Showing posts with label private equity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label private equity. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 31, 2017

Article Summary: Using Customer Due Diligence to Chart a Winning Innovation Roadmap | Axial

Anthony Bahr Strategex | October 31, 2017


I have summarized the key points from the article below.  To read the entire article, click the link at the bottom of my summary - Eric Gall.
  • Customer due diligence should be done prior to closing a deal.
  • Many customer due diligence programs are cursory checks with no added value. 
  • It’s a missed opportunity to engage with customers and derive insights for post-close growth.
  • A well-designed customer due diligence program should:
    • Be based on Voice of the Customer (VOC).
    • Include quantitative and qualitative customer feedback. 
  • Feedback can help mitigate risk and accelerate value creation post-close.
  • A VOC-based customer due diligence program is scalable and customizable. 
    • You can determine the strength and stability of customer relationships.
    • You can address a variety of deal-specific objectives on the buy- or sell-side.

Case Study
  • A PEG was looking to acquire a global manufacturer of specialized chemistry solutions. The acquisition target was investing in the R&D for new products. 
  • Customers were not expressing strong interest in new offerings. 
  • This led to poor ROI on the  R&D investment and compressed margins.
  • The seller suspected customers were not innovating leading to limited demand for a broader portfolio of products.
    • If true, the PEG would have confidence to reduce R&D investment post-close. 
    • If false, VOC would provide alternative explanations and present opportunities to evolve the company’s new product development approach.
  • Strategex partnered with the PEG and developed a VOC program to:

      1. Improve market share by measuring and identifying opportunities to improve customer loyalty.
      2. Boost customer satisfaction by uncovering opportunities to enhance the customer experience.
      3. Reinforce competitive advantages and shore up weaknesses by benchmarking against key purchase criteria.
      4. Determine if an ongoing innovation program was worthwhile by validating or invalidating the hypothesis.
      5. Develop an approach to innovation more likely to succeed by securing a robust understanding of each customers’ internal innovation efforts, outlook for the category, and unmet needs.

The Approach

  • Strategex conducted 49 customer interviews across 34 top accounts. 
  • All interviews were conducted by phone and lasted about 45 minutes.
  • Interviewers used a discussion guide prepared with the PEG.
  • Transcripts were provided to the client after the interviews. 
  • The data was aggregated, coded and synthesized. 
  • The management report outlined key themes and recommendations. 
  • The report also included analysis of the data and customer commentary across a variety of segments.
The Results

In respect to the innovation question, the  revealed that:


  1. The hypothesis was false. Customers thought they were being innovative. 16 of 34 accounts considered themselves to be highly innovative.
  2. The approach to innovation was out of touch with customer needs.  Customers little interest in new products was because they were not relevant to their needs.
  3. There was no shortage of innovation opportunities. Customers identified over 200 potential innovation opportunities.
  • Armed with these insights, the PEG:
    • Closed the deal;
    • Increased the R&D budget; and
    • Implemented joint innovation programs with key accounts. 
  • This led to the development of new products that were highly relevant and in high demand.
  • The deal ended up being highly successful. 
  • The customer due diligence provided the management team with a launch pad for value creation. It also bridged the innovation gap between the portfolio company and its most valuable customers.



For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall, CBI, CM&AP at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com. To search for Florida Businesses for Sale: CLICK HERE

Monday, October 23, 2017

Capital Superabundance is Transforming Middle Market M&A | Axial

Peter Lehrman Axial | October 18, 2017
Bain & Company coined the term “Capital Superabundance” to describe a flush dealmaking environment in which the availability of financial capital is at record highs while the weighted average cost of capital for companies is experiencing record lows. What follows is how this environment is affecting American middle market M&A and its three major participants: private equity and corporate buyers, investment bankers, and exit-ready or “exit-curious” private companies.
To begin, look at the charts below:
The chart from Bain reveals the near 500% growth since 2003 in ongoing dry powder in the global private equity markets.
When demand rises faster than supply, prices tend to rise.
The chart below details U.S. leveraged buyout purchase prices as a multiple of EBITDA for the past 20 years. Source: Capital IQ.
These macro charts provide the framing for a discussion about the most meaningful effects of Capital Superabundance on its participants in middle market M&A.

