Showing posts with label recapitalizations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label recapitalizations. Show all posts

Monday, December 5, 2016

How to Prevent Failed Mergers | Axial

By  | 
Private equity-driven M&A deals have an embarrassingly low success rate. This is understood within the industry, at least on a colloquial level — it’s commonplace to hear off-the-cuff numbers that 50% of proposed deals fall through, even when both sides agree it’s a money maker.
Except it’s worse than that. The Harvard Business Review suggests the real figure is closer to 90%. A McKinsey study concluded the failure rate was between 66% and 75%. (This isn’t an isolated product of the American regulatory environment, either; the Global Times reported that only 2,500 of about 7,000 declared deals were completed in China in 2014, for a failure rate of 64%.)
Of course, it’s not enough to complete the merger. There are still businesses to run, products and services to produce, and customers to satisfy. One KPMG study found that 83% of M&A deals fail to boost shareholder returns. Eighty-three percent!
The number one killer of M&A deals is a “failure to integrate effectively,” according to a survey of executives by Deloitte. Fifty-five percent of respondents cited integration as a top area of concern, and 54% called integration a top area of concern before pursuing a deal. This means that firms know ahead of time that integration is a huge challenge, but two out of three mergers fail anyway.
Why is integration such a problem? Some of the problems are strategic, i.e., how the firm approaches integration and identifies success. Others are tactical, such as how and when to inform staff of key decisions.
Start Thinking About Integration Yesterday
Sage Harrison is a principal at private equity firm Evolve Capital, an Axial member, which specializes in leveraged recapitalizations. “Because we’re partnering with founders, the integration plan is sketched out while we’re in diligence and almost always involves getting a CFO involved in the company from day one while assessing the human capital needs and defining the growth strategy.”
At a fundamental level, mergers occur because there is an opportunity to realize some yet-untapped value. “Growth is our number one priority,” says Harrison. But realizing (and maximizing) that value requires buy-in from everyone, and planning for that buy-in should start just as early as planning finance or legal.
“We expend a lot of effort refining the growth strategy. This involves analysis around the company’s brand, target customers, competition, and sales,” says Harrison. “Often times the companies we invest in have a very strong product or service but everything customer facing needs work.”

Integration means more than just running through standard M&A processes, checklists, PowerPoint templates, and risk-avoidance lectures. Take this opportunity to practice some empathy for all of those whose lives are about to change in uncertain ways. Make sure you understand if/how the IT systems can talk to one another; effective integration relies on effective communication between humans and systems alike. The earlier a firm thinks strategically about these issues, the more prepared it will be when it comes time to execute.
The nice thing about starting early is you can afford to start simply. Harrison’s basic philosophy: “Focus on the easiest things that will produce the biggest impact first.”

Businesses Are Made of People, Not Numbers
Growing a business means paying attention to the financials, but also understanding that those numbers reflect the efforts and passion of real people. Shareholders, board members, directors, employees, vendors, customers — these people are the real building blocks of any successful M&A.
For example, the owners and/or founders of the target firm will have to yield some power — a stressful adjustment. Customers will worry about changes to the products and services they’ve become accustomed to. Employees fear job loss or the cultural impact of new leadership. “Many employees associate ‘synergies’ with ‘people getting fired,’” says Brandon Hinkle, vice president at Kovitz Private Holdings, an Axial member.
“Many people are generally afraid of the unknown, and flight risk must be thought through,” says Hinkle. “Pride, ego, fear, jealousy, excitement, anxiety — these are all emotions you’ll likely see from folks during most integrations. If a few key folks become disenchanted, the machine can fall apart.”
Know How to Build on Success
Effective M&A teams know how to avoid operational missteps, build on success, and keep the good times rolling.
“I’m a huge believer in momentum,” says Harrison. “You can feel it while watching or playing sports but you can also feel it inside of a company.” Momentum means hitting goals and generating enthusiasm about the project in an uncontrived way. It means elevating the collective performance to a level beyond a group of individuals. “When we invest in a company, everyone involved believes it’s a catalyst for growth. It’s a great time to reexamine the strategy, the brand, and the sales effort.”
The first step is creating a firm direction and maintaining the focus to carry it out as planned. Everyone in the C-Suite has a role to play in an M&A transaction; leadership is responsible for providing strategic vision, executing on details, mapping out the integration plan, and more.
The employees also “need to buy in to help effectuate the integration successfully,” stresses Hinkle. Prior to close, “keeping the integration on a need-to-know basis to prevent the rumor mill from swirling is usually a good idea.” Once the integration is announced, employees need to hear that their jobs are safe and their work is appreciated (assuming it’s the truth). Hinkle suggests that “employment agreements and non-competes can provide helpful piece of mind.” Everyone should expect to work towards — and share in — the new vision and successes.

