Showing posts with label Strategic Acquirer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Strategic Acquirer. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 14, 2017

7 Fundamentals to Due Diligence You Need to Know | Divestopedia

By  , 
Takeaway: Being open about your business practices and financial statements can lead to a better takeaway for both the buyer and seller.
7 Fundamentals to Due Diligence You Need to Know
Source: Info40555/Dreamstime.com
According to Bizbuysell.com, there were a total of 1,840 businesses transactions that took place worldwide during the first quarter of 2016. Businesses were either bought and sold or mergers and acquisitions took place in that first quarter. People buy and sell or merge businesses for different reasons, but whatever the reasons, there are always a wide variety of preliminary activities that must take place prior to closing the deal. In almost all cases, an attorney who is fluent in due diligence for mergers and acquisitions is required to ensure that the transaction takes place based on the laws that have been put into place by FINRA or other regulatory agencies.

1. Historic and Projected Financial Information

Historic Information

The seller should be providing financial documents for the past three years. The buyer will need to perform due diligence concerning the company’s historical financial information and supporting documentation.
The seller will need to provide documents for the buyer to perform an assessment of the company’s financial statements so they can make note of any financial trends, spikes or decreases in sales and revenue, consistencies or inconsistencies in cash flow activity, the company’s current debt, receivables and other assets, as well as all other aspects of the company's financial performance.

Projected Information

In addition to performing due diligence on the historical financial information, the buyer will also need to perform due diligence on any future financial activity as well. Carefully checking to ensure reasonable financial projections of the company’s future performance were made. Some of those areas involve whether or not the projections are based on reasonable assumptions whereby a clear path to achieving those results is laid out and linked to the actual financial activity in a practical, succinct manner.
  • Is the projected financial information sound and believable?
  • Were the documents succinct?
  • How much working capital is necessary to continue running the business beyond its current state?
  • Are there additional capital expenditures or other required investments that need to take place to ensure the future growth of the business?

2. Technology Developments and Intellectual Property

The seller will need to provide the buyer's attorney with information about any current or pending intellectual property, technology developments, copyright and patent ownerships that the company may have.
If the company has patent applications and potential trademarks, the buyer should ensure that the appropriate registration has taken place. When materials are used in marketing or technological advances, the company must have the rights and control the copyright, or risk lawsuits. If they haven't, it could be a risk for the buyer who will take on any liability based on prior violations.
Trade secrets are vital to the success of some companies, so as the seller, you'll need to ensure that the secrets have been preserved appropriately and other companies' secrets have not been infringed by your company and be able to prove that to the buyer.

3. Customers and Revenue Streams

Before purchase, the seller will have to detail the various revenue streams of the business. This includes the company's satisfied customers, and what they purchase. The buyer should have a grasp of who the customers are as well as how revenue is generated by these customers especially the top 20 percent who will account for much of the business.
Another consideration is the satisfaction of the customers after a change in ownership. Are there going to be problems with new ownership that will impact the business' revenue going forward?
Along with evaluating customer loyalty and spending habits, the seller will be giving the buyer information about the backlog of issues. Are there warranty problems that are not being handled properly? Do there seem to be a high level of exchanges and refunds being issued? The seller should already have this information and be able to tell the buyer why there were problems.

4. Contract Agreements and Insurance

A review of all pending and active contracts and agreements should be a part of the due diligence process as well as a review of insurance coverage.
The key areas include some of the following:
  • Outstanding loans, personal guarantors, and note payables
  • Outstanding customer and vendor contracts
  • Partnerships, joint venture, or operating agreements
  • Outstanding or pending Settlement agreements
  • Equipment or vehicle lease agreements
  • Independent contractor and Employment agreements
  • General liability and Worker’s compensation insurance
  • D&O / E&O and Key man insurance
  • Intellectual property insurance
  • Vehicle insurance
  • Health insurance
  • Umbrella policies

5. Staff and Key Management

The buyer will need to perform diligence activity for all staff, independent contractors, and key management. This should include looking into scheduled pay raises, equity shares, profit distributions, 401(k), commissions, bonuses and other employment related issues. This means the seller will need to have opened their human resource files and be willing to have a buyer comb through the documents.
Along with the functionality of the human resources department regarding compensation, there should be a detailed audit of the history of labor disputes. If there's even been a threat to stop working for any reason, that could be a red flag, but the buyer will need to look into the issues that caused the employees to be disgruntled.

6. Legal and Compliance

One of the biggest headaches for a buyer can be legal tangles, which include any current, pending or settled litigation, arbitration or other proceedings. Any compliance- or regulation-related issues can be a problem, too. This is where the buyer's attorney should be forecasting the result of the litigation as well as investigating claims and threats against the company. The seller can help by being as forthcoming as possible and talking to their own attorneys about the legal future of any claims.
With detailed due diligence procedures for acquisitions, a seller can avoid serious legal problems in the future by looking at the prior, current, and future potential for legal threats. There might even be matters in arbitration at the moment that could resolve into a problem for the new owner. In some cases, a buyer might come back and sue a seller for fraud if they weren't forthcoming with information regarding fraud.

7. Tax Issues

It’s important to perform a tax due diligence to determine whether the company has any tax liability issues. This process should include a review of tax returns that have been filed within the past five years including the federal, state, and local returns. The buyer's accountants and attorneys should be checking for net operating losses. Credit carryovers should be investigated to ensure that the change in ownership won't impact the relationship with the creditor.
If there have been agreements, waivers or tax communications with the IRS, the new buyer should understand exactly what that means for acquiring the business. If there have been settlement agreements with the IRS or other agencies, the seller will want to let the buyer know that those will not impact the new ownership negatively, and might not carry over to the new buyer.

Final Words

Due diligence in merger and acquisitions requires that a substantial amount of activities take place from both sides prior to making a full commitment to the transaction. It’s a means for the buyer to do some fact-checking, so that he or she is fully aware of what is actually being purchased. By carefully planning these and other related activities for the due diligence in mergers and acquisitions process, the buyer will feel confident in his decision and will be prepared to proceed with the purchase of the business. The seller will be able to say that they provided all the information the buyer needed to make a sound decision.

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com.