Top three effects of Capital Superabundance on private equity investors and corporate buyers:

  1. A respected and highly memorable brand has become a major advantage. Capital Superabundance is rewarding organizations with differentiated brands aligned to credible value creation strategies. 
  2. “Business Development” has gone from an afterthought to top of the strategic agenda. BD excellence has become just as strategic to private equity and corporate development teams as sales and marketing excellence is inside companies. 
    Source: BCG
  3. Revenue-oriented value creation. It is often easier to cut costs than to find sustainable methods to drive revenue growth. Capital Superabundance’s upward pressure on purchase price multiples is rendering cost reductions insufficient. Buyers have responded to this reality with increased expertise around buy-and-build value creation models. These approaches play to buyers’ transaction expertise and utilize the increasingly popular “operating partner” model.

Top three effects of Capital Superabundance on investment bankers:

  1. The “personal Rolodex” approach to winning clients and creating great client outcomes is ancient history. Investment bankers are incorporating modern data services to discover buyers, research real-time buyer intent and engage buyers more intelligently. 
  2. Capital superabundance has made investment banking economic for sub-10M EBITDA opportunities. Combining Capital Superabundance with some of the regulatory changes that have eliminated or relaxed broker dealer capital and oversight requirements for the execution of private M&A, establishing one’s own “micro-boutique” investment bank is easier than ever. Growth in micro-boutiques confirms this.
  3. The brand of an investment bank is more important than ever. Investment banks are leveraging well-established content marketing strategies to disseminate their expertise, clarify areas of focus, and create an inbound funnel of prospective clients. Similar to PE, sector and transaction specialist bankers are outflanking generalists with more memorable and more focused brands.

Top three effects of Capital Superabundance on middle market companies:

  1. It’s the most attractive and sustained seller’s market in at least half a century. Multiples are at record highs for businesses across nearly every sector.
  2. Middle market companies have unusually high amounts of strategic choice and freedom. Capital Superabundance has created a new set of choices for entrepreneurs running middle market businesses. They shouldn’t assume conventional approaches are the only way to realize their liquidity goals.
  3. M&A educational information is more widely available for entrepreneurs than ever. Free and affordable solutions for entrepreneurs such as BizEquity’s software-powered valuation tool, Axial’s online deal network and The Salability Score are examples of online solutions that educate and serve private companies that are considering a financing or exit event. 

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall, CBI, CM&AP at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com. To search for Florida Businesses for Sale: CLICK HERE

Wednesday, August 30, 2017

Article Review: Micro Private Equity: The Art of Acquiring Small Businesses | Divestopedia

 ,    

Takeaway: Learn about the opportunities present in micro private equity. Deal structuring will be an important skill for young entrepreneurs looking to acquire businesses and those owners seeking an exit.
Micro Private Equity: The Art of Acquiring Small Businesses
Source: flickr/DennisSylvesterHurd
Summary of points discussed:
  • The importance of timing the market when selling a business;
  • The opportunity of finding hidden value in business acquisitions;
  • How young future entrepreneurs can buy a business with little or no capital;
  • The fact that a business is worth zero if there are no interested buyers; and
  • How properly documenting five areas of your business can help increase business value.

About the Guest

Ace Chapman has bought and sold 11 companies using funds raised from high net-worth individuals and institutions.

Listen here:


You can also get this Podcast by:

Read the Full Transcript Here:


At 19, Ace Chapman came across an online stock market simulator. He loved what they were doing, but felt like they were not promoting it.
He started a web development company. He got the CEO of the simulator on the phone. He negotiated his first leveraged buyout as he was a college student with little money. They did half owner financing. With credit cards and a friend he ended up buying the business.

His friend was technically sophisticated. Find the right partner with a different skill set. The friend programmed in what was needed to facilitate good growth and Ace handled marketing.
They took the site down, did a complete rebuild. Sent out invites to other college students. We put in viral aspects where we would give them money to play trade if they spread the word.
They built a database for 500 people because they thought it would be crazy if they many over the course of the school year. In the first hour it’s 50 people and then 100 and 200. It exploded from there.
This was before the internet boomed. After the boom, they had seven-figure offers to sell the business. After the bust, the model changed. They got less than a tenth of what was offered during the boom. Now Ace is quick to sell businesses for a profit.

