Showing posts with label Purchase and Sale Agreement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Purchase and Sale Agreement. Show all posts

Monday, October 30, 2017

Article Summary: Maximize Your Selling Price by Finding the Right Buyers | Divestopedia

 | 
Maximize Your Selling Price by Finding the Right Buyers

Takeaway: Not every offer will be a reasonable one. If you're using business-for-sale websites, you will likely receive lowball offers. Avoid them with these tips.
Most companies deciding to sell have characteristics that drive down their value, such as customer concentration or management all from the owner's family. This article discusses how to minimize discounting by locating the right buyers.

Selling Process

The author discusses the sale of a Human Resources Consulting company. They contacted several industry players, but buyers dropped out because the seller's entire management team was comprised of family members. They took the company off the market and brought in one non-family executive who had the authority to run the company. 
The business is counter-cyclical and grew during the economic downturn. It was difficult to determine how much improvement was due to the new manager.
The business was put back on the market. One buyer was particularly interested and asked to put together his letter of intent.
He started by giving all the reasons to discount the price, e.g., fear of losing key employees, no recurring revenue, etc..  He was provided a chart showing recurring revenue from the top 20 clients to demonstrate consistency and predictability of revenues.
He then focused on the prior year's upward spike and said, "I am just going to use 2015's revenues as my basis for my offer." The author asked how he would have made an offer if last year was unusually bad, but the prior five years were strong. He did not answer, but it is expected he would have made his offer based on the new trend.

Stand Strong

These kind of buyers are common. A famous residential real estate investor wrote a book on investing; his philosophy was to find 100 people with their homes for sale, approach them aggressively, make a lowball offer, and one will take it.
The buyer inquired from a business for sale website - a perfect platform for this philosophy.
Get multiple buyers involved in the process. If you just post on one of the Business-for-Sale websites, you may get multiple buyers interested, but they are the buyers contacting 100 sellers very efficiently in order to make lowball offers.
Six other industry buyers were contacted.  All were looking for acquisitions based on acquiring new customers, adding a product offering, or leveraging their sales force or install base. Their motivation was not to buy a company with a lowball offer.

Encourage Fair Offers

The way to encourage buyers to make fair offers is to conduct outbound marketing to industry buyers that have strategic reasons for making acquisitions.  If a business seller only attracts inbound, bargain seeker buyers from websites, they will be getting low ball offers and waste time. 

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall, CBI, CM&AP at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com. To search for Florida Businesses for Sale: CLICK HERE

Monday, October 9, 2017

Article Summary: Biggest Lessons Learned From Selling My Business | Divestopedia

 ,  

   
Takeaway: Cory Janssen, co-founder of Investopedia and Divestopedia, shares his nuggets of wisdom learned from selling Investopedia to Forbes.
Biggest Lessons Learned From Selling My Business

Cory Janssen co-founded Investopedia.com in 1999 and helped grow it into one of the Web's largest financial sites devoted to investor education. In April 2007, the company was sold to Forbes Media.

1. We were very careful about not building the company around our personalities so eventually, we could sell it if we wanted to.

2. We interviewed brokers and selected a firm in Silicon Valley who had done some similar deals and started a formal process with them.
3. After two months of preparation, the broker put the offer out to 40 to 50 organizations.  After four months, we narrowed the list to ten firms who came to visit us. 
4. LOIs were requested and we further narrowed the list to three companies.  We visited the three companies at their locations and closed with Forbes in April, nine months after we initiated the process.
5. The biggest lesson I didn’t realize beforehand is you have to manage your team differently at different stages of the process. Early on, the investment banker is your best friend because they are incented to get your idea in front of the right people. However, your lawyer is your worst enemy because he’s just racking up your bill.
6. Later in the process, it flips at the point there where the broker figures they got you as much as they can, so at that point, your lawyer is your best friend because your broker doesn’t care about everything you’re doing in the legal agreement. 
7. You have to manage the exit team, e.g, tax planners, accountant and other exit planners.  They are all on your team, they’re all for you, but you need to treat and manage each differently based on where you are in the deal.
8. You want to align your interests. Before selling my partners and I wrote down our goals for the deal. It helped ground us near the end of the deal when things are going back and forth and you can’t keep your head straight, it grounded us. 
9. We also gave the broker an above-market fee over a certain dollar to incent him. Alignment of interests works for whether you’re trying to hire a sales person or whether you’re trying to sell a business.

