall | April 21, 2017

As most people know, attorneys can be your best friend or worst nightmare in small business.  It all depends on how and when they are used.  Below are my three rules for involving attorneys in a business transaction (in Florida):

When working in the Corporate world, it is quite common for two companies to work a deal on paper and then hand it over to Corporate Counsel to tie up all the loose ends.  In the small business world, attorney involvement is completely different.

Corporate Counsel doesn't exist in small business.  Legal expense is not a budgeted item.  Small business owners' experiences with attorneys are often unpleasant, for example, initiating or defending a lawsuit.  When it comes to a business purchase and sale, small business owners prefer to do the deal businessman-to-businessman and keep the attorneys on the sidelines.  I both agree and disagree with this approach.

I agree all Purchase and Sale Agreements should be first negotiated businessman-to-businessman with the intermediaries (either a transaction business broker or both buy and sell-side business brokers) in-between to diffuse emotion, help answer sensitive questions, and solve problems.  My experience has been eighty percent of the time when a buyer enters a negotiation to purchase a business with their attorney drafting the initial agreement, the deal fails.  And even if it succeeds, half the time the deal winds up in litigation after the sale.  Attorneys are paid to over protect their clients.  When a buyer's attorney drafts the Purchase and Sale Agreement it is generally very one-sided.  It immediately breaks trust and creates an adversarial relationship between the buyer and the seller.  Small business deals get done when the buyer and seller like and trust one another.  Break the initial trust and the deal is likely done or poisoned leading to post sale problems.

Intermediaries generally start with a neutral document (I use the Business Brokers of Florida Standard Asset Purchase Agreement) designed to equally protect the buyer and seller.  If two intermediaries are involved, the buy-side intermediary puts together the initial offer.  A neutral document will highlight where protections above and beyond the norm have been added allowing for easy review by the seller and their counsel.  When protections are clear, an open and honest negotiation can proceed.  When buy-side attorneys write the agreement, protections are often hidden or baked into the "legalese;" thus creating mistrust.

Rule #1:  Have your intermediary write up the initial Purchase and Sale Agreement.  

As an intermediary can help solve problems between buyer and seller, a third-party closing attorney will help solve problems between the buyer's and seller's attorneys.  I always recommend the buyer and seller select a third-party closing attorney to handle escrow, draft the closing documents, and execute the closing.  Of course, I provide recommendations based on location and expense.  Third-party attorneys do a great job in keeping the buyer's and seller's attorneys from creating unnecessary turf wars with their resultant legal expenses.  I've seen buyer and seller attorney bills greater than $25K per side when buyer and seller refused to use a third-party closing attorney.  I've seldom seen buyer and seller attorney bills over $2K when a third-party closing attorney is involved from the initial placement of escrow.

Rule #2:  Agree on a third-party closing attorney.

Where I disagree with this approach is I always recommend small business sellers and buyers to have an experienced business transaction attorney review all contracts.  This includes the Purchase and Sale Agreement, the closing documents and any contracts that are to be transferred as part of the sale.  In Florida, buyer and seller have five business days after the signing of a Purchase and Sale Agreement to have their independent counsel review the agreement and request changes.  I have found attorneys seldom drive changes to the document that will break trust and kill a deal after the buyer and seller have initially agreed in principle to the transaction.

Rule #3:  Use attorneys to review all contracts associated with the purchase and sale of a business. 

This by no means constitutes legal advice and as stated using independent counsel to review all documents associated with a business purchase and sale is always recommended.

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com.