Cash flow attracts buyers. Assets are not a focus. Ace looks for businesses that aren’t pushing marketing as much as they could.
A recent acquisition had a 10,000-person database of past clients and customers with email, phone numbers and addresses. They never emailed, called, or direct marketed. Ace doubled the month-to-month revenue and ended up selling it six months later by targeting past customers. 
Ace looks for a hidden opportunity or a hidden asset to leverage or a situation where the seller is highly motivated to sell (divorce, death) and is highly flexible about deal structure.
When selling, Ace likes to provide several very attractive deal structures to appeal to different buyers.
Creative deal structure and leveraged buyouts will become necessary as 12 million businesses are coming to market as baby boomers retire. Nobody is training a younger generation to take over those businesses. 
With young folks, there’s preparation and the structure. Many times you can only go to a very select group of buyers. 99% of general buyers don’t have the financing or experience or don’t understand due diligence. Preparation starts with training, then building business credit.
They target businesses a buyer will be very comfortable with. They just did a publishing software business for a client. The seller is an amazing programmer. Operations were exceptional. She built a large business because she built an amazing product. The buyer brought marketing consulting from PriceWaterHouse. She saw what the business was missing. To create a win-win we allowed the seller to keep some equity.

They do not deal with banks. Banks have only done 7% of business lending. In 2008, it went down to 1%. 99% was picked up by everybody else.

They keep a database of alternative lenders and can select lenders based on the buyer's financial situation.

Examples:

  • Gold’s Gym acquisition, they leveraged the equipment. 
  • Carwash deal, they found an SBA program. 
  • Banks are going to seek some SBA-type guarantee that ties up all your business and personal assets in liens. 


They look for different types of financing to get a better deal for the business buyer.
There are a lot of local opportunities to obtain financing for specific programs. For the publishing company, part of the deal is a local loan that the state of Pennsylvania for people bringing jobs to Pittsburgh. 
Every deal is unique and they go after every type of financing that might work. They see what is leined then pick out the best financing and deal structure for the business buyer.
Ace has focused on micro-private equity (owners who are not actively involved) over the last six years. With buying a business under the $5 million dollar, the multiples are incredible. With the private equity model you need to be able to manage the business. You have to work it. Paying off a business in 3 to 4 years, is a powerful wealth building strategy. There’s just no other asset class where you’re buying something at that low a multiple.
Above $5 million, you’re competing with private equity. Below $2 million you’re doing deals max at a two multiple. The micro-private equity concept was born out of past clients who see the opportunity but just don't want to work the business. They work with younger buyer clients and invest in them and their deals.  They not only put up money, but experience, time, mentorship, and strategic planning without the day-to-day responsibilities.


For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com. To search for Florida Businesses for Sale: CLICK HERE

Friday, August 18, 2017

Article Summary: How Your Company Is Valued Depends on the Buyer | Divestopedia

By 

How Your Company Is Valued Depends on the Buyer
Source: Violka08/iStock
Takeaway: Different types of acquirers use different valuation methods. 


  • There a several different types of buyers.
  • Each type will value businesses differently.
  • Business valuation is incredibly complex.
  • Business is not an exact science; they are based on many subjective decisions.
  • Business valuations can vary from appraiser to appraiser.

Basic Valuation Approaches

There are three fundamental approaches to valuing a business:
Market Approach

  • Works best in real estate due to few parameters.
  • Businesses have many number of moving parts.
  • Comparative sales have to be used with other valuation methods. 
  • Often not enough data to compare apples to apples. 

Income Approach

  • Most common for valuing private small businesses. 
  • Based on company revenues and earnings. 
  • Method #1 is Multiple of Discretionary Earnings (SDE) Method, where SDE is defined as the net operating income plus adjustments plus the owner’s salary. 
  • The multiple is the inverse of the capitalization rate (cap rate). 
  • Method #2 is discounted cash flows is based on reasonable projections (usually 5 years), and uses a discount rate (usually the cap rate plus rate of growth) to calculate the present value of the future cash flows.
Asset Approach

  • Asset approach is used when fair market value of assets represents most or all of the business value. 
  • The net tangible assets of the business comprise : the machinery, equipment, furniture and fixtures, etc. 
  • Used when the business is no longer a going concern, or losing money for a few years.

Valuation Method Depends on Buyer Type

Let’s look at the most likely valuation methods used by each buyer type:
Strategic Buyer

  • Typically large private or public companies. 
  • Strategic buyers are interested in the future synergies and not as concerned about past performance. 
  • The likely valuation method will be the discounted cash flow approach.
Sophisticated Financial Buyer

  • Typically small investment groups, private equity groups (PEGs) and small companies interested in growth by acquisition. 
  • Interest in both past performance and future opportunities for growth. 
  • The likely valuation methods will be multiples of earnings and discounted cash flow.