10. Looking back, we could have made the deal much smoother by having a better exit plan. I didn't know what an exit plan was at the time, to be honest. 
For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall, CBI, CM&AP at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com. To search for Florida Businesses for Sale: CLICK HERE

Friday, April 21, 2017

Three Rules for Involving Attorneys in a Small Business Sale

Eric J. Gall | April 21, 2017

As most people know, attorneys can be your best friend or worst nightmare in small business.  It all depends on how and when they are used.  Below are my three rules for involving attorneys in a business transaction (in Florida):

When working in the Corporate world, it is quite common for two companies to work a deal on paper and then hand it over to Corporate Counsel to tie up all the loose ends.  In the small business world, attorney involvement is completely different.

Corporate Counsel doesn't exist in small business.  Legal expense is not a budgeted item.  Small business owners' experiences with attorneys are often unpleasant, for example, initiating or defending a lawsuit.  When it comes to a business purchase and sale, small business owners prefer to do the deal businessman-to-businessman and keep the attorneys on the sidelines.  I both agree and disagree with this approach.

I agree all Purchase and Sale Agreements should be first negotiated businessman-to-businessman with the intermediaries (either a transaction business broker or both buy and sell-side business brokers) in-between to diffuse emotion, help answer sensitive questions, and solve problems.  My experience has been eighty percent of the time when a buyer enters a negotiation to purchase a business with their attorney drafting the initial agreement, the deal fails.  And even if it succeeds, half the time the deal winds up in litigation after the sale.  Attorneys are paid to over protect their clients.  When a buyer's attorney drafts the Purchase and Sale Agreement it is generally very one-sided.  It immediately breaks trust and creates an adversarial relationship between the buyer and the seller.  Small business deals get done when the buyer and seller like and trust one another.  Break the initial trust and the deal is likely done or poisoned leading to post sale problems.

Intermediaries generally start with a neutral document (I use the Business Brokers of Florida Standard Asset Purchase Agreement) designed to equally protect the buyer and seller.  If two intermediaries are involved, the buy-side intermediary puts together the initial offer.  A neutral document will highlight where protections above and beyond the norm have been added allowing for easy review by the seller and their counsel.  When protections are clear, an open and honest negotiation can proceed.  When buy-side attorneys write the agreement, protections are often hidden or baked into the "legalese;" thus creating mistrust.

Rule #1:  Have your intermediary write up the initial Purchase and Sale Agreement.  

As an intermediary can help solve problems between buyer and seller, a third-party closing attorney will help solve problems between the buyer's and seller's attorneys.  I always recommend the buyer and seller select a third-party closing attorney to handle escrow, draft the closing documents, and execute the closing.  Of course, I provide recommendations based on location and expense.  Third-party attorneys do a great job in keeping the buyer's and seller's attorneys from creating unnecessary turf wars with their resultant legal expenses.  I've seen buyer and seller attorney bills greater than $25K per side when buyer and seller refused to use a third-party closing attorney.  I've seldom seen buyer and seller attorney bills over $2K when a third-party closing attorney is involved from the initial placement of escrow.

Rule #2:  Agree on a third-party closing attorney.

Where I disagree with this approach is I always recommend small business sellers and buyers to have an experienced business transaction attorney review all contracts.  This includes the Purchase and Sale Agreement, the closing documents and any contracts that are to be transferred as part of the sale.  In Florida, buyer and seller have five business days after the signing of a Purchase and Sale Agreement to have their independent counsel review the agreement and request changes.  I have found attorneys seldom drive changes to the document that will break trust and kill a deal after the buyer and seller have initially agreed in principle to the transaction.

Rule #3:  Use attorneys to review all contracts associated with the purchase and sale of a business. 

This by no means constitutes legal advice and as stated using independent counsel to review all documents associated with a business purchase and sale is always recommended.

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com.

To search for Florida Businesses for Sale: CLICK HERE

Tuesday, March 14, 2017

7 Fundamentals to Due Diligence You Need to Know | Divestopedia

By  , 
Takeaway: Being open about your business practices and financial statements can lead to a better takeaway for both the buyer and seller.
7 Fundamentals to Due Diligence You Need to Know
Source: Info40555/Dreamstime.com
According to Bizbuysell.com, there were a total of 1,840 businesses transactions that took place worldwide during the first quarter of 2016. Businesses were either bought and sold or mergers and acquisitions took place in that first quarter. People buy and sell or merge businesses for different reasons, but whatever the reasons, there are always a wide variety of preliminary activities that must take place prior to closing the deal. In almost all cases, an attorney who is fluent in due diligence for mergers and acquisitions is required to ensure that the transaction takes place based on the laws that have been put into place by FINRA or other regulatory agencies.

