Showing posts with label business mergers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label business mergers. Show all posts

Sunday, February 26, 2017

How to Create Value in Lower Middle Market Bolt-On Acquisitions | Axial






By , AGI Partners LLC | 


Corporations represent a complicated amalgamation of many components: people, process, products, and stakeholders. This complexity is particularly acute in the lower middle market space, as successful companies are often stretching the capacities of their infrastructure and management resources. Creating value in lower middle market companies involves many layers of decision-making — both daily and longer-term.
Successfully navigating this landscape is more art than science, and requires private equity managers to utilize a flexible approach. In many cases the leadership of lower middle market companies are single entrepreneurs or families, rather than the more developed corporate executive suite typical of a larger company.

Toeing the Line

Part of the conundrum in lower middle market private equity is navigating the line between “strategic improvement” and “destabilizing revolutionary change” at the right time.
Let’s consider a fast-growing B2B services company with multiple national offices. When we consider structuring the accounting department for optimizing cash flow management, we encounter multiple questions. For example, where should the gatekeeper of Accounts Receivable and Accounts Payable be located? Does it make sense to have a single location processing all invoices, streamlining the process, and eliminating redundancies, or should local offices manage their own customers’ receivables and lean on their local relationships with customers and vendors? A similar matter emerges with managing company information systems, where again we debate the metrics of centralization versus developing competency at each office.
In the meantime, another aspect of the problem: the management team may perform best with the way things were done in the past. In these cases, it’s important to consider the repercussions on strategy and culture – in addition to the bottom line – that changing the company structure could bring about. Depending on the situation, it may or may not be worth the disruption.

Balancing Bolt-On Best Practices  

This conundrum becomes even more complicated when platform companies do bolt-on transactions with the aid and capital of private equity sponsors. Best practices call for the acquired company’s legacy system and procedures to be upgraded to match the platform company’s. In this situation, “destabilizing revolutionary change” may fit the bill in order to ensure a successful integration. Successful private equity firms can employ a few tactics to implement these changes:
  • Plan ahead.
A 100-day plan is always a good start in private equity bolt-on acquisitions. A plan with categorized action items, detailed implementation strategy, and necessary steps to achieve them should always be prepared in the early deal process. Some of the key features of a good plan (per each action item) include: involved organizations and responsible leaders, achievable milestone dates, clear goals or visible impact (e.g., economic, organizational), and follow-up protocol for multiple-step items. It is important to let the management of the platform company and the acquired company communicate from an early stage to create a reliable and realistic plan, rather than something last-minute and over-ambitious.
  • Implement a people-based solution.
The lower middle market necessitates nuance and flexibility in the action plan, whether related to management issues such as personal ego and management style, succession matters, divisions between family members, and estate planning, or to business issues such as customer concentration, lower economies of scale, unsophisticated IT solutions, unique payment terms, and others relevant ones in small business. Many companies have typically been run by family members, who are talented, smart, and successful leaders but may not have formal business education. Moreover, post-close changes may require support from multiple organizational layers. Therefore, creating a proper incentive plan matters. Consider setting the management team’s bonus and awards not just on earnings but also on qualitative criteria such as team success and well-executed transition plans.  Finding a right balance between different criteria is also  critical.
Working with the right partner makes all the difference in the lower middle market.  Good private equity managers have learned, sometimes the hard way, the best way to solve problems from their previous investments. The best way to find a great private equity partner is to look at their portfolio companies. Track their performance to date; talk to a management team member of a current or former portfolio company; search for related information in middle market M&A and private equity communities. Great private equity managers know that building a great, lasting enterprise is not always easy, but they are nevertheless excited by the challenge.
Article LINK
For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Thursday, February 23, 2017

When Should Your Company Build Instead of Buy? | Axial





By , VERTESS | 


Is acquisition always the best path for companies looking to grow and accelerate investor value?
Not necessarily.
That answer might sound like heresy coming from an M&A advisor. But though acquisition is often the best answer, it’s not right for every company at every point in time.
“De novo” is a Latin term that is usually translated as “starting anew.” It is used in a wide range of contexts, from our legal system (a new trial with no assumptions based on earlier proceedings) to biology (a mutation that no parent possessed or transmitted). In the world of M+A, it refers to launching and building a new operation based on what you’ve learned in the past.
So when would an ambitious company that is trying to accelerate investor value favor de novo over acquisition?
Here are six circumstances where it makes abundant sense:
1. Strategic Sense: Sometimes investment platforms are built with a plan to grow by replicating their operating model, whether for products, services, or both. They may offer a very unique approach and de novo systems are built to support it.
2. Economics:Investors determine that de novo is more cost effective than acquisition. Considerable financial analysis, where the same time and dollars are applied, may be needed to support this decision.
3. Fragmentation: The market may be very fragmented with largely Mom and Pop companies, so there is often considerable room for best practice innovation by a larger, more established firm with more access to resources and technology. Within healthcare, this is particularly evident in the substance abuse treatment field, where there is a proliferation of small programs that are predominately 12-step-focused.
4. Quality: When a company has a high quality service model with demonstrated results, its leaders may believe that that the only way they can guarantee good outcomes is through de novo. For example, if a company has a dynamic, well-established company culture, it may be easier to replicate this in a new venture rather than try to insert in an existing agency.