Lifestyle Buyer  

  • Looking to supply income, equity, and debt service from future cash flows. 
  • Will buy the future, but only pay for the past. 
  • The valuation method is multiple of seller discretionary earnings. 
  • For larger companies they may use the multiple of EBITDA.
Industry Buyer

  • Industry buyers are in your niche, you know them, and consider your company inferior. Typically bottom feeders trolling to buy on the cheap. 
  • Valuation method will be the asset approach. 
  • If this particular buyer is interested in buying your company (total assets plus goodwill), then seek professional help to even the playing field.

Article LINK


For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall, CBI, CM&AP at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com. To search for Florida Businesses for Sale: CLICK HERE

Thursday, August 10, 2017

Article Summary: Even With Valuations High, PE Sees Strong Exit Environment | Axial

I've pared down the article to the key points.  If you want to read the entire article click the link at the bottom of the summary -- Eric Gall

By , Axial | 
Axial surveyed their PE members for their pulse on the current deal environment. Forty-five middle market investors shared their thoughts.
The Exit Environment

  • 71% say the exit environment was positive in 2016. 
  • 42% said they are waiting until 2017 before selling.
  • Buyers are more likely to be strategic investors (40%) vs. PEGs (33%).
  • In hot industries like healthcare, corporate buyers may justify higher prices due to expected synergies
  • 2/3rds expecting to sell to strategic buyers expect to do more deals with private companies vs. publicly traded corporations. 
  • 20% believe their next buyer will be a fundless or independent sponsor, who have become increasingly active in the middle market. 
Deal Dynamics

  • 69% will deploy more or the same amount of capital into add-on and platform investments.
  • Many middle market investors are moving down market looking to smaller add-on companies.
  • Co-investments is increasing between PE, family offices, or other PE shops to partner on a deal.  31% will complete more co-investment deals.  
  • Generalist investors with a broad industry/sector mandate are more likely to complete co-investments this year (38%) compared to specialists (20%).


Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Wednesday, August 9, 2017

Article Summary: M&A Trends for Sellers in 2017 | Axial

By , Axial | 

I've summarized key points and added commentary in red text.  If you want to read the original article, click the link at the end of the summary - Eric Gall

Comments from two investment bankers from December 2016 on M&A in 2017:
Shea's advice:

  • Think long before executing. 
  • Have your financial house in order.
  • Understand the key metrics of your business.

3 M&A Insights


1. Search funds have proliferated the lower middle market.
Search funds are individuals or small groups looking to buy and operate a small company. Search funds are viable options for businesses not fitting the objectives of strategic buyers or private equity funds.  Search funds tend to be conservative regarding valuations.  I have seen this as well and I am executing searches for quite a few of them.
2. Private equity is going upstream.  
Private equity has become too well funded to be interested in add-ons under $2M EBITDA.  Smaller companies need to sell turn to strategic buyers, search funds, or independents.  True as well as you just can't obtain interest under $2M EBITDA.
3. It’s still a seller’s market.
There is still a lot of money in private equity and the lower-middle-market.  There is a short supply of quality companies.  You always want to be selling on an uptrend. 
In this video, Shea discusses tips for preparing for a transaction: 

3 Industry Trends

1. The precision machinery industry is hot.
Aerospace drives a huge number of inquiries from private equity and strategics. Large manufacturers (Boeing, GE) are gearing up for big projects in the next 20 years. Buyers are looking for highly skilled labor and capacity.  Aerospace has done very well for me over the past few years.
2. Infrastructure, energy, and defense companies might want to wait and see on M&A.
The new presidential administration will focus on infrastructure, energy, and defense. Older business owners should initiate a deal process now as the market heats up.
3. Buyers continue to reward recurring revenue in IT services businesses.
Buyers pay very high premiums for recurring revenue models in IT services (vs. project model companies).  Very high demand for subscription software/SAS companies.
In this video, Dee discusses the importance of educating oneself as a seller: 


For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com.

Monday, June 26, 2017

Article Review: Growing Your Business in Preparation for a Sale | Divestopedia

 ,  

  
Takeaway: Follow these steps if you realize your business value is not where you want it to be.