Sunday, November 6, 2016

Acquisition Growth Strategies for Middle Market Companies | Divestopedia

By  , 
Acquisition Growth Strategies for Middle Market Companies
Source: Ximagination/Dreamstime.com
In this podcast, John Bly, author of "Cracking the Code: An Entrepreneur’s Guide to Growing Your Business Through Mergers and Acquisitions for Pennies on the Dollar," talks about:
  • The benefits of acquiring an existing company versus starting a business;
  • Biggest challenges encountered with acquisition integration;
  • Strategies when negotiating the purchase price in an M&A transaction;
  • Role of advisors during the acquisition process;
  • What is currently evolving in the M&A marketplace;
  • Important takeaways for owners that are thinking about exiting; and
  • His best advice to successfully execute an acquisition.

About the Guest

John Bly is the co-managing member of LBA Haynes Strand, PLLC, located in the Charlotte area. John’s entrepreneurial guidance as co-managing member has propelled the firm to rapid growth. He utilizes M&A to drive development—in nine years, LBA has grown from $0 to more than $4 million, through a series of eight acquisitions and two mergers. John is also seen by his peers as an expert on the topic and consults on 20 to 30 M&A transactions a year.
John's book serves as a guide to effectively find good deals for entrepreneurial businesses in the $1 to $30 million range. It provides a blueprint for how to tackle issues, such as determining whether it’s a good fit, due diligence, structuring the deal, valuation, tax issues and how to land the perfect catch.

Listen Here:

You can also get this Podcast by:

Read the Full Transcript Here:

Noah Rosenfarb: Hello everyone and welcome. It’s your host, Noah Rosenfarb, from Freedom Business Advisors here with John Bly. He’s the author of "Cracking the Code: An Entrepreneur’s Guide to Growing Your Business Through Mergers and Acquisitions for Pennies On The Dollar." John, thanks so much for joining us today.
John Bly: Noah, looking forward to it. Thanks for having me and hopefully, can help your listeners with a few different ideas.
Noah Rosenfarb: Yes. You’re a CPA. We’re brethren in that respect. How did you get interested in cracking the code?
John Bly: Good question. It really started about 11 years ago just thinking about how growing a professional service firm was a struggle organically and so got really excited about growing it inorganically and so now in the last 11 years have done 11 acquisitions on the CPA side and have done three as of last week on the fitness business side, so I have two different core businesses and have done 14 acquisitions in the last 11 years, and also have done a bunch of exits. We’ve sold four divisions of our company over that period and so over that period, just getting really excited about helping entrepreneurs think about both buy side and sell side and adding value so that when they decide they want to get out, they have the right formula, the right buy out, and the right structure. That’s really how I got passionate about it.
Noah Rosenfarb: Perhaps it might be unfair to call an addiction to acquisition. What keeps you in this process of continuing to buy companies instead of grow organically or in addition to, I should say’?
John Bly: Well, it’s funny. I haven’t heard it called an addiction but I have heard people call me a junkie, so I don’t know. I think the thing that excites about acquiring as a strategy is it helps people grow faster. A lot of people are looking to grow and they look at hiring another sales person, starting a new niche area, opening a new market, different city. They look at those as exit strategies but really there are studies out there on starting new businesses are 80+% fail in five years but 90% of all businesses purchased in the US according to banking studies are still in business five years later.
Those two dynamics are radically different and so it’s a way that entrepreneurs can grow their company faster with less risk, in my opinion, and at the same time, the benefits of growing company for those people who have a company that has grown is it allows them to really focus on what they are really good at because as an entrepreneur when you’re a small company, you have to do 10 or 15 different things of which you may be passionate or good at three or four of those, and so when you’re a small company, you have to do that. If you can accelerate it and get bigger faster rather than organically at 5, 10, 20% a year, you can get there faster and do just the stuff you really love.
Noah Rosenfarb: What about appraising? I know people they say, “Well, it’s just cheaper for me to build it. I’m not going to buy it. I’ve already got my infrastructure and everybody wants crazy prices.” What do you have to say to them?
John Bly: It’s a great argument. I hear it all the time. I guess my argument to that is, “Okay, if you’re going to grow it organically, you’re going to go higher.” Let’s say $100,000 sales person just for easy math and you’re going to grow by hiring that next sales person and you’re going to invest $100,000 with them in the first year and if you’re lucky, they might generate $200,000 in the first year, maybe they will do really well and they will generate $300,000 or $400,000. What I would say is that with that same $100,000 investment in my experience, you could purchase a business between, well, it depends on the business but you could purchase a business between $700,000 and $1 million.
Now, if somebody bought a business that they paid $700,000 for as the down payment in bank financing and that sort of thing, that $100,000 instantly turns into between $200,000 and $300,000 a cash flow the first year. If you buy a business for $700,000, they are generating likely $200,000 a profit. If you’re going to invest $100,000, that’s not a bad return. Never mind the future growth of it. For me, it’s a trade off. It’s an alternative growth strategy.
Noah Rosenfarb: Tell me how you get to pennies on the dollar in the title of your book. Obviously you’re saying, “I’m going to buy a $700,000 business on my own. We’re going to use $100,000 of my cash.” Where is the rest of the money coming from?
John Bly: Yup, in most deals that I’ve done or that I advise on, because I have advised on over 300 transactions in the last 11 years, is if it’s under $5 million, the purchase price, a significant majority of the funding comes through the banks through the Small Business Administration. The SBA lending arm of the Federal Government lends through the banks, through commercial banks throughout the US and that is where a large chunk comes from. The SBA guarantees 75% of the debt so the banks don’t have nearly as much risk which is why there is a lot of funding for acquisitions but there is not much for startups. A lot of it comes through that.
If the deal is a little bit more risky or maybe it’s too owner driven, meaning the owner was really key person to the business, then there’s probably some owner financing to it but it’s usually not a huge percentage. It could be 5, 10, 25%, 30%, somewhere in there maximum probably in the deals that I normally see under that $5 million range.
Noah Rosenfarb: So there are 300 transactions that you’ve done. How many of them were for clients of yours that were looking to grow their business versus exit their business? Just to give us some perspective.
John Bly: Yeah absolutely. It’s probably about 225 that were looking to grow and 75 that were looking to sell.
Noah Rosenfarb: Let’s take the growing companies first. You and I were talking before we got on the call here about companies growing through acquisition prior to wanting to have their own exit. Do you have some clients that are doing, talking acquisitions before they are looking to sell their own company?
John Bly: Absolutely. We’re working through one right now on the exit where about five or six years ago, they said, “Hey, we want to sell in 2015-2018, somewhere in that timeframe but the multiples for our business gets significantly larger if we get above $10 million but we think we’re going to grow too slow to get to it organically. What do you think about doing it inorganically and doing a tuck-in?” That’s exactly what they did. They bought a smaller company with about $1.5-2 million in revenue.
Because they bought it, they bought it for about four times. It’s a recurring revenue model. They bought if for about four times recurring revenue and they are turning around right now and they are getting eight times on the sale because they added it to their core business. Their core business, they raised their revenue multiple because they got to where a public company now is actually interested in buying them and that transaction is going to close next week.
Noah Rosenfarb: Congratulations. It sounds like a smart move.
John Bly: Yeah, it’s that sort of thing where when you’re a decent-sized company acquisitions can make a lot of sense. They make more sense if you already own a company. If you’re starting from scratch and acquisition makes sense still in my opinion but it’s a little bit more risky. If already own a company, though, doing an acquisition to me is much less risky than starting a new division or growing, hiring that next sales person. The stats out there show you can basically flip a coin on whether the next hire is going to be productive and you’re going to keep them long term and they are going to be engaged. It’s better than that based on government studies about the success of buying a business.
Noah Rosenfarb: What do you see is the biggest challenges for people that are integrating an acquisition into their company?
John Bly: Usually if they are not paying attention, they miss one or two thing on the front end in the really big things. One is either culture. They get so focused on the numbers through the due diligence process that they forget to pay attention to what the cultures are going to look like when they mesh and that causes problems when it comes to integration time. The other thing is integration of systems and so they think about the IT and the people and how they are physically going to integrate them until literally probably the day they close and then they think, “I didn’t spend enough time thinking about the integration process. Now I’ve got 60 days of figuring that out and now I’m behind the eight ball and I thought we’d all hit the ground running and I can’t because I didn’t think about this ahead of time.”
Noah Rosenfarb: Have you seen any of the failures amongst your client on the integration side?
John Bly: Yeah. Usually, it’s more culture on those two things because we work a lot on integration but if they are not paying attention to the culture even though we discussed it a lot, they might miss it on the culture side and what ends up happening typically in the case like that is three, six, 12 months in, one or two of the key people on the company they bought end up disappearing. We haven’t found that to be very impactful to the business except it’s a real pain for 6-12 months. As you hire a new person, find the replacement, get them up to speed, it doesn’t overall affect the deal structure. It’s just that it’s sort of a pain point for a period of time.
Noah Rosenfarb: What would you say are some of the strategies that work best when negotiating a price or a deal?
John Bly: Yeah, that’s a great one because a lot of people when somebody says, “Oh, they want too much money for the business.” That’s a very common thing and it sounds like based on your question a few questions ago about what do you say to people who say it’s too expensive, that’s what I hear most of the time is, “Oh, it’s too much.” Well, my comment repeatedly to people is, “Think about it.” There are so many things in the negotiation process. If you say $1 million is too expensive to buy this company, what if they were willing to finance it at no interest for five years?
Well, now you’re not really paying $1 million at net present value. You’re paying less than that. Well, what if they were willing to work for free for six months or what if they were willing to leave the AR, the cash, and the business? There are so many things that are negotiable that I try to advise clients, “Don’t run at the price discussion right off the bat. Think about the fact that there’s probably 20, 30, 40 different negotiating points that if they want $1 million, that seems to be something that they are really passionate about because they want to say they sold their company for $1 million.