1. Historic and Projected Financial Information

Historic Information

The seller should be providing financial documents for the past three years. The buyer will need to perform due diligence concerning the company’s historical financial information and supporting documentation.
The seller will need to provide documents for the buyer to perform an assessment of the company’s financial statements so they can make note of any financial trends, spikes or decreases in sales and revenue, consistencies or inconsistencies in cash flow activity, the company’s current debt, receivables and other assets, as well as all other aspects of the company's financial performance.

Projected Information

In addition to performing due diligence on the historical financial information, the buyer will also need to perform due diligence on any future financial activity as well. Carefully checking to ensure reasonable financial projections of the company’s future performance were made. Some of those areas involve whether or not the projections are based on reasonable assumptions whereby a clear path to achieving those results is laid out and linked to the actual financial activity in a practical, succinct manner.
  • Is the projected financial information sound and believable?
  • Were the documents succinct?
  • How much working capital is necessary to continue running the business beyond its current state?
  • Are there additional capital expenditures or other required investments that need to take place to ensure the future growth of the business?

2. Technology Developments and Intellectual Property

The seller will need to provide the buyer's attorney with information about any current or pending intellectual property, technology developments, copyright and patent ownerships that the company may have.
If the company has patent applications and potential trademarks, the buyer should ensure that the appropriate registration has taken place. When materials are used in marketing or technological advances, the company must have the rights and control the copyright, or risk lawsuits. If they haven't, it could be a risk for the buyer who will take on any liability based on prior violations.
Trade secrets are vital to the success of some companies, so as the seller, you'll need to ensure that the secrets have been preserved appropriately and other companies' secrets have not been infringed by your company and be able to prove that to the buyer.

3. Customers and Revenue Streams

Before purchase, the seller will have to detail the various revenue streams of the business. This includes the company's satisfied customers, and what they purchase. The buyer should have a grasp of who the customers are as well as how revenue is generated by these customers especially the top 20 percent who will account for much of the business.
Another consideration is the satisfaction of the customers after a change in ownership. Are there going to be problems with new ownership that will impact the business' revenue going forward?
Along with evaluating customer loyalty and spending habits, the seller will be giving the buyer information about the backlog of issues. Are there warranty problems that are not being handled properly? Do there seem to be a high level of exchanges and refunds being issued? The seller should already have this information and be able to tell the buyer why there were problems.

4. Contract Agreements and Insurance

A review of all pending and active contracts and agreements should be a part of the due diligence process as well as a review of insurance coverage.
The key areas include some of the following:
  • Outstanding loans, personal guarantors, and note payables
  • Outstanding customer and vendor contracts
  • Partnerships, joint venture, or operating agreements
  • Outstanding or pending Settlement agreements
  • Equipment or vehicle lease agreements
  • Independent contractor and Employment agreements
  • General liability and Worker’s compensation insurance
  • D&O / E&O and Key man insurance
  • Intellectual property insurance
  • Vehicle insurance
  • Health insurance
  • Umbrella policies

5. Staff and Key Management

The buyer will need to perform diligence activity for all staff, independent contractors, and key management. This should include looking into scheduled pay raises, equity shares, profit distributions, 401(k), commissions, bonuses and other employment related issues. This means the seller will need to have opened their human resource files and be willing to have a buyer comb through the documents.
Along with the functionality of the human resources department regarding compensation, there should be a detailed audit of the history of labor disputes. If there's even been a threat to stop working for any reason, that could be a red flag, but the buyer will need to look into the issues that caused the employees to be disgruntled.

6. Legal and Compliance

One of the biggest headaches for a buyer can be legal tangles, which include any current, pending or settled litigation, arbitration or other proceedings. Any compliance- or regulation-related issues can be a problem, too. This is where the buyer's attorney should be forecasting the result of the litigation as well as investigating claims and threats against the company. The seller can help by being as forthcoming as possible and talking to their own attorneys about the legal future of any claims.
With detailed due diligence procedures for acquisitions, a seller can avoid serious legal problems in the future by looking at the prior, current, and future potential for legal threats. There might even be matters in arbitration at the moment that could resolve into a problem for the new owner. In some cases, a buyer might come back and sue a seller for fraud if they weren't forthcoming with information regarding fraud.