Eric Gall:  We have programs and consultants available to assist you in bridging the gaps.
Growing Your Business in Preparation for a Sale
Source: tuk69tuk/iStock
Many business owners realize too late that the value of their business is not what they need to meet their retirement goals/financial objectives.

Evaluate the Timing


  • If you must sell, then you will need to adjust your objectives to to accept a lower price.
  • If you have three to five years prior to the sale, you have time to grow the business and improve processes.

Find Help

  • There are business consultants who specialize in business growth and preparing a business for sale.
  • Of course, you the owner, must have the skills, discipline, time, focus and determination to help plan and execute the strategy.
  • The strategy starts with a "Needs Assessment" that is the basis of the growth and process improvement roadmap.
  • Process improvements may include building, training, documenting, reviewing and improving systems around quality, safety, communications, human resources, production, maintenance, sales, logistics, etc.

Identify Value Drivers

  • Clean and accurate financial information.
  • Sales history is trending upwards and not at the expense of margins. 
  • You have "barriers to entry" that give you a competitive advantage.
  • You, the owner, are the strategist and visionary, but not required for day-to-day operations. 
  • You have systems and documentation throughout your business to help your staff meet operational objectives. 

Baby Steps

For companies less than $2 to $3 million in revenue it may be too costly to afford a consultant; however, it is never too early to start working on improving the key value drivers.
ARTICLE LINK
For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com. To search for Florida Businesses for Sale: CLICK HERE

Thursday, June 15, 2017

Article Review: Who Is the Right Buyer for Your Business? | Divestopedia

 ,     

Key Takeaway: With all the potential buyers out there, how do you choose the right buyer for you?
Who Is the Right Buyer for Your Business?
Source: Gazometr/iStock
Depending on the company’s profile, trading outlook, management structure and growth potential, shareholders who are considering their exit strategy may have more than one type of buyer for consideration to approach, in order to ensure they maximize the value they receive.

Types of Buyers

Defensive 

A sale to a competing company.  It can generate the greatest financial return, but also carries a confidentiality risk. Competitors acquire to enhance their business model, synergistic savings, buying power and market share.  

Synergistic

A sale to a company in a different market. This buyer may or may not be aware of synergies between your businesses. The tactic is to make them aware. This type of buyer will not have identified your company as an acquisition target. It will take time to demonstrate why you are a good acquisition. 

International Entity

 A sale to an international entity. This buyer operates within the same markets, provides similar products and services in other countries, but will not have a presence in your area. The challenge is to convince them they need to pay a premium to unlock your customer base vs. growing organically. Again, it will take time to demonstrate why you are a good acquisition. 

Financial or Private Equity

 A sale to a financial buyer or private equity firm. Private equity invests in companies having potential for significant near-term growth that they can sell at a significant gain in 3-5 years. Private equity firms either invest capital to unlock growth, or convert the company into a platform to consolidate a fragmented market.
Private equity firms typically value lower, but they allow management equity to be rolled over, offering the potential of a much higher, long-term gain based upon the future sale.
Conclusion
You will only get to sell your business once, so you owe it to yourself to ensure it is to the right buyer.

Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com. To search for Florida Businesses for Sale: CLICK HERE

Thursday, June 8, 2017

Podcast Review: How to Sell Your Business for a Crazy High Price | Divestopedia

 ,    

Takeaway: "There will always be a market for outrageous prices as long as the buyers are looking to grow, which for big companies, that's what they do."
How to Sell Your Business for a Crazy High Price
In this podcast, Kevin M. Short, Author of "Sell Your Business For An Outrageous Price", talks about:
  • How to exploit your company's competitve advantage to get the highest price:
    • You need to cause a market leader pain via a competitive advantage,
    • You need a "big" buyer that does not need bank financing,
    • You need a seller who is patient and willing to invest in the strategy,
    • You need an advisor who can do the business case and convince the buyer;
  • Aligning investment banking fees to incentivize them in getting the highest selling price; and
  • Success stories on deals selling for crazy high prices.

About the Guest

Kevin is the author of Sell Your Business For An Outrageous Price. This book synthesizes Kevin’s experience in selling mid-size companies ($10MM - $250MM in value) for up to twice the multiple of the industry average.

Listen here:


You can also get this Podcast by: 

Article LINK


For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com. To search for Florida Businesses for Sale: CLICK HERE