To search for Florida Businesses for Sale: CLICK HERE

Wednesday, July 27, 2016

When To Form An LLC (Limited Liability Company) | Forbes


This photo taken Friday, June 12, 2015, shows a Diebold stock certificate in the name of Elliot Ness, in Fort Lauderdale, Fla. Eliot Ness, the famed Prohibition agent who led the “Untouchables” in their crusade against Chicago gangster Al Capone’s liquor bootlegging rackets, later became the top executive at bank services company Diebold Inc. Part of his compensation appears to have been company stock that recently surfaced in Florida, sparking a new legal fight between the company and the Ness estate. (AP Photo/Alan Diaz)
Forming a corporation is a big step in a company’s journey. But it’s also a confusing one. After all, there are a variety of options available, such as an LLC (Limited Liability Company), S-Corporation and C-Corporation.
Yet for early-stage companies, the LLC is generally the most popular. Why is this so?
Well, let’s take a look:
Less Paperwork and Procedures: Hey, running a business is time-consuming. If anything, a key reason for why the LLC was formed – which happened during the 1970s – was to make the process less onerous. Keep in mind that for most states you just need to pay a fee, file the articles of organization (which is fairly easy to do and often is done online) and perhaps make annual filings (which are also fairly straightforward).
Now this does not mean you should run your LLC with minimal effort! It’s advisable to put together an operating agreement (especially if you have partners). This sets forth the governance of the LLC, such as with voting, allocation of profits/losses, compensation, authorizations and so on. An operating agreement can be an effective way to allow for stronger management.
Something else:  It’s a good idea to, at a minimum, have an attorney review your documents.
Taxes: By default, an LLC is treated as a “pass through entity” — that is, the profits and losses go directly to the owners. For a single-member LLC, this means that preparing a tax return is usually easy. You’ll need to file a Schedule SE for self-employment taxes and also a Schedule C to detail the revenues and deductions.
As for a multi-member LLC, things get more complicated. For example, you will need to file a partnership return (called a 1065) and K-1’s for each member (this shows the allocations of profits, losses and credits).
Regardless, the pass-through feature means that you may be able to deduct losses against other income, which can be a nice benefit. Oh, and if this is not as important, the LLC allows you to elect to be taxed as a C-Corporation or an S-Corporation. In other words, it’s a good idea to compare the different methods to see which provides the maximum tax benefits.
Limited Liability: This is perhaps the biggest attraction of an LLC (keep in mind that you get limited liability protection from a C-Corp and S-Corp too). This means that you can generally protect your personal assets if there is litigation or bankruptcy of your company.
Granted, this is not absolute. If you are grossly negligent, engage in a fraud or commit a crime, then you will likely not get limited liability protection. This is also likely to be the case with signing a lease or getting a loan from a bank (alas, you will probably have to sign a personal guarantee).
But for the most part, limited liability protection is very powerful. Let’s face it, early-stage businesses are very risky.
Estate Planning: An LLC can be placed in a living trust, which can provide for tax benefits and better estate planning. But of course, this is a highly complicated topic and really needs the help of a qualified attorney.
The Drawbacks? No entity is perfect. And yes, the LLC is not ideal for all businesses. Actually, one of the biggest disadvantages is that it is not particularly good for raising money, especially from VCs. It is tough to structure protections in stock (such as priorities with dividends and liquidations), the governnenance tends to be too flexible (there is no board of directors) and even the pass-through tax feature can be a problem (the reason is that VCs may have tax-exempt investors). So if you intend on raising substantial amounts of money, you probably should instead look at the C-Corp. For the most part, the LLC will likely just make things too complicated and may even scare away potential investors.
Tom Taulli, a JD and Enrolled Agent, has written a variety of books for entrepreneurs, such as the Launching Your LLC: A Super-Easy Guide.
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Sunday, January 31, 2016

Thinking About Selling Your Company? Here Are 5 Things You Need and 1 Thing You Don't (Surprisingly) | Huffington Post


 01/28/2016 02:22 pm ET | Updated 19 hours ago
  • Dave BookbinderValuation Expert, Proactive Problem Solver, Go-Giver, Collaborator, Connector, Hockey Fan