Article LINK
For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Monday, January 11, 2016

Don’t leave the fate of your closely held business to chance | Baltimore Business Journal

Dec 29, 2015, 7:16am EST
As a Baltimore business owner, you are part of a long tradition of home-grown success stories.
Consider McCormick & Co. Inc., which started out in Baltimore in 1889 when founder Willoughby McCormick began selling flavors and extracts door to door.



Perhaps your personal and financial goals are to establish a legacy as long asWilloughby McCormick’s. More likely, your goals may be to fund a comfortable retirement, and perhaps leave a legacy for your children.
In any case, if you are counting on your ownership interest in your closely held business to help meet your goals, you would be well advised to consider adopting a buy-sell agreement or BSA for your business in order to preserve the business’ viability.
The agreements prevent control from passing to unwelcome and potentially disruptive parties. They also help make sure you — or your estate— receive a fair price for your interest in the business on your retirement or death.
As time goes by, one of the most fundamental threats to preserving a closely held business’s value is the risk of ownership interests passing to individuals who will disrupt the smooth operation of the business. By way of example, following the death of an owner, his or her children might acquire an ownership interest through inheritance.
Should some of those children elect not to take an active role in the business, there may be clashes among the resulting owners on issues where their respective interests are not aligned, such as whether to distribute or reinvest profits. Needless to say, this type of turmoil can have a corrosive effect on the ongoing viability and value of a business.
Your business' buy-sell agreement could mitigate this risk by placing restrictions on transfers of ownership interests. These restrictions typically take the form of “rights of first refusal” given to the business, or current owners, to purchase the interest of a withdrawing or deceased owner at an established price. Where the rights are given to current owners, they may be allocated equally or tailored to specific situations.
Rights of first refusal are very useful to preserve your business’s ongoing viability, but they do not require anyone to purchase your ownership interest upon your death or retirement. This leaves open the additional risk that upon your death your estate will be forced to either negotiate a sale of your ownership interest from a position of weakness, or postpone any sale and risk a liquidity crisis when estate taxes become due and/or your surviving family members require funds for their support. This could severely reduce the value of your legacy to your family.
Your BSA could mitigate this risk as well, by empowering you to negotiate in advance the price that will be paid for your interest upon your retirement or death and imposing a mandatory purchase obligation on the business, or remaining owners, to buy your interest at the established price.
By establishing who will buy a withdrawing or deceased owned interest well in advance of a purchase, your business’ BSA could have the added benefit of giving the designated buyer time to plan how to fund the purchase. A common funding strategy is for the designated buyer to purchase life insurance on each owner, and upon the death of an owner use the insurance proceeds to purchase the deceased owner’s interest.
This approach is particularly appropriate where it is uncertain whether the buyer will have sufficient funds to purchase a deceased owner’s interest. Your advisers can help determine who should be the designated buyer under your BSA and the funding option that is most advantageous for you.
Your advisers should also help you select the method for determining the purchase price of a withdrawing owner’s share — a critically important question. A simple approach is to set a fixed price with provisions for periodic price renegotiation, since the value of the business is likely to change over time. But watch out: you may neglect to renegotiate the price until a buyout is triggered.
At this point, your bargaining leverage may be weak, resulting in a lower renegotiated purchase price than the interest’s value. Another option is a buy-out formula tied to a financial measure, such as your business’ book value, net earnings, or cash flow. Whether any of these financial measures constitutes an appropriate price setting approach depends on the circumstances and nature of your business.
While setting a fixed price or utilizing a financial measure has the benefit of expediency, your BSA could alternatively call for engaging a professional appraiser. This can provide a greater degree of comfort that the purchase price reflects current market conditions. Under this approach, your BSA could specify the minimum credentials for an appraiser and how the appraiser will be selected.
By protecting against loss of control of your business to outsiders and setting a fair price for each withdrawing owner’s interest, your business’ BSA could help to preserve the value of your hard-earned investment, which will be critical for maintaining your quality of life in retirement and protecting your financial legacy for your family. Note that any strategy should be based on the business owner’s objectives, and services of professional advisers should be sought.

Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Wednesday, October 7, 2015

BUSINESS BROKER VS. M&A INTERMEDIARY | Business Brokerage Press

Decent article below.  My editorial comments:

An M&A Intermediary requires a much stronger financial skill set.  In addition to understanding EBITDA, you must be able to calculate Free Cash Flow, determine Cost of Capital, and calculate Net Present Value of Free Cash Flow.  The vast majority of Business Brokers will be lost when asked to provide this information.

An M&A Intermediary requires a much greater comfort level working with C-Level executives, Private Equity Groups, Attorneys and CPAs.  For example, smaller business owners may or may not have a business attorney.  An M&A Intermediary may work with the Seller's and Buyer's business attorneys, environmental attorneys, Tax Attorneys, etc..  Deal structure is also significantly different.  Business Brokers manage outright sales to individuals.  M&A Intermediaries may do an outright sale, handle investments, recapitalizations, mergers, reverse mergers, etc..  Managing the process, deal structure and egos is significantly more complex.

And now the article...



We often get asked what the difference is between the Business Broker and the M&A Intermediary. We went to our archives to see if we could find an article or two on the subject. We found two articles written by Russ Robb, a very successful M&A practitioner.

Russ’s thoughts on what a business broker does.

They generally represent companies under $3 million in sales.
1) Normally they do not require a retainer to list the business, but their commission as a percentage of sales can be up to twice the Lehman or modified Lehman formula. Business brokerage listing agreements are predominately for a twelve-month exclusive period, which is longer than M&A intermediaries.
2) Business brokers generally list the asking price plus inventory and a suggested down payment. Brokers frequently advise the seller to withdraw the cash post closing and/or peg the working capital at zero. Middle market intermediaries generally do not operate this way.
3) Brokers will often times base the company’s price on rules of thumb for particular businesses and/or a multiple of sellers’ discretionary earnings, which are earnings, owner’s salary, all owner’s compensation and perks. The theory is that the acquirer is in essence “buying a job” so the focus is on total personal return on investment.
4) Balance sheets are not usually provided as the sales price is generally predicated on assets such as goodwill, plus fixtures and equipment being sold on a free and clear basis.
Quite a few business brokers move up to the larger companies with sales, for example, from $2 to $20 million. The acquirers are more apt to be corporate buyers who are accustomed to using different valuation metrics, i.e., multiple of EBITDA with some but not all add-backs to earnings.
A Second Article
Russ also did an article for his book, ”Selling Middle Market Businesses: Guide Book for Intermediaries (available through BBP at www.businessbrokeragepress.com) with the following list of differences between a general business broker and an M&A intermediary.
The business broker generally sells businesses $100,000 to $3 million made up of retail stores, food establishments and small service businesses. The documentation consists of a minimal or short write-up. The buyers are generally local individuals. The compensation is generally no retainer and a commission of 10% to 12%. The business brokers use the internet, email and local advertising to sell the businesses and carry a much larger inventory of businesses for sale. The listing period usually ranges from 6 months to 12 months. Confidentiality is extremely tight with visits often made after hours. Financial information usually consists of profit and loss statements, tax returns or unaudited figures. The decision maker is almost always the owner. The sale from listing to closing is approximately six months.
Now for the M&A intermediary. The sale price can range from $3 million up. The types of businesses sold are manufacturers, distributors, wholesalers and large service operations. The documentation is generally a 30 to 50 page Offering Memorandum. The buyers are private equity groups, strategic buyers and both national and international companies. A retainer is almost always required with a minimum fee of $150,000 plus; usually some form of the Lehman formula which is 5% of the first $100,000, 4% of the second $100,000 etc. The method of selling is a controlled auction for buyers, focused direct mailing and the use of in-house buyer lists – all generally specific industry focused. As opposed to the use of last year’s P&L, M&A deals require extensive financial analysis.
One area not mentioned in the material we reviewed is the number of outside professionals that get involved in the M&A deal.
Interestingly, Russ made a comment that says it all. “A business broker moving up the food chain should try not to be overwhelmed with the challenge of properly representing mid-market companies for sale. He or she should not be intimated just because the deal is larger or because the level of sophistication is greater., particularly if the broker has the following attributes:
• A successful track record of closing deals
• An engaging personality with candor and honesty; after all, business is in large part about people skills.
• An ability to successfully solicit and sign up new clients (listings).”
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.