Think about all the other things you can win on and say well, I gave you the price so let’s revisit this. I really need this back in return or I really need that back in return.” When they take that approach instead of “all or nothing” type of approach, I typically find that the deals get done a lot smoother and both sides end up winning.
Noah Rosenfarb: We have a saying. We say, “You tell me whatever price you want as long as I could set the terms. I’ll pay you whatever you want I just get to decide when.” I agree with that. It’s all in the terms and terms could be very meaningful. You mentioned a couple of terms that might be important whether it’s the owner contributing, the seller contributing labor at no cost post closing, work and capital adjustment, the actual length of time that the payments will be made, the interest rate on the payments, and the other big term conditions that you’ve seen that have been very influential in getting a deal closed.
John Bly: Yeah, there are some others. Some are terms of non-competes and non-solicitations. They are extending those or shortening them depending on which side you’re representing and how the deal is structured. Another is a lot of times, and you probably see this as well in small businesses, many entrepreneurs decide to buy their own commercial real estate and so they are occupied. Their business runs out of a piece of property they own and sometimes that goes in the transaction and sometimes it doesn’t, and what those lease terms light might look like or what if they are going to lease them, can I lease it for three years from the seller and have an option at today’s price to buy it in three years rather than at some inflated price? A lot of times, that’s a negotiating tool because maybe they can’t come up with enough down payment to buy it but they really want the real estate. Those sorts of things tend to move the needle a decent portion.
Another one besides just the length of time you pay the person over is the interest rate. I mean, there’s a big difference between if you’re going to pay the owner some over time at 8% versus 4% and 0%. Those are significantly different payment terms and then the last one would be just sort of how long the seller stays with the business. Sometimes, I have had clients who want to sell the estate for a long time and sometimes I have clients who want them to disappear day one. They don’t want them to ever show up. Those are all bearing terms that you’re sort of playing with both side’s egos as you work through the transaction.
Noah Rosenfarb: What is the biggest challenge you’ve seen in getting a deal closed that still ended up closing?
John Bly: Let’s see. That’s a tough one. I would say I’ve seen so many where they should have closed that fell apart because somebody’s ego got in the way. Sometimes what I’ve seen when deals fall apart is really emotional and it’s usually falling apart because of emotions. It’s rare that I see somebody work through something really challenging and still get the deal done. The only time I would say I’ve seen that is a transaction about two years ago and the seller really wanted a certain price. It was a little bit higher than the buyer should have paid and they worked through terms for months.
It was probably 3-4 months going back and forth, back and forth. What they ended up settling on was because the seller was really adamant about the price and what they ended up settling on was, “Okay, we’ll agree to a minimum price" which is not quite, it’s probably 80% of what the seller wanted but if these earn out terms are hit, which they were challenging but not impossible and they said, “Instead of what your offer is, we’ll give you 20% more on the upside.” So the buyers sort of covered their minimum floor that they are willing to pay and they were willing to give upside if certain benchmarks were hit, but that took a long time to work through because both sides were sort of adamant about their own positions.
Noah Rosenfarb: How do you see the role of an accountant in an acquisition for an accounting firm client? Maybe you can walk me through what does firm do and perhaps that might differ from the industry average?
John Bly: Sure. I think a lot of firms are really focused on due diligence and what specifically on due diligence they are focused on two things, one is the actual process of financial due diligence, which is okay, let’s look at financials and make sure they tie to tax returns. The second thing is let’s look at tax structure of the deal. They talk about what does that look like? Is it going to be asset sale, a stock sale? What are we going to do for purchase price allocation? That’s typically where a CPA firm stops.
Now where we differ is we have a lot of discussions on the front end with clients about the strategy. So it’s a lot about strategy. "Okay, you want to sell in five years? Maybe you do and talk in now or you want to sell in 1.5 years? Here are two or three things we need to do immediately. You’re going to sell to a public company? You’re going to start to need the audited financial statements three years before you’re going to sell probably would be good and let’s start that process.” Those sorts of discussions are things that a lot of people are not having those proactive discussions.
The other is in your process, we talk a lot about integration and culture, which a lot of CPA firms just don’t focus on because they haven’t done acquisitions themselves to know what the pain points are. Because we’ve done so many at our firm ourselves where we’ve actually been the buyer, we know where the pain points can be in culture, in HR, and those sorts of things.
A few years ago, we were advising on a transaction and we didn’t get very deep into it because we recognize very quickly that there was no Obama Care issue but we didn’t recognize it because anybody has spelled it out or because there was a tax issue. This was just a sense of they were doing, this company was growing so fast and they were so profitable. The sellers were fairly young individuals that we said, “There’s got to be something else here.”
So we thought about it for a day or two and just went back to our potential buyer and said, “I think there’s an Obama Care issue. Let me just call the…” and this was right after the law was passed. It was probably six months so none of the regulations have even been written. We called the investment banker and we said, “Here is what we think the issue is. Here’s why we think they are selling. I need some sanity check on this.” The investment banker used a few choice words and then said, “I think you might be right” and they took it right off the market.
Noah Rosenfarb: Wow.
John Bly: I don’t think that the accounting firms from what we understand and from our competitors in the market aren’t necessarily doing these sorts of things.
Noah Rosenfarb: Who do you see is filling the void? I mean obviously you have created your own niche in advising companies on how to either handle a merger, an acquisition, or a divestiture. What’s your perception of the market place and who is helping the owners?
John Bly: I think there are people trying to help owners. I think it’s sometimes teams of people - it’s attorneys, it’s bankers, not just their corporate banker but investment banker and or a business broker and their attorneys. I think it’s sort of a team approach in most cases. If you don’t sort of have a team like that, that can be a problem. If you don’t have some people helping you, I’ve been on sides of the transactions many times where ate the other party for lunch, for a lack of a better term.
They were awful, they could not perform. We would laugh because we go, “Okay, we’re definitely winning this issue because the other side of the transaction does not know what the transaction is and they are going to be in a lot of trouble.” You have to have qualified advisers and when I say qualified advisers, people who actually do the deals and pay attention to what is going on in the market place because these negotiating points can shift deal to a win loss pretty quickly.
Noah Rosenfarb: I agree. How have you seen things change over the course of the last few years? What would you say are the biggest things that you see evolving as you look at the M&A market place?
John Bly: The biggest thing is the baby boomers aging out of every business, the availability of capital now compared to 2008-2011 and combined with the price. The price right now is really hot so all of that led to, and you may have had this in a previous podcast but there was some stuff that came out about six weeks ago that the first quarter of 2015 had more M&A transaction than any quarter in the prior 16 years.
Noah Rosenfarb: Wow, I didn’t see that.
John Bly: And that is going to continue to heat up. It’s projected that between now and maybe the end of 2018 that it will be the hottest M&A market probably of all time. There are lots of stats that show that about 63-70% of all businesses that are privately held are owned by baby boomers and the folks that were late baby boomers where they are significantly older now, well, they had to survive the recession of 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011 so they delayed their exit which sort of condensed this whole M&A process into a really short five-year cycle.
Noah Rosenfarb: I heard some statistics the other day that there are $550 billion in cash on private equity firm balance sheet and another $500 billion of committed capital to open funds besides whatever it is, $1 or $2 trillion of capital that they are looking to raise. In my perspective with the clients that I’m interacting with which tend to be the target market of these private equity firms, I can’t imagine a better time to sell, like you said, these next couple of years. What is your prediction for what’s going to happen afterwards?
John Bly: Yes, you’re exactly right and then we have the perfect storm coming of 2018, 2019. Somewhere in that range, everybody I have seen and I’ve been a believer of it for probably six years now, I’ve been talking about this, 2018, 2019 somewhere in there the market is going to shift drastically. I’m not a stock market predictor so I’m not making any predictions like that but in M&A space, the boomers will have significantly exited, the capital you’re describing will have been used and now it’s tied up typically for 3-7 years as they grow the business before they sell it because those types of investors are flipping them. Interest rates will have risen.