7. Tax Issues

It’s important to perform a tax due diligence to determine whether the company has any tax liability issues. This process should include a review of tax returns that have been filed within the past five years including the federal, state, and local returns. The buyer's accountants and attorneys should be checking for net operating losses. Credit carryovers should be investigated to ensure that the change in ownership won't impact the relationship with the creditor.
If there have been agreements, waivers or tax communications with the IRS, the new buyer should understand exactly what that means for acquiring the business. If there have been settlement agreements with the IRS or other agencies, the seller will want to let the buyer know that those will not impact the new ownership negatively, and might not carry over to the new buyer.

Final Words

Due diligence in merger and acquisitions requires that a substantial amount of activities take place from both sides prior to making a full commitment to the transaction. It’s a means for the buyer to do some fact-checking, so that he or she is fully aware of what is actually being purchased. By carefully planning these and other related activities for the due diligence in mergers and acquisitions process, the buyer will feel confident in his decision and will be prepared to proceed with the purchase of the business. The seller will be able to say that they provided all the information the buyer needed to make a sound decision.

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com.

Friday, May 6, 2016

Ask an Expert: 5 Questions on Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs) | Divestopedia

By  ,  

Ask an Expert: 5 Questions on Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs)
Source: flickr/mark falardeau
A Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA), also called Confidentiality Agreements (CA), are contracts that stipulate that information received from a counterparty will only be used for the purpose as defined in the NDA. This information will not be used as a basis for competitive tactics or shared freely with others. NDAs are signed in cases of divestitures, but also for joint ventures and other collaborative and strategic relationships. 
Here are some key questions I often get asked about NDAs and the responses I provide:

What is the typical term of a NDA?

The term of an NDA is typically one to three years, and the appropriateness of the term depends very much on the rate of change in the company and the industry in which it operates.

If a buyer signs an NDA, can they solicit my employees or customers?

NDAs may include non-solicitation and/or non-circumvention clauses. Non-solicitation clauses can apply to customers and/or employees. Non-circumvention clauses protect entrepreneurs with great ideas from well capitalized parties acting on the idea without acknowledging or compensating the entrepreneur.

Is all information included within an NDA, or is there some information that doesn't qualify?

Every NDA will include clauses that describe when the agreement does not apply; such as (i) if the information falls into the public domain other than as a result of a disclosure in violation of the agreement; or (ii) if the information is already known to the recipient at the time of its disclosure; or (iii) if it is independently obtained or developed by the recipient. The reasons for these are fairly self evident. You can’t stop a person from acting on information that they already know or is publicly available (that everyone else can act on).

Are NDAs universally applicable regardless of where they are signed and who the parties are?

NDAs may need to be adjusted for different jurisdictions and for certain counterparties. For example, NDAs usually address what the recipient should do with the information once one party determines the process is over. This may include returning or destroying the information. However, in certain jurisdictions, companies will want to retain a copy of the information in case it is required to be disclosed pursuant to applicable law, regulation or legal process. Private equity and venture capital groups typically add a clause to protect their ability to invest in, or operate companies in the same or related fields of business as that engaged in by the company.

What is the likelihood that a company will sign an NDA if I'm selling my business?

Certain companies will not sign NDAs at all (at least not in the initial stages). IBM will not review blind teasers (i.e. a summary without disclosing the company name) and requires all introductory information to be marked "non-confidential." Microsoft’s policy is that NDAs are executed on the condition of aligned business group(s) willing to sponsor an engagement. These companies see so many proposals and are in so many businesses that they have simply decided that it is not worth the expense of processing NDAs at an early stage.

In conclusion, ask yourself the following questions

Do NDAs really protect you from counterparties using the provided information against you?
And if someone contravenes an NDA, can you prove it? 
Can you sue them? 
YES, but....will it be worth it?
RARELY. 
My view is you should always put an NDA in place before you share information, but then use caution and share only select information that will not potentially harm your business. Don’t view an NDA as a bulletproof vest. Continue to be guarded particularly in the areas of new business partners, potential new customers and key employees.
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Monday, February 29, 2016

9 Critical Areas for Effective Due Diligence | Divestopedia

By  , 

Takeaway: Part 2 of a two part article discusses what constitutes an effective operations due diligence and nine critical areas of focus.
9 Critical Areas for Effective Due Diligence
Source: flickr/ImagesofMoney
In Part 1 of this article, I described the need for both investors and business owners to perform an operations due diligence and the role of these assessments. In Part 2 we will discuss what constitutes an effective operations due diligence.

