Showing posts with label Documentation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Documentation. Show all posts

Sunday, August 21, 2016

Earnouts or Burnouts: Don't Get Burned on an Earnout | Divestopedia

Takeaway: Earnouts are difficult legal clauses to manage and can often lead to misunderstanding and difficulty realizing them. Here is a practical example of some of the pitfalls that sellers should watch for.
Earnouts or Burnouts: Don't Get Burned on an Earnout
Source: Ra2Studio/Dreamstime.com















Earnout clauses are becoming more and more common in purchase and sale agreements, especially in a volatile economy or where the target company’s earnings have fluctuated over past years. There are many risks associated with earnouts and if their provisions are not properly drafted in the definitive agreement, then the seller stands a good chance of getting burned.
Here is an example of where a seller can get burned on an earnout:

Pre-Sale Background

OPCO is a company which is comprised of two divisions: Division A, which provides services to customers; and Division B, which sells goods complementary to its services. The revenue streams from these two divisions can be broken down as follows:
  • Division A (services) - $900,000 of OPCO Revenues
    • High margin (large) clients ($700,000)
    • Low margin (small) clients ($200,000)
  • Division B (goods) - $100,000 of OPCO Revenues
Mr. A buys all of the shares in OPCO from Mr. B. Contained in the share purchase agreement is a very basic earnout clause which states, in so many words, that if OPCO meets certain revenue targets during the earnout period, then Mr. B will be entitled to an earnout amount from Mr. A. The earnout period in this example is one year. As with most earnouts, the revenue target was an ambitious number based largely on a three-year average of historical revenues. In order to meet this target, OPCO would need to run lean and have a solid year of earnings.

Post-Closing

Mr. A, like many entrepreneurs, has big plans for OPCO. Coming from a sales background, he sees tremendous opportunities for growth in Division B by selling more goods to OPCO’s existing customer base and new customers alike; he sees this as a long-term growth strategy. As with most small businesses, time and resources are not unlimited and to expend more time and resources in one division of a business would necessitate less time and resources in another division.

So, immediately upon acquiring ownership of OPCO, Mr. A implements his marketing plan for Division B growth and allocates more resources and personnel to Division B, pulling these additional resources and personnel from the low margin portion of Division A. This is an easy decision for Mr. A because, although the low margin portion of Division A contributed to 20 percent of OPCO’s revenues, it also consumed more than 30 percent of the company's resources and personnel.

During the earnout period, Mr. A is successful at growing Division B revenues by $50,000. In contrast, because the resources required to support this growth were taken from Division A, it suffers a $100,000 decline in revenues. This results in a $50,000 decline in overall revenues during the earnout period, OPCO not meeting its revenue target, and Mr. B, therefore, not receiving his earnout amount. In hindsight, it was quite foreseeable that OPCO would have met its revenue target had Mr. A operated OPCO the way Mr. B had operated it historically and not taken a gamble on Division B.

Mr. A's gamble did not pay off immediately, at least not within the earnout period. While OPCO may have experienced substantial Division B growth in the following years as a result of Mr. A’s efforts, none of this is relevant to Mr. B and he paid the price for Mr. A's long-term growth strategy.

How Can