5. Too Few Opportunities: Some markets are so new that they lack sufficient acquisition opportunities. In these cases, there is greater upside in de novo than hunting for hidden gems.
6. ROI Challenges: Although good acquisition targets exist, the investment frenzy may have pushed EBITDA multiples beyond a reasonable rate of return. This pushes many investors to the sidelines while others pursue replication through de novo as a more valuable course of action.As advisors, it’s crucial to recognize when and why potential clients may explore alternate options — so we can advise clients on the path that will create the most value for their company and have the greatest impact on their market. Most growing companies embrace, or at least strongly consider, both strategies at different points in their growth trajectory.
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Friday, October 28, 2016

The State of Mid-Market M&A: Q4 2016 | Axial

By , Axial | 
After a record-breaking 2015, M&A activity is on the decline
Worldwide M&A activity for the first nine months of 2016 is down 22% from the same period in 2015, deal-making activity is down 32%, and PE-backed deals are down more than 27%, according to data released by Thomson Reuters.
We checked in with three deal professionals to see how these trends are being felt in the middle market, and get their predictions for the months to come.
Eric Mattson is Principal at Excellere Partners, a private equity firm based in Denver, CO. Mike Richmond is Managing Director at The DAK Group, an investment bank based in New York, NJ, and PA. Arun Prakash is Managing Director at Carbon Arrow Advisors, a consulting firm based in Austin, TX.

What trends have you noticed over the past year? 

“As to be expected in an election year, there’s some of the normal wait-and-see chatter, but there really has not been a discernible new trend that’s developed in the markets we track. Deal flow remains as strong as ever and the quality of the businesses we see are outstanding. Anecdotally, we are hearing from investment bankers and service providers (lawyers, accountants, etc.) that an unusually high number of transactions are failing to close. This is likely a dynamic resulting from some combination of premium pricing (perhaps we’ve hit the peak), uncertainty around the election, under-prepared businesses coming to market, and/or tighter credit markets.”
-Eric Mattson, Excellere Partners
“The deal activity we have seen has been strong all year. We expect this positive activity cycle to continue into 2017. Today, in the middle market, prospective buyers are looking for companies with very specific factors, and are willing to pay for them. Some of these factors include: that they have defensible market positions, stable historical growth, a solid plan for future growth, and that they provide added value to the existing company.” 
-Mike Richmond, The DAK Group

What do you foresee for deal activity and volume in Q4?

“Post-election, we expect to see deal activity pick-up. The wildcard here for private equity is what happens in the debt markets.”
-Eric Mattson, Excellere Partners
“We see 2017 as a very strong year with transaction multiples at or near record highs. Financing will still be readily available, though borrowers may have to work harder to obtain higher leverage and the best terms. M&A volume and valuation trends are cyclical and there is no way to predict how long the favorable environment will last. Business owners considering a future exit strategy may want to begin preparing now if they hope to take advantage of the current climate.” 
-Mike Richmond, The DAK Group

Is there a particular industry in which you foresee a decline in activity? Why?

“Given the concerns over a possible correction, discretionary markets and large capital goods markets could see some deal pressure in the coming quarters.” 
-Eric Mattson, Excellere Partners

Is there a particular industry in which you foresee increased activity? Why?

“Business services. The uneasiness in the economy will affect these companies the most as they tend to be less sticky, so their owners may want to sell.”
-Arun Prakash, Carbon Arrow Advisors
“We are seeing a lot of activity in niche manufacturing, value added distribution and the industrial markets, particularly in the Northeast. In addition, there has been an uptick in all healthcare-related businesses.” 
-Mike Richmond, The DAK Group
“There are number of ‘prognosticators’ who are predicting an economic correction in 2017-18; therefore, the safe bets are in non-cyclicals and those sub-sectors that perform well in tighter markets. In addition, given the unfortunate reality of terrorism here in the US, we see the security and safety market as having a strong tailwind. Since the recovery has not really created a bubble scenario, we’re not overly concerned with the magnitude of a potential correction.”
-Eric Mattson, Excellere Partners

In your opinion, what external forces have shaped or will most significantly shape dealflow in Q4 and 2017?

“Absent a significant geopolitical event that disrupts the global capital markets, or a severe tightening of credit, we’re not seeing anything on the horizon that’s signaling a dramatic change in the M&A markets. PE still has massive amounts of capital to deploy, the public corporations still have growth targets to hit, and mid-market business owners are approaching retirement age at an increasing rate. Therefore, M&A will remain strong for the foreseeable future.”
-Eric Mattson, Excellere Partners
“In 2016, the single factor that has helped M&A activity has been the economic stability of the United States. The economic strength is providing record high amounts of cash being used for investing in acquisitions. This stability has also continued to attract foreign buyers interested in investing here.”
-Mike Richmond, The DAK Group
“If there was one event that would have a major effect on deal flow the next few quarters, it would be whether the Fed raises rates in November or December. If rates go up, overall deal acquisition multiples may decline, which could stall some deals and deal flow. Certainly the election, especially if Trump wins, could have some impact as a result of post-election volatility and uncertainty, but interest rates, in my mind, remain a key driver of financing and multiples and trickle down to affecting deal flow.”
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com.

Tuesday, August 16, 2016

Are We At the Peak of the Sellers’ Market? | Axial

By , The DAK Group | 
The past few years have been an excellent time for business owners to sell and this should continue for at least another year: interest rates are low, private equity firms and strategic buyers have cash to invest and are hungry for acquisitions that will be accretive to their businesses, and there is a lot of interest in US companies from foreign buyers that are willing to pay a higher price to gain access to the US market. Companies that had done the proper preparation, and were ready for sale these past few years have been rewarded with high multiplies.
Are we at the peak of the sellers’ market? The “good times” for selling a mid-market company cannot last forever, but we believe 2016 will continue to be strong. For business owners thinking about an exit strategy, the next 12-18 months may be the best time to take advantage of current market conditions and prepare their companies for a transaction.  We advise owners to “run their business like they will own it forever, but, be prepared to sell it tomorrow.”
As a seller, there are also numerous options to take cash off the table while retaining full or partial control. The partial sale is an ideal option. This allows the business owner to sell a portion of the company, get some cash out of the business, reduce personal risk, yet still be able to help grow and guide the company.  We are seeing both private equity and strategic buyers welcoming the opportunity to invest in an established company providing the resources it needs for growth and maintaining the leadership to provide the vision and operational expertise. Other options include “recaps” which also allows cash off the table while retaining full or partial control.
Preparing for Sale
Buyers in general have a set of value drivers for evaluating a perspective acquisition. For a business owner getting ready to sell their company, a key point is preparation. In order for a business owner to earn the maximum value from the sale of their company, they need to ensure that value driver areas of the company are functioning at the criteria level deemed by the buyer.
There are great opportunities to realize value in today’s market as either a buyer or as a seller. Most sellers do not understand how to run a sales process and identify the “unusual” buyers who will pay a premium price for a business.  Most buyers don’t understand how to unearth businesses on a pre-emptive basis. Find a good advisor who specializes in your size business and take advantage of their advice and experience.
In addition, whether it is to buy or sell a company owners need to do their own due diligence and evaluate the transaction, looking closely at nine critical value drivers to evaluate how “transaction ready” the business is. This helps determine what it is worth to the other side. The factors are:
  1. Sales trends
  2. Profitability recasting
  3. Balance sheet strength
  4. Product differentiation
  5. Depth of management
  6. Customer concentrations
  7. Supplier dependency
  8. Sustainable-adaptable model
  9. Deal killers
How strong a company is in these nine areas will directly determine the value to both the buyer and seller. For sellers, it gives them an opportunity to see where the weaknesses are and do what it takes to strengthen them prior to the sale. For buyers, it lets them also see the weaknesses to determine if they want to make an investment. For both, evaluating these areas will give them leverage at the negotiating table.
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Wednesday, April 6, 2016

Successful Mergers in One Easy Lesson | Axial

By , Rumson Acquisitions | 
There is really only one major consideration that business owners and senior executives need to keep in mind to successfully integrate their acquisitions.  Ready?  Here it is:
Merging two businesses is not like running one bigger one.
That’s it.  No, really, that’s The Key.  If you approach your next deal with that one maxim in mind your chances of a successful integration – and hence a successful investment – will soar.
How could it be that simple?  It’s that simple because your only chance of hitting a target is by aiming properly at the start.  Merging two companies is not about managing growth or managing costs or even managing people; it’s about managing change.  It requires a different focus, different skills, a different timeframe, and a different approach to a host of issues, many of them not readily measurable.
Business owners and C-level executives who assume they can execute a merger in a way that keeps their core business humming (their day jobs), AND prevent the target business from stumbling (an extra day job), AND meld the two of them together with minimal disruption (a completely different job) on their own are kidding themselves. Period.
There is no project that will affect more corners of your company, more of your staff, and more of your outside stakeholders than a merger.  None.  So the odds are that something somewhere will go wrong if you don’t see the integration process for what it is.
Once you’ve accepted the fundamental difference, including the different skills and approaches that are needed, you will be more likely to insist on the right steps and ask the right questions about effective integration.
Let’s look at a few of the key things to do (and not do) as you move into and through the integration:
  • DO NOT view acquisition as a business strategy; in almost all cases it is merely a device or a technique by which you execute a strategy.  DO acquire opportunistically but not outside the bounds of your strategy.  Successful deals start with sensible strategies.
  • DO use that underlying strategy as the basis for your integration priorities and decisions.  And make sure you can articulate the strategy in words of two syllables or less. Remember you are managing change.  Your ability to articulate what the change will entail and why it will be positive will determine whether stakeholders successfully embrace it.
  • DO NOT be misled by the unfortunately common term “post-merger integration.”  If you wait until the transaction has closed to start your integration, you will have wasted precious time and put valuable resources at risk.  DO start your integration in the strategy phase, or at the very latest in the deal structuring and due diligence work.
  • DO decide well ahead of closing day the extent to which you will merge the two companies.  As a general rule, acquisitions that are focused on adding to the buyer’s scale should be integrated fully whereas those aimed at expanding its scope can be integrated more selectively.
  • DO identify the key value drivers that will support your attaining the deal’s strategic intent.  These value drivers will then become rallying cry and measuring tools for your integration team.
  • Speaking of which, DO assemble a dedicated and diverse team (staffed in balance from both companies) to manage the integration process.  Treat them as the biggest value creation vehicle that your company has at this moment.  Put one person in charge who, if at all possible, has no other “day job.”  DO staff the team and fund it for what it is: an insurance policy against the 70-90% failure rate of acquisitions.  If you are not willing to fund a thorough integration process, take the purchase price and put it on red at the nearest casino — your odds of a positive return are better there.
  • DO create a clear and fast channel for integration decision-making so your team doesn’t waste time waiting for answers.
  • DO NOT rely on your lawyers and accountants for all your due diligence needs.  Strategic and operational discovery is the third leg of a comprehensive due diligence process. It will be absolutely essential in determining what to do with your acquisition and how to make the deal actually work.  DO create your own due diligence list built around the strategic intent and the value drivers of the deal, your roadmap for realizing them, and potential surprises that could impair your doing so.
  • DO over-communicate.  The time to guard secrets is not when your company’s work environment is at its most turbulent and your stakeholders are at their most unsure.
  • DO go fast.  Make decisions as quickly as possible.  Faster actions means shorter periods of employee uncertainty and competitive exposure and a swifter translation of strategic intent into return on investment.
  • As a corollary, DO NOT wait for perfect information or the perfect resolution; they don’t exist.  A grade of B+ on a completed and working project is better than an A+ grade on a project that never gets to market.
  • DO identify and take swift action to protect key people and customers on both sides of the deal. These are essential value drivers to achieving the acquisition’s objectives. DO NOT give any of them the excuse of time to walk.
  • DO target a few key metrics to measure your progress against the acquisition’s stated objectives and share that progress regularly around the combined companies.  DO NOT use your company’s default KPIs.  Remember the mantra: you’re merging not running.  Track results that measure the progress against the specific strategic intent and value drivers of the deal.  They will almost always differ from those of the underlying company.
  • DO identify a couple of “quick wins” that can be used to reinforce to all your stakeholders the benefits of the transaction.  DO toot your company’s horn far and wide when the winners come in.  Everyone loves good news.
  • DO take the time to look up from your integration to-do list every so often.  Ask yourself and your team, “What are we missing here? What could be going wrong that we aren’t thinking or hearing about? What opportunities are we missing because we’re too tightly focused on managing the integration process?”
  • Finally, DO NOT be fooled into ending the integration process too soon. Consider the athlete: one of the most frustrating – and dangerous – times is when his injury seems behind him and he wants to quit physical therapy and get back out on the field. Integration is like that.  Be disciplined to stay the course until a reliable, extended and consistent stream of metrics (both financial and otherwise) confirm that the combined business can indeed run itself.  Even in lower and middle market deals, this process usually requires a year or more … but the goal is not return to normal, it’s return on investment.  They’re different.
Like merging two businesses versus running one bigger one.
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.