When I was writing my book "Operations Due Diligence - An M&A Guide for Investors and Business" I didn’t realize what a radical idea this would be for some people. Over the past year I have had very few people who acknowledged that an effective due diligence included the need to perform an enterprise risk/operations assessment… until the benefit was explicitly pointed out to them. This is the point when I see the twinkle of understanding come into the faces of my audiences and they have a moment of understanding, "of course I knew that"… but it’s clear they had never actually made the connection of performing an enterprise wide assessment as part of their due diligence. And here is how I know they had not thought of it as an enterprise wide assessment.

Generally, when their hands went up in response to my question about what should be assessed beyond legal and financial due diligence and the "Ooo, Ooo, Ooo… started I found most people picked one particular operations area they felt needed to be assessed. Without the principals of law or accounting to guide them, the requirements of an effective operations due diligence have not previously been very well defined. Some investors look at the management team or the sales pipeline or, if it’s a software company for instance, they have an engineer look at the code. Unlike legal or financial due diligence an operations due diligence needs to covers a lot of potential risk areas. Most investors perform their operations assessment in an ad hoc manner assessing random areas based on who they currently have on staff or looking just in places where they have had past problems. They send an engineer to look at the source code or a department manager to speak with the management team. This team has rarely been trained to perform a true enterprise risk assessment. Generally they are asked for their opinion of one particular business function or another. When they are asked, universally these investors believe they have performed an operations due diligence. Universally, they have failed and this failure to perform an effective operations due diligence that spans the entire operations infrastructure of the business (the enterprise) is one of the leading causes of M&A failures. An effective operations due diligence should be performed by a Business Analyst with enterprise risk assessment experience whose goal is to assess the operations infrastructure of the business.

To quote one bright young MBA graduate, "OMG, that’s a lot of stuff!" Yes it is and I am often asked if it can be cut back. Yes it can but you risk (there’s that pesky risk word again) the opportunity to discover a latent risk or opportunity that could impact the future sustainability of the business. If you are going to bet a large sum of money, maybe it’s worth the time to perform an effective assessment. In our practice we recommend assessing the following nine operations infrastructure areas:

CUSTOMER SATISFACTION: The customer satisfaction infrastructure has to be designed as an integral part of the business and not simply included like a facade over the front door. The customer satisfaction infrastructure defines the role of functions such as product support, requirements definition, and quality assurance.

PRODUCTION/SERVICES: The production/services infrastructure defines the methods that will be used for the delivery of all products and services and ensure that this is being done in a safe, compliant, and consistent manner capable of bringing all products and services fully to market.

INFORMATION MANAGEMENT: It would be a tremendous understatement to say that all businesses today are information intensive. The information management infrastructure defines the methods for protecting all business data, the electronic tools that form the backbone of the business, printed material and all media that is used to support the business. All personal privacy and security controls need to be assessed here.

SALES AND MARKETING: The sales and marketing infrastructure defines the methods used for everything from pricing and lead flow needed to support the sales pipeline to the methods used to develop new products and markets including the use of competitive and strategic analysis as assessment tools.

ORGANIZATIONAL: The definition of the organizational infrastructure includes the formal and informal structure of the business. It includes the organization chart that forms the command and control structure plus the informal structure that becomes the culture of the business.

PERSONNEL: The personnel infrastructure defines the working relationship between the business and its employees and between employees including the roles and authority of the management team. It defines the benefit strategy and compensation plan plus the procedures for hiring, firing and everything in between.

FINANCIAL OPERATIONS: The financial operations infrastructure forms the framework for all financial operations of the business. It defines all financial authority and controls including AP/AR, payroll, cost account and project management, plus the definition of methods to be used for budgeting and projections.

LEGAL OPERATIONS: The legal operations infrastructure forms the framework for all legal operations of the business. It defines all legal authority, professional licensing and controls needed to support the business on a continuing basis. It defines all activities used to protect the business from legal risk and liabilities and to ensure the compliant operation of the business.

INSTITUTIONALIZED PROCESSES: The institutionalized processes infrastructure includes the definition of all formalized policies, procedures and methods that guide the businesses operations. Methods such as ISO, CMMI, Six Sigma, Enterprise Risk Management (ERM), Lean or Quality Management Systems (QMS) and any areas where the business needs certification to qualify for a market driven process are defined.

Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Monday, June 22, 2015

10 Rules for Effectively Negotiating the Sale of a Business | Divestopedia

By , 

10 Rules for Effectively Negotiating the Sale of a Business
Thousands of companies are sold each year. Sometime soon, you may be asked to participate in the negotiation of the sale of a company. Will you be ready? Negotiation are an extremely improtant part of the sales process. The following guidelines will help you negotiate more effectively not only the sale of a company, but any major negotiation.

Rule #1: Define your key negotiating objectives.

On one piece of paper, rank your key negotiating objectives, with the most important at the top of your list. For instance, some sellers primarily want a minimum amount of cash when the sale closes and, secondarily, employment agreements for key personnel must be part of the deal.

Rule #2: Execute a plan.

Develop an overall action plan that incorporates your key objectives. Then develop tactical action plans for each negotiating session that are consistent with your overall action plan.

Rule #3: Be prepared.

There is no substitute for a well-prepared negotiator who has studied the situation and prepared consistent, well organized, fact-oriented material. Start with a clearly written memorandum about the company being sold, describing its strengths, challenges, and future opportunities in detail. This document forms the basis for productive advanced negotiations.

Rule #4: Negotiate only with a qualified party.

The company/group considering the purchase should have some knowledge of the selling company’s industry and they need to be financially capable of consummating the sale. The individual or individuals conducting the negotiation should have decision-making authority to advance the negotiation’s major issues. Ideally, they would have the authority to resolve the major issues themselves.

Rule #5: Resolve the few really important issues first.

Most negotiations have a few really important issues and many minor issues. If the really important issues are resolved, all the minor issues can normally be settled quickly. Focus on the few important issues initially and then work your plan with regards to the sequence of required actions; the delivery of key messages; developing interpersonal relations; the views of influential people not present in the negotiating session; and documenting issues as they are resolved.

Rule #6: Organize simultaneous bidding.

In order to maximize the financial return to the selling shareholders, several qualified acquirers should be simultaneously bidding and negotiating. Horses run faster, and acquirers pay more, when they are competing.

Rule #7: Know the buyers’ side.

Try to determine the buyers’ positions and goals. There is an old Indian saying, "You need to walk a mile in another man’s moccasins before you can understand the man." Determine the buyers’ key sticking points. Study their personalities and try to predict their likely behaviors.

Rule #8: Anticipate.

Consider the likely actions of the buyers and anticipate what they will say and how they will act. Prepare insightful and immediate responses to their likely actions.

Rule #9: Maintain consistency.

Volatility can be very frustrating. Determine what you really want and be consistent on the key issues throughout the negotiations. Effective negotiations normally involve agreement on a series of issues until all issues are resolved. Introducing new issues late in the discussions, or changing positions on resolved issues, can lead to a prompt termination of the negotiation.

Rule #10: Maintain emotional stability.

The best negotiators, like the best poker players, are calm. Delivering your message in a highly emotional state frequently backfires. Appear calm, even if sweat is running down your back and your heart is racing. Winners stay calm.

These 10 rules should significantly help you when you are negotiating the sale of a company or participating in any other major negotiation.

Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Tuesday, May 26, 2015

Using Representations and Warranties Insurance in Mid-Market M&A Deals | Divestopedia

By ,  
Takeaway: Representations and warranties insurance can help facilitate the transaction process while offering business owners a strengthened bargaining position, favorable exit terms, and improved economics.
Using Representations and Warranties Insurance in Mid-Market M&A Deals

The Traditional Negotiation Process

For most entrepreneurs, the negotiation of the purchase and sale agreement (PSA), can be one of the most important - and often taxing - aspects of selling their business. The use of words such as holdback (or escrow) and indemnity can be confusing to many, and yet they remain an integral part of the process. Becoming familiar with these terms is important, and can help the seller navigate the intricacies of the PSA negotiation.

But what happens when the seller confronts an unbridgeable gap between itself and a prospective buyer around indemnification issues? 

Consider the following example

A business owner is looking to sell its textile company for $100MM. A potential buyer submits an offer matching the asking price. In addition to the price however, it asks for an escrow of $10MM to support claims for breaches of seller’s representations and warranties (R&W). The seller is unwilling to leave such a large amount of money in escrow and declines the offer. After further negotiations, and in exchange for a smaller escrow ($5MM), the buyer makes a reduced offer of $90MM. The seller is happy with the smaller escrow, but considers the altered purchase price too low. Negotiations falter and eventually the deal fails.