We’ve been at historic lows now for seven years and everybody projects they are going to rise significantly between now and then and so you’re not going to be able to get bank capital at the same low percentages which drives down prices because you can’t leverage it as much and then there aren’t going to be as many sellers because the baby boomers will have significantly exited and people will only be in 2, 3, 4 years of ownership, so they are not going to be selling. Between now and 2018 is the time to sell if you were to, at least in my predictions, by 2018, 2019, it will have flipped and it will stay that way for three or four years until 2022, somewhere in there.
Noah Rosenfarb: Yeah. That’s kind of my guess as well. I think Rob Slee, I don’t remember that I’ve ever had Rob on the show but Rob has a cyclical market kind of diagram going through the 60, 70, 80, 90s and first decade in 2000s showing where the markets were hot and when they were not, and we’re just repeating the same cycle. It’s pretty interesting.
John Bly: You’ve got it.
Noah Rosenfarb: Yeah. So what do you think are the most important takeaways for owners that are thinking about exiting in the next 2-5 years? What should they be thinking about?
John Bly: If they are looking to exit in the next 2-5 years, they need to be thinking more like 2 than 5. That would be my #1 recommendation. If you need to exit by 2020, you better shorten that time horizon to two years because if you’re thinking five years, there’s not going to be very many buyers, my prediction, by 2020 and the price is going to be lower. That would be #1 would be to start looking at the market now especially with all the transactions and the all the capital. Prices have risen significantly in the last two years on businesses. They are transacting for higher multiples because there’s more money and it’s lower interest rates. That would be #1.
#2 would be just to make sure your operations and financials are in really solid order because people want to buy companies that are running well and you know what happens when somebody makes an offer and they start doing due diligence, is they start chipping away at that price they are willing to pay as they find all these holes and gaps. You really want to sure up your standard operating procedures and your financials and make sure they are in good working order.
Noah Rosenfarb: I couldn’t agree more. As we look at the multiples, one of the things I tell clients that have this, you know, “I want to wait until I’m 67” mentality. I don’t want to sell when I’m 64 is I try to equate it to a stock market. If you owned Google or Apple and you could get what you say was a ridiculously high price for it today, would you rather sell it today or would you rather wait until your 67th birthday with all the unknowns. How do you interact with clients around this window of time that we have in front of us?
John Bly: It’s a great point but sometimes entrepreneurs, this is where entrepreneurs struggle is they sometimes feel if they haven’t had a failure or if they haven’t gone through a business cycle, they feel like they are invincible, and so their business is only going to get to be more valuable. When you deal with somebody which we’re advising right now on a hopeful exit, they are working through the book right now and putting out to market but this person has upside to his business but he has been through a couple of cycles in the last 20 years and has had some losses in other company startups and has also seen a family business hold on too long and lose a lot of value.
If you’re an entrepreneur, the thought is you want to sell on the way up not on the way down because if you’re selling a company when it’s growing and when it’s going up, and when there’s profit, cash flow, and all that, everybody wants to buy. When you own a company that’s going down, there aren’t as many buyers and the multiple, even if it’s the same thing even if it’s the same profit, let’s say it’s $500,000, $500,000 going up to $600,000 and $700,000 versus $500,000 going down to $400,000, the multiple could be one or two times different and it’s a big difference so you really want to be selling on the upside not the downside.
Noah Rosenfarb: We had a guest on and it’s great. I went to meet with a seller and he said, “You know Matt, things are too good. I don’t want sell.” The broker says to him, “Okay, why don’t you call me when things are bad. I’m sure we can find somebody then.” That’s great. Sometimes the owner’s perspective is they like reaping the benefits of all their hard work especially coming out of that recession and our clients are making money now. They are feeling good and they want to live in the moment and thinking it will last forever, but we all know that it doesn’t always last forever, right?
John Bly: That’s right.
Noah Rosenfarb: What else would you have as advice for an owner that’s thinking about doing an acquisition? How do you help coach them to be aggressive about either their search or being willing to pay with the high prices that people are looking for nowadays?
John Bly: Yes. One of the things on the search specifically is I tell people to realize that you’re going to have to knock on a few doors sometimes before you find the right house that fits and that means you’re going to have to share information. If you’re a member of a CEO type group like Entrepreneur’s Organization, Vistage, or YPO or something like that, you get this concept which is some sort of transparency and opening the door to show people you’re inside and as a buyer, you have to be willing to do some of that because the more transparent you are with a potential seller, the more they are going to open up the commode and share the good and the bad about their business.
You really just have to have a very open and frank and sharing discussion both ways. I find that that leads to more successful deals because they know what the holes are and they are sharing it. They are willing to work through those holes and they have a plan for fixing those holes before they acquire the business.
Noah Rosenfarb: Unfortunately, I haven’t found a great way for my client to get a pipeline to deals unless their owner writes a check each month for someone to go search for them. How have you found deals, how has your clients sourced deals? What are some of the tips and strategies you have there?
John Bly: Sure. This one I’m going to use myself as the case study because 11 years ago, I started basically at the start with Google and starting with searching for, if you’re looking for a specific industry and you Google that industry, you will find that almost every industry has experts that sell those types of companies. So you can start with something passive like that. Do fast forward and we found a couple of deals that way and we fast forward 12, 18, 24 months and we started to get our own traction around this. We started to tell every banker we knew, we started to tell every attorney we knew, if you were not me, you’d tell every CPA you knew as well, you’d tell every financial adviser.
Anybody who those core people are that served the entrepreneur business owner, you let them know that, “Hey, I’m looking to grow my business and I’m looking to do it through some acquisitions. Here’s our strategy.” If you happen to run across anybody and more times than not, you know I know a guy who is 65 years old and I don’t think he has any strategy for exit. I’ll reach out to him because people like helping other people be successful. That’s one of the weird phenomenon I’ve found over the last 11 years.
People want to see other people be successful even if there’s nothing in it for them. Sharing that idea and then we’ve also blogged about it so if you Google CPA firm merger and acquisition, terms like that, we always fall on page 1. We fall below the four, five that sell businesses in our industry but we’re on page 1 and we want to leave it that way because they read our blogs and they reach out to us.
Another thing we’ve done is we send direct mail. Now it’s up to about just under 100 competitors within about 100 miles of us. We know we’ve targeted our marketing person and administrative assistant, have targeted which CPA firms fit our category. This data is mostly public. It’s not very hard to find and in a few hours, they can target these people and that turns into opportunities every single month. We send those letters every six months and today I had a meeting with two of those firms.
One of them kept the letter from 16 months ago on their desk and they waited for now to reach out, and another one just got the letter for the first time in May and reached out to us. It’s amazing how many, now we’ve had 100 of those opportunities over the years. We’ve only done 11 of the deals but it’s because in an initial meeting, we can tell them, “Hey, we’re not a fit for them. We can refer them to somebody else that we know in the market might be looking for an acquisition." But those are the basic ways to find.
Noah Rosenfarb: That’s a pretty solid batting average compared to the private equity investors I talk to that say, “We get 100 deals to look at and we might close on 1 or 2.” So you’ve done pretty good.
John Bly: Well, we’ve done our research on the front end when we do these mailings to make sure we’ve eliminated a lot of the firms that we know are not going to be a fit. We haven’t eliminated all of them because we’ve still met with a bunch that we didn’t do but we try to screen on the frontend before we even do the mailer. But the mailer, letting the attorney, the advisers, the bankers, and the financial advisers, sharing at even industry conferences, we share industry conferences that we’re looking ot continue to acquire, these things just have a life of their own, blogging. It’s amazing, the opportunities we get. We get a lot of inbound leads for CPA firms looking to be acquired.
Noah Rosenfarb: That’s great. So John, kind of an open ended question, what else do you want to share with the listeners?
John Bly: I would say just recap a couple of things. If you haven’t thought about an acquisition, think about it as an alternative growth strategy. It provides you a lot of different venues for growth and a lot of different strategies around it. If you’re thinking about an exit, think sooner rather than later unless you’re looking more than five years out, in which case, just make sure you’re prepping your business for that ultimate time. Every discussion that you’re in with another one of your colleagues, competitors, think being a buyer and a seller in every meeting and think about whether you can have an opportunity to sell to them or a chance to buy their business.
Noah Rosenfarb: Great advice, John. I want to thank you for coming on the show today. John Bly, Cracking the Code, John, how should the listeners get in touch with you?
John Bly: Our website is www.LBAHS.com. You can email me at JohnBly@LBAHS.com and follow me on Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn.
Noah Rosenfarb: Sounds great. Thanks for coming on the show today and to all our listeners, don’t forget to like us on iTunes and leave us your feedback. Have a great day.

Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com.

Thursday, August 25, 2016

How Industry Consolidation Can Impact a Business Exit | Divestopedia

Takeaway: Have you considered the stage of consolidation in your industry and how that might impact your plans for an exit?
How Industry Consolidation Can Impact a Business Exit
Source: Kantver/Dreamstime.com















Over time, industries tend to follow a predictable path of consolidation, referred to as the "consolidation curve." Big companies are acquiring smaller companies using affordable capital to grow. This growth creates economies of scale. And economies of scale allow larger companies to provide goods and services relatively more efficiently and at a lower cost than their smaller competitors.
Consolidation will continue because it is a virtuous cycle where success attracts additional investment that generates further business advantage. A growing consolidator will continue to acquire for two main reasons. First, each acquisition presents an opportunity to further build economies of scale to propel further competitive advantage. Second, disciplined acquisitions increase the value of a business in excess of the cost of the acquisition. This is generally referred to as an accretive acquisition, or multiple arbitrage in the financial world.

The Stages of Consolidation

There are three stages of consolidation. Well, actually four, but the last stage represents stability rather than consolidation. The stages are:
  • Stage 1: Fragmentation
  • Stage 2: Acquisitions
  • Stage 3: Expansion
  • Stage 4: Maturity

Stage 1: Fragmentation

Industries begin in a highly fragmented stage. Depending on industry dynamics, some industries move very rapidly through this stage. In the collision industry, this stage has lasted for decades, but is rapidly changing due to internal and external forces previously discussed.
Leading companies in the initial stages of industry fragmentation focus on building a footprint. They are focused on establishing a “first mover advantage” in size and brand. These companies begin to develop an acquisition-based growth strategy. They focus on building revenues over profit growth. Growth comes in fits and starts. Acquisitions are often “one off” in nature and tend to be opportunistic. Companies are still perfecting their acquisition and growth strategies. Sometimes there are spectacular failures. At this stage, acquisitions are focused on enhancing revenues and expanding footprints.

Stage 2: Acquisitions

This stage is about rapidly building scale. Consolidation takes place rapidly in this stage. Major players begin to emerge from the chaos of a highly fragmented industry. Consolidated business models have been validated and leaders are able to attract capital. The major players begin to form empires, buying up competitors. The pace and frequency of acquisitions increase significantly. At this stage, the leading companies develop a core competency in acquisitions-based growth. The industry is still fragmented, but sizable players have emerged as clear leaders. The top three or four companies account for 30% to 45% of market share.
The type of company acquired also changes. One-off acquisitions that enhance revenue are still important, but maintaining the pace of growth and developing scale become the primary goals. For an acquiring company, the focus shifts to larger targets that provide both revenue enhancement and cost reduction opportunities. In this environment platform, acquisitions become more important. Platform deals tend to be much larger than the average one-off deal and often catapult a company into a new region. Platform acquisitions experience significant valuation inflation as they are important to active acquirers to maintain growth expectations. Acquisition targets, while generally still smaller in size than the acquiring company, tend to increase in size to better leverage cost reduction opportunities.
Successful companies in Stage 2 are companies that are excellent in both acquisitions and integration. Retention of the best employees in these organizations becomes much more important. Building scalable platforms like sophisticated operations management, integrated IT systems, and in-house employee training and development systems becomes important. Companies that survive to Stage 3 are those that acquire key competitors and build competitive advantage through successful integration.

Stage 3: Expansion

After the rapid (and often rabid) consolidation in Stage 2, the leading companies in Stage 3 focus on expanding their business to aggressively outgrow their competitors. While consolidation continues, acquisitions tend to become less frequent, but more focused. Acquisitions are often large scale mega-deals between remaining companies. By the end of this stage, top companies can control as much as 70% of the market.
Rather than buying one-off competitors, top companies shift their growth strategy to brownfield and greenfield development. One-off acquisitions become less frequent in nature because they do not provide sufficient revenue enhancements or cost reductions. They also become less valuable because by this stage buyers usually have built enough brand recognition to justify paying a premium for a seller's existing customer base.
Both brownfield and greenfield developments have higher financial returns and lower risks than most acquisitions. They are more common at this stage as the leading companies use them to “fill in the dots” in areas where they have not been able to find a suitable or affordable acquisition. They also provide more predictable growth, which is important to investors, especially in publicly traded companies.
At this stage, companies begin to focus more on profitability and core competencies developed in prior stages. Leading companies have already developed economies of scale, a recognized brand and an experienced management team. There is no longer a pressing need to acquire talent and invest in projects to build scale as there was in Stage 2. The pace of acquisitions drops substantially, as do the premiums paid to target companies. The credible threat of building a greenfield rather than paying a high premium to a seller keeps prices in check and provides substantial negotiating power to buyers. Companies that survive to Stage 4 are ones that aggressively grow in a disciplined and cost effective manner.