2016-01-18-1453128692-4030420-Depositphotos_62003893_m2015.jpg
"I'm thinking about selling my company - I need a valuation."
That's how many conversations begin. I had one again recently. It was in a conference room with the president of a privately-held company. The business was growing quickly, and was very profitable. They had been approached by competitors in the past but the timing wasn't right.
Until now.
The business had reached a level of sustained success that it was time to maximize the valuation for the shareholders.
"How much will it cost and when can you start?"
That's pretty much how it began in that conference room as we were still putting the creamers in the coffee. This guy was eager to become a client.
But this is not a story about a new client win. This is a story about doing the right thing - and that means trying to help and add value; not sell a service that may be had for free down the road. And that's why...
You Probably Don't Need A Valuation
There are many circumstances where a valuation in conjunction with a sale of a company makes perfectly good sense, but if it's really about selling for the highest valuation, that's probably not one of them.
Many business owners aren't aware that selling a company is a 12-24 month process. Emphasis on 'process.' They typically want to know "what is my business worth?" but there's way more to do than just determine an asking price.
People want what people want and this person really wanted a valuation. I've heard this request many times over the course of my career, but the reality is that very few people who are seriously thinking of selling their business need an independent opinion of value only. The valuation is only one piece of the puzzle.
2015-12-31-1451568559-8220914-9685735puzzleintheformofcurrencyoftheusaofdollarincosthundred.jpg
Assuming that there is no one to succeed the current leadership team and the employees are not interested in, or able to purchase the company via an Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP), that means the buyer will be an 'outsider.' Someone who doesn't understand the corporate culture or know the details behind the financial performance. You've got a lot of educating to do.
If there is no real deal experience among the team, a valuation-only won't be enough ammunition to use against the skilled negotiators of sophisticated strategic and financial buyers.
It's one thing to know the value of the business; but it's another thing altogether to realize that value. That's what we're talking about here. And even if you 'get your asking price' the details of the deal structure can make all the difference in the world as to whether you actually receive those proceeds, and in the amount and time frame that you expected.
So how did I handle this potential client's demand for a valuation? The same way I've handled every other such request - with the preceding conversation and the following advice and introductions.
1. Hire an Investment Banking Firm. (Or business broker, depending on the size of the company) As a former investment banker, I learned first-hand the power of the auction process. A valuation analysis can provide very reasoned and supported conclusions of value, but until a potential buyer receives the confidential information memorandum (prospectus) on your behalf, they won't take you seriously. And when they do receive that document, they also know that others have as well. Perhaps their competitors.
2015-12-31-1451569063-6238746-SilentAuctione1425572230953.jpg
If they want to buy the company, or keep it out of the hands of a competitor, they might just pay more than the valuation would suggest. And who doesn't love a bidding war?
Oh, by the way, most intermediaries will provide you with a valuation analysis as a part of the sale mandate. Yes, the intermediary will charge a success fee when they sell the company, but they will guide you through the minefields of management presentations to maximize the sale price and earn that fee.
The key, of course, is to work with an intermediary that is more concerned about your success than their success fee.
2015-12-31-1451568717-7484228-Negotiating.jpg
2. Consider an Accounting Upgrade.Many privately-held companies are working with friends and family who act as part-time bookkeepers. Some are using small accounting firms and maybe they're having a review done. They probably aren't doing an audit. Yet.
Getting the financial house in order is an important step in the process because if buyers can trust the numbers you're providing them, you can spend less time 'explaining' them or 'normalizing' them.
3. Get an Attorney on Board. Not your brother-in-law, the personal injury guy. A deal attorney. Properly documenting the agreed-upon terms and conditions is as important as negotiating those points in the first place.
2015-12-31-1451569316-3337418-Investmentadviserpic1030x579.jpg
4. Bring in the Investment Adviser. One that acts as your fiduciary with your interests in mind. When you sell the company, you need to decide what's next for you. For some, it's retirement and travel. But most of the business owners that I've met say that the biggest reason that they don't want to sell is because they don't know what to do next.
An investment adviser will work with you to understand your goals and circumstances to help ensure that the proceeds of the sale of the company will not only benefit you, but those for whom you've worked so hard and sacrificed.

5. Choose A Quarterback
It's great to have all of these resources available to help you, but unless they are all talking to one another, the ball is likely to get dropped somewhere. That's why you need a quarterback to coordinate all of these efforts. I can't emphasize this need enough - it is imperative that all of your advisers know what the others are doing so that you can get the best possible outcome.
In Conclusion
There are many times when an independent valuation of your business is a valuable strategic tool. It can be much more than a compliance exercise if you're working with the right partner. But if you're ready to sell, you might just need the help of other experts.
Like I said earlier, this is not a story about a new client win. This is a story about doing the right thing.
Every time.
Article LINK
For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.