Negotiations like this on escrow and indemnities occur because the seller, as part of the PSA, makes certain R&W about the condition of the business when the deal is signed. These reps and warranties are essentially assertions of fact - a common one being that the financials of the company have been audited and are in compliance with regulatory standards - which the buyer relies on in valuing the business.

In the event that one of the R&W is inaccurate and such inaccuracy results in a loss post-close, the buyer will seek to recover the loss in value by making an indemnity claim against the escrow. 

R&W Insurance and Its Place in the Transaction Process

R&W insurance steps into this process by providing coverage for liabilities arising from an unknown breach of the R&W by the seller. On the one hand, the seller can backstop its indemnity to the buyer by purchasing R&W insurance in its own name, effectively buying a backstop against an unknown breach. Far more frequently, however the parties will arrange R&W insurance for the benefit of the buyer in lieu all or the better portion of seller’s escrow or indemnity, providing seller with a cleaner exit from the deal.

Purchase of R&W insurance is done on a designated limit and retention level. The limit is the maximum amount the insurance will pay out in the event of a breach of a representation or warranty, while the retention is the loss which must be borne before the insurance comes into effect.
The process for obtaining this type of insurance is fairly straightforward. Typically, an insurance broker will approach the market on behalf of the seller/buyer with information about the transaction and company. After obtaining quotes, including prices and coverage terms, the client will select the offer that best meets its needs. Then begins a process of underwriting during which the insurer examines the risks of the deal and writes the actual R&W policy. The entire sequence can take a few weeks to perform, but can also be completed on an expedited basis in line with the mechanics of the deal. The carrier’s underwriting will consist of a review of the data room and, assuming the insured is the buyer, the entire buyer’s due diligence reports on the target. 

Where R&W Insurance Works/Doesn’t Work

For the seller in a transaction, the use of R&W insurance can provide significant benefits, including:

  1. Lower escrow and indemnities - By placing R&W insurance for a buyer as a proxy for the typical seller indemnity, sellers can shift the risk of unknown breaches to the insurance market for a fixed cost and achieve a greater and more certain return at closing.
  2. Protecting purchase price erosion - Historically, buyers utilizing R&W insurance unbeknownst to a seller would seek a discount on the purchase price in exchange for limiting the escrow and/or indemnity contained in the PSA. However, a seller who takes the initiative by building R&W insurance into the terms of the PSA can eliminate this arbitrage and level the playing field among all potential purchasers, securing the cleanest exit possible without sacrificing purchase price. 
For a buyer, the use of R&W insurance can provide for a more attractive bid to the seller, and the potential to win an asset by providing seller with a cleaner exit than the competition. In today’s market, considering the rapid growth in usage of R&W insurance (particularly in the private equity community) over the past 3-4 years, buyers often need to consider the use of R&W insurance simply to keep pace with their competition for a given asset.

Despite the obvious advantages, there are still some challenges associated with the placement of R&W insurance. In general, the economics of R&W insurance seem to make the most sense for targets with an enterprise value (EV) of approximately 50MM+ (assuming a purchased limit of 10%). While R&W insurance can be placed on deals below that level, and while carriers are attempting to service that end of the market more efficiently, the pricing on such deals may become prohibitively expensive due to minimum premium demands by many carriers.
In addition, risks associated with certain industries are also more difficult to insure, with healthcare billing risk in the US being one such example. It should also be emphasized that R&W insurance is not a replacement for proper due diligence on a deal. A seller or buyer should continue to negotiate the R&W, prepare disclosure schedules and perform due diligence as though insurance were not present in the deal. In the end, R&W insurance does not eliminate risk, but rather transfers some portion of it to an insurer who will require comfort that the deal has been executed professionally, as though the insurance were not a factor. 

Trends in R&W Insurance

As the number of transactions using R&W insurance increases, the terms and prices associated with it will change; while pricing decreased dramatically during the recession years as M&A deals became scarce, leading to renewed interest in the product from many firms, pricing has crept back up a bit as coverage has broadened and demand and usage have increased. As the comfort level with R&W insurance continues to grow among deal professionals and advisors, enterprising sellers understanding the particulars of R&W insurance will be in a favorable position to achieve a better exit for themselves and their businesses, with potentially higher EVs, lower escrows and indemnities, and more control over the negotiation process.

Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.