Stage 4: Maturity

Every industry eventually reaches a maturity stage where the acquisitions trickle to a standstill, growth moderates to a few percentage points a year and the market becomes fully developed. In this stage, a handful of dominant players will often control the industry. Examples of mature industries include pharmacies (domestically: CVS and Walgreens), aircraft manufacturing (Boeing and Airbus), automotive manufacturing (domestically: Ford, Chrysler-Fiat, Chevy), shipping (UPS and FedEx) and soft drinks (Coca-Cola and Pepsi).

Case Study - Automotive Collision Industry

The entire automotive aftermarket industry is consolidating. Dealers, tire vendors, parts distributors, paint distributors, software providers are all consolidating. Let's take a closer look at the stage of consolidation for the collision industry.
Stage 1 began in the 1990s with the formation and expansion of groups like Caliber, M2, CTA, ABRA, Boyd, CARA and Gerber, to name a few. These companies grew in fits and starts. Clearly some continue to succeed. Some failed miserably.
After the failures around the turn of the 21st century, Stage 2 began between 2005 and 2008. Service King began to grow in earnest and both Caliber and ABRA underwent significant recapitalizations. Stage 2 started calmly, but, much like a freight train, consistently gained speed and velocity. Both volumes and valuations of deals increased. Year 2014 was a hallmark in terms of both. And 2015, while relatively slower than 2014, experienced a very active year for acquisitions in North America. Is the collision industry in the middle of Stage 2, the tail end of Stage 2, or the beginning of Stage 3?

Seeking an Exit in a Consolidating Industry

Have you considered the stage of consolidation in your industry? More importantly, what are the implications to business owners at each stage? If you are considering a sale to a consolidator, what are the risks of selling later versus selling now? If you are considering growing like a consolidator, how will competition change? How do risks change in each stage?
But before I give you my opinion, I would like to know yours. Where do you see risks in your business and what are you doing to mitigate those risks?
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Monday, June 20, 2016

For High-Tech M&A, Strategic Value is Not Automatic | Divestopedia

By  ,  
Takeaway: If you are a B2B company, it's important to get multiple buyers involved and to get at least one of them to acknowledge the strategic value.
For High-Tech M&A, Strategic Value is Not Automatic
Source: Rancz Andrei - Dreamstime.com






















Wow did I get a real world demonstration of the saying, "Beauty is in the eyes of the beholder," recently. If I could rephrase that to the business sale situation it could be, "Strategic value is in the eyes of each unique buyer." We were representing a small company that had an online hospital information system - specifically, a nurse staffing and shift bidding and scheduling application. They had received a handful of sales from some of the early adapters in the hospital industry.

Raising Capital vs. Selling

The owner was at a crossroads. To keep up with their very well funded competitor (some of the Web MD investors launched a competing product), they recognized that they would require a substantial capital investment. They understood that they had a window of opportunity to achieve a meaningful footprint before their much better capitalized competitor established market dominance. They realized that their ability to scale was critical to their ultimate success and felt their best route was to sell out to a strategic buyer.
The good news is that the owner made a very sound decision going this route rather than trying to raise capital. Speed to market was critical and he reasoned that the strategic acquirer route would be more expeditious than the capital raise approach. He recognized that his company, standing alone would not be able to overcome the conservative hospital decision process of going with the well-known, branded, larger vendor.

Identifying the Perfect Buyer

The ideal company buyer is a larger company that provides information technology and software products in the human resources and staffing departments within hospitals. They could plug this software capability into their existing product line and distribution channel and immediately drive additional sales. They would strengthen their position within their accounts and prospects by offering an additional productivity enhancing product that would promote companion product sales. It would also provide a unique door-opener to other major accounts that would want this high ROI product.
With the input from our clients, we located a handful of companies that fit this profile. We were pretty excited at the prospects of our potential buyers recognizing all of these value drivers and making purchase offers that were not based on historical financial performance. The book, memorandum, confidential business review, executive summary, or whatever your investment banker or merger and acquisition advisor calls it, will certainly point out all of the strategic value that this company can provide the company that is lucky enough to buy it.
As part of the buying process, we usually distribute the "book" and then get a round of additional questions from the buyer. We submit those to our client and then provide the answers to the buyer with a request for a conference call. We had moved the process to this point with two buyers that we thought were similar strategic buyers. The two conference calls were surprisingly totally different.

Option #1: The Financial Buyer

The first one included the M&A advisor and the Chief Financial Officer. Their questions really indicated that they were used to analyzing potential acquisitions strictly from a financial perspective. They focused on our client's EBITDA, gross margin, growth rate, cost of customer acquisition and other historical financial metrics. We had a very bad vibe from these guys. They were refusing to recognize that this was a high gross margin product growing in sales to more than 200% year-over-year, and had a higher level of selling and promotional expense than a mature commodity software application. We couldn't determine if they just didn't get it or were being dumb like a fox to dampen our value expectations.

Option #2: The Strategic Buyer

The second call from the other company included the M&A advisor and the HR systems product manager. The whole tone of the questioning was different. The questions focused on growth in sales, pricing power, new client potential, growth strategy, their status at the major accounts, and ownership of intellectual property.

Differences in Purchase Offers

Well, we got the initial offers and they could not have been more different. The first company could not get beyond evaluating the acquisition as if it were moving forward in the hands of the current owner and with his ability to grow the business. Their offer was an EBITDA multiple bid without taking into consideration that the product sales had grown to more than 200% year-over-year and the marketing and promotional expenses were heavily front end loaded. In spite of our efforts to convey that this was a competitive bid situation and that we were in front of their competitors, they refused to be moved off this financial approach to the valuation of this high-potential product.
The second company understood the strategic value and they reflected it in their offer. We had done a good deal of strategic positioning with this buyer. We discussed with them the tremendous potential growth rate they could achieve with this product being incorporated into their product portfolio and being sold into their install base, and prospects through their highly developed distribution channels. We recognized that they would not pay for this potential with all cash at closing. So, we encouraged them to include a significant portion of transaction value in an earnout based on product sales over the next three years.
The financial buyer's first offer was all cash at close. When we compared that offer to the conservative mid-point of our strategic buyer's combined cash and earnout offer, our transaction value was 300% higher with the strategic buyer. This was the biggest disparity between offers I have ever experienced, but it was quite instructive as to the necessity to get multiple opinions by the market of potential buyers. This is especially important where a meaningful percentage of the company's value is contained in their technology and intellectual property.

