Showing posts with label pegs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pegs. Show all posts

Thursday, August 10, 2017

Article Summary: Even With Valuations High, PE Sees Strong Exit Environment | Axial

I've pared down the article to the key points.  If you want to read the entire article click the link at the bottom of the summary -- Eric Gall

By , Axial | 
Axial surveyed their PE members for their pulse on the current deal environment. Forty-five middle market investors shared their thoughts.
The Exit Environment

  • 71% say the exit environment was positive in 2016. 
  • 42% said they are waiting until 2017 before selling.
  • Buyers are more likely to be strategic investors (40%) vs. PEGs (33%).
  • In hot industries like healthcare, corporate buyers may justify higher prices due to expected synergies
  • 2/3rds expecting to sell to strategic buyers expect to do more deals with private companies vs. publicly traded corporations. 
  • 20% believe their next buyer will be a fundless or independent sponsor, who have become increasingly active in the middle market. 
Deal Dynamics

  • 69% will deploy more or the same amount of capital into add-on and platform investments.
  • Many middle market investors are moving down market looking to smaller add-on companies.
  • Co-investments is increasing between PE, family offices, or other PE shops to partner on a deal.  31% will complete more co-investment deals.  
  • Generalist investors with a broad industry/sector mandate are more likely to complete co-investments this year (38%) compared to specialists (20%).


Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Monday, November 28, 2016

The New Buyer Landscape: Q&A With Private Equity and Strategic Acquirers | Axial



By , Axial | 

There is a diverse environment of investors today, each with different goals and strategies. At the 2015 Axial Concord, a recent panel of investors discussed what sellers and others in the industry should know about different types of potential buyers.
Here are a few excerpts from the conversation.
Q: Can private equity add as much value as other types of buyers?
A: “Every PE firm tells every seller that they can add more value than everyone else can,” said Brandon Hinkle, vice president at Kovitz Private Holdings, a Chicago firm. He added sarcastically: “And yes, we can add more value than anyone else.”
Kidding aside, Hinkle noted that as a private equity holding company, his firm offers unique opportunities for sellers. “What differentiates a private equity holding company from a traditional PE fund is that we don’t have an investment horizon. Sometimes private equity isn’t the best fit for certain companies. We like capital intensive businesses, but traditional funds may not because the return on investment may not happen for 5-7 years. As a holding company, we can think long-term. We have not only financial engineers, but also operating partners that can help the company think tactically and strategically about the future.”
Q: What are the qualitative considerations that go into an acquisition decision?
A: Strategics look carefully at culture, according to another panelist, the CEO of a manufacturing company and strategic acquirer. “We’re looking for a management team that has a similar vision for where the industry and its products are heading.” Strategics evaluate at the ability of the acquisition’s management team to grow and adapt — with the right team, there are countless opportunities for synergies.
For both small and large cap businesses, “you need to have both fit and finances. If the numbers don’t work, the deal won’t work. If fit isn’t there, the financials will fall apart quite rapidly,” said the CEO.
Armando Soto, managing director of private investment firm Isaac Capital, agreed. “Partnerships are very important to us and we have to make sure that everyone sees the deal through the same lens. When we look at companies, we’re looking for a marriage. Otherwise, the deal goes downhill pretty fast.”

Q: At what point in the deal process do you start thinking about integration? 

A: “The first day,” said Kovitz’s Hinkle. The panelists agreed that failing to do so could have a negative impact on valuations.
“One of the conversations that we have up front is do we want to make this a branded house or a house of brands?” said Hinkle. “Think about Apple’s branding strategy vs. Kellogg’s. Is it better to keep the brands siloed or bring them together under one name? If the latter, we look at the software compatibility first. I don’t know if that’s strategically the right place to start — but we won’t put the two companies together until the systems can talk to one another with no errors. Otherwise invoices can’t be sent, basic things can’t happen.”
According to Soto, “we typically let our platforms take a look first to evaluate whether there’s a fit. We take a step back from the process and rely on our management teams to make that happen. We’re investors, not operators. If you asked me to integrate a company I’d probably destroy it. We know what we’re good at and what we’re not.”
Q: What’s your view of the current M&A market?
A: “We’re seeing low interest rates for the next couple years,” said Soto. “This is a good thing for us, obviously. From a macroeconomic standpoint, the U.S. is in a strong position to continue growing because of the strong dollar — making the raw materials we’re sourcing overseas a lot cheaper and adding money to the bottom line.
“The M&A market overall seems to ebb and flow depending on the industry,” said Soto. “We try to look at everything from a macroeconomic standpoint and forecast where the markets are going and what the next big market will be.”
For example, Soto said, “Five years ago we were looking at healthcare, and no one else was — but now everyone’s in healthcare. We started going into manufacturing and industrials at the beginning of the year, and now in the fourth quarter, it seems like the space is heating up.”
Q: What are you worried about?
A: Kovitz’s Hinkle said he worries increasingly about the “acceleration of tech,” which can be hard to predict, and how it will impact popular industries. “For example, there have been a lot of plastics related businesses for sale. Why is that? How will new technology like 3D printing impact those and other businesses?”
The strategic acquirer on the panel agreed. “One of our biggest challenges is buying for the future vs. buying for the past. As a strategic acquirer, you know what’s working out there. It’s important to make sure though that you’re buying for the capabilities of the future as opposed to what would have made you successful five to 10 years ago.”
Q: How much do you think you should pay up front, if at all, for value that could be added post closing?
A: “It really depends,” said Soto. “It depends on the business and what the management team can bring to the table.”
“We struggle with this more than anything,” Hinkle said. “As a private equity firm we try to avoid paying up for value we create post close, but what I’ve generally heard is that strategic buyers will pay 20% of the value they think they can create if it’s a business they really want. ”
The strategic acquirer agreed. “The short answer is I don’t want to pay for anyone else. I want to pay for my own synergies. The real question is, is the target bringing value or are we? That’s where the negotiation lies.”
Article LINK
For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Sunday, November 27, 2016

How Does the Public Market Affect Private Equity? | Axial



By  | 


History suggests that a rising public market is good for private capital fundraising, but bad for private equity returns.
Mid-market PE investors and dealmakers will likely see frequency and volume increase when the public market is healthy, but they’ll also experience lower multiples on the back end, according to research from the National Bureau of Economic Research and Ohio State University. The silver lining is that PE-backed firms are more likely to succeed in a public offering during bull markets.
During 2014, bullish public equities grew at a fast clip. The Dow rose a healthy 7.5%, distantly trailing the S&P (11.4%) and Nasdaq (13.4%). Predictably, private equity fund-raising was strong and we saw a record year for exits. By early 2015, it was clear that private capital markets were flush with cash and returns leveled off.
It remains to be seen how PE markets will respond to turmoil in Asia or a reluctant U.S. monetary policy. Public markets slid across the globe after the Shanghai Index bubble popped in June and lost nearly a third of its value by August. Among the unconcerned is Theodore Koenig, CEO of Monroe Capital, who confidently predicted that August turmoil “will not affect middle-market financing at all.”
Even if Koenig is right, private market participants should keep an eye on public market volatility; struggles on the exchanges may leave room for opportunity.
Opportunity Costs and Basic Economics
Private equity investors, on the whole, lack a suitable method to internalize public market dynamics when making decisions. The most popular measure of private equity fund performance is probably the Multiple on Invested Capital, or MOIC. It’s a simple, easy-to-understand number that investors can make comparisons with. A $500,000 investment that returns $5,000,000 has a MOIC of 10x, for example.
But MOIC doesn’t — and can’t — tell the investor what would have happened if that $500,000 was instead used to buy shares of AAPL or left in an S&P 500 ETF. In other words, MOIC doesn’t highlight the opportunity costs.
Cambridge Associates offers one proprietary measure, the modified public market equivalent(mPME), which pretends that a PE investment has instead purchased a basket of publicly traded investments. If the private fund’s return exceeds the mPME return, the private fund has added value. Bain Capital reports as of June 2014, US buyout funds underperform the S&P 500 mPME for investment horizons under five years but overperform for 10- and 20-year horizons.
To the extent that public securities compete with private capital, basic economics tells us that declining prospects in the stock market should make private capital more attractive, but PE investor behavior appears to follow the opposite pattern; capital calls and distributions are more frequent and more valuable when public equities rise. It seems general market optimism is a boon to all capital markets in the short run, but higher asset prices tend to push down IRRs in the long run.

Strength in PE-Backed Mid-Market IPOs
It’s not immediately clear how PE investors benefit from retroactively knowing opportunity costs. Even when the public middle market is humming, private equity is comparatively illiquid; money invested in a venture one day can’t be thrown into stocks the next day. But PE firms have one clear way to take advantage of bull markets: Take their companies public and look for an exit before the market declines again.
This is exactly what mid-market PE-backed companies did last year. In fact, CohnReznick research reported that nearly two-thirds (64%) of middle market IPOs were backed by private capital sources in 2014, and that those offerings brought in greater than $18 billion. If an IPO exit is the end game for a fund, then investors should welcome a healthy — or even speculative — public market. 
Finding Trends in Public Markets
There are several different ways to gauge public market sentiment. One favorite is the Chicago Board of Options Exchange’s Volatility Index (VIX, which reflects a “minute-by-minute snapshot of expected stock market volatility over the next 30 calendar days.” Theoretically, a long-term rising VIX should discourage public market activity and (possibly) encourage private market activity if owners are persuaded to sell and lock in gains.
When trouble from China upset global equity markets in July, the VIX shot up 80% in a matter of weeks. The Dow dropped 6.2% during the next month — a move essentially mirrored by the Nasdaq and S&P — while public market concerns rose again when the Fed declined to raise interest rates in September.
Buyouts have historically tended to rise and fall with public equities, but there is reason to believe that the spread between private and public IRR grows when the public markets struggle. This coincides with the largest middle market in United States history (at least 360,000 operating firms), 75% of which reported increased revenue growth in the first half of 2015. History says that some capital will opt to sit on the sidelines with a volatile market, but the fundamentals in the lower end of the middle market suggest there are still plenty of opportunities for value-add investments.
Article LINK
For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Sunday, May 29, 2016

The Ins and Outs of Spins | Axial Forum

Eric's comments:  Having executed several spin-offs, without question, they can be a great way to unlock hidden value and maximize your return.  Specifically:
  1. The spin-off and remaining company likely have different strategic buyers.
  2. The remaining company often has little value to the spin-offs strategic buyer, i.e., there is added cost to them to carry or eventually spin-off that portion of the company in the future.
  3. The remaining company's value is enhanced through contractual obligations with the spin-off's buyer and greater clarity from it's eventual buyer.
By  | 

For strategic buyers and private equity funds in search of quality targets, acquiring only a portion of a company through a spin-off can end up being a good proposition. Spin-offs are independent businesses created through a sale or a distribution of new shares of a parent company’s existing division (for main street and lower middle-market companies, spin-offs can also be executed as asset sales).

These deals are on the rise. Equity research firm The Edge expects $1.5 trillion worth of global parent companies to 
execute spin-offs in 2015, over double 2014’s figure. Furthermore, the firm projects the value of these global transactions to reach $3 trillion by 2016.

Domestically, The Edge expects an 18% increase in spin-off transactions, with around 40 to 42 US parent companies spinning off this year. This is compared to 34 transactions by U.S. parents last year.

What’s behind this upward momentum? Many companies and investors have realized that businesses can garner higher valuations if they are independently owned. Shareholder activists have also been exerting pressure on parent companies to maximize their worth through these transactions.

Going It Alone and Flourishing

Recent successful spin-offs have also boosted their appeal. Consider retail bank holding company Citizens Financial Group, which spun off from parent company the Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS). Before its separation, the regulatory pressures and subprime fallout that RBS was undergoing reportedly hindered Citizen’s growth. But after Citizens’ September 2014 initial public offering, the bank has been expanding its commercial lending and other businesses.

Taking Shareholders for a Spin

Spin-offs have also become a popular way for companies to increase shareholder value. The current low interest rate environment has motivated many firms to spin off income-producing assets. “This is particularly evident in the energy sector, where companies have routinely spun off assets into master limited partnerships (MLPs), and for companies with substantial real estate holdings as they have spun off assets into real estate investment trusts (REITs),” said Shaival Patel, a director in event driven equities at The Spin-Off Report, a publication authored by Horizon Kinetics and PCS Research Services.

A recent example from the energy sector is California-based Sempra Energy’s plan to separate its liquefied natural gas business into an MLP called Sempra Partners. In healthcare, Ventas has spun off most of its skilled nursing and rehabilitation facilities into a new REIT named Care Capital Properties.

It’s All About the Margins

On top of increasing shareholder value, buyers can also look forward to rising profits when they acquire a spin-off.

According to Patel, margin growth usually becomes part of the new company’s overall strategy, and there are often opportunities for shareholders to purchase a low-margin business, with margin expansion being a key part of the growth story.

For instance, when military shipbuilder Huntington Ingalls Industries was spun off from security firm Northrop Grumman, it had 6% operating margins; it was able to grow those margins to upwards of 8% in a relatively short time.

Running a Tight Ship

Aside from the promise of higher margins, a spin-off’s independence is a key advantage for investors seeking to acquire a well-run target. As a streamlined firm with established leadership, a spin-off allows management to have a laser focus on a single business area.
“In buying a spin-off, there is a greater probability that the company has been ‘polished up’ and gained credibility since an enhanced and ‘public company ready’ leadership team will have been put in place and things like contracts and key processes tidied up,“ said George Budden, a partner at Deloitte.

Not All Hunky-Dory

However, the process of buying spin-offs is not always easy, specifically for smaller-cap firms.

Challenges include retaining employees used to working in a larger organization that offers brand prestige and more career mobility. Adapting information technology to a smaller firm that has basic systems might also present problems. Additionally, the new company’s back office infrastructure might not be ready for independence from the previous owner.
Getting in Early

Despite these setbacks, there are things investors can do to make the acquisition process more seamless. For instance, when buying a spin-off, get in early.

“A good time to buy a business is just before it is spun off as the buyer can get involved in the cleanup process and avoid the added cost of having a new, heavyweight board; unwinding the stock exchange listing; and experiencing shareholder issues that might come up post spin,” Deloitte’s Budden said.

Taking initiative is also is key. Smaller buyers in particular have a better chance of landing a desired acquisition if they proactively engage companies that own assets they are interested in. “Small-cap firms can use a spin-off idea as a way to open a discussion about a division they want to acquire,” Budden said.

Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.