Establish Strategic Value

There are some companies that, no matter how hard we try, will not be perceived as a strategic acquisition by any buyer and they are going to sell at a financial multiple. Those companies are often Main Street type companies like gas stations, convenience stores and dry cleaners that are acquired by individual buyers. If you are a B2B company, software, high-tech, health care technology company, have a competitive niche, and are not selling into a commodity type pricing structure, it is important to get multiple buyers involved and to get at least one of those buyers to acknowledge the strategic value.
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Tuesday, May 10, 2016

How Are Middle Market Business Acquisitions Financed? | Divestopedia

By  ,  

How Are Middle Market Business Acquisitions Financed?
Source: flickr/Guillaume-Barcelona

















I have found that many owners of lower mid-market businesses lack adequate knowledge on how a business sale is actually financed by a potential third-party acquirer. This is understandable given that most business owners will only go through the process of selling a business once. Unfortunately, this lack of knowledge is a contributing reason many deals are not consummated. Sellers are not the only ones to blame, though. Many buyers, and even their advisors, don't realize what it takes to finance the purchase of a business in the lower middle market. Buyers make unrealistic offers and when they approach a financing institution, the deal is rejected. Here we'll take a look at the specifics of financing in middle market business acquisitions.

Lower Mid-Market Deals 101

The lower middle market accounts for more than an estimated 90 percent of the total number of all middle market companies in most global economies, so the lack of knowledge on deal structures is a significant succession planning issue. 

Businesses in the lower mid-market, especially those with enterprise values below $20 million, are often stuck in no man's land. They are too small to be an impactful acquisition target for sizable strategic buyers or private equity groups, but too large for an individual buyer to finance. Typically, a competitor of relative size, high-net-worth individuals or investor groups are the most likely potential buyers. For these buyers, capital is not endless and they want to stretch their own equity investment as much as they can. 
When I assist clients in the acquisition of a business, I start by assessing an appropriate valuation, while at the same time determining a financing structure that I believe is achievable. All financing structures will consider some level of the following:
  • Bank financing
  • Vendor financing
  • Purchaser's equity 
The appropriate amount of each source of capital is based on the specific circumstances of the deal.

Bank Financing

The level of bank financing that can be obtained on the purchase/sale of a business is based on two things:

  • The amount of tangible assets that can be pledged as security on the loan. This debt will be senior debt.
  • The level of free cash flow available to service any amount of outstanding debt. This type of debt will be mezzanine, or subordinated (sub), debt. 
Let's take, for example, the purchase of a business with a negotiated purchase price of $10 million. If this company has $8 million in assets, an acquirer will be able to obtain more bank financing than if the business had $5 million in assets. Similarly, if this business has $4 million in EBITDA, the purchaser will be able to get more financing than if there was only $2 million in EBITDA. This is a pretty obvious and straightforward concept.


At a very high level, banks will require the acquired company to maintain a number of specified covenant ratios. Covenants that I have commonly encountered are debt to equity of 2.5:1 and a debt servicing coverage of 1.25:1. A financial model that forecasts profitability, asset levels and free cash flows will assist in determining the right level of bank financing that can be obtained. The allowable level of bank financing in a deal is a very mathematical calculation but it is based on very subjective future projections. Having clear and defensible assumptions within these projections will go a long way toward obtaining the necessary level of financing from a bank. 

Vendor Financing 

The right level of vendor financing is not as easy to quantify as bank financing. From my experience, vendor financing on lower middle market deals ranges from 0 percent to 30 percent of the purchase price. This level moves up or down depending on a number transactional risk factors including, but not limited to:

  • The dependency of a business's operations on the owner rather than established systems and processes
  • The depth of the secondary management team staying on after the business is acquired
  • The level of customer concentration or diversity
  • The certainty of recurring revenue based on contractual obligations
The appropriateness of the amount is based on qualitative characteristics and, of course is negotiated between the vendor and purchaser. Banking institutions also like to see a certain level of vendor financing in a deal because it ties the selling owner to the business and ensures (to some extent) that they are committed to a successful transition.


Vendor financing is one of the most contentious issues in closing the sale of a lower mid-market business. Vendors raise concern over the security (or lack thereof) available for a seller's note because bank financing will alway take priority. The banks will also most likely ask for assignment and postponement, which will place restrictions on the repayment of the seller's note if the company is in breach of it covenants.

No doubt there is risk for the seller around vendor financing, but buyers require a certain amount to compensate for the transitional risk items noted above. If a vendor is adamant about reducing the level of the vendor financing, they will need to provide evidence on how the transitional risks can be mitigated.

Equity

The appropriate equity level is the easiest amount to figure out because it is just the remaining required capital to close the deal. Unfortunately, you must first nail down both the bank and vendor financing, which is sometimes difficult to do.


A bank will always require the purchaser to have some skin in the game. Much like vendor financing, banks want to ensure that the buyer is committed to making the deal work. From my experience, the lowest level of equity from a third party purchaser that a bank will allow is 15 percent. This might be lower in the case of a management buyout where the bank is already comfortable with the expertise and commitment levels of the existing management team. 

Buyers will usually stretch to use the least amount of their capital in order to increase their return on equity. Sophisticated buyers are looking to generate equity returns of 25 percent to 35 percent. No buyer (at least in my experience) will use all of their own cash to finance a deal.

Most business owners don't understand how a business for sale is financed by a third-party acquirer. Unfortunately, this lack of knowledge can be the fundamental misunderstanding that causes such deals to fall through. If your mid-market business is on the auction block, take some time to learn about how potential purchasers will pay for it. It can make all the difference in getting the deal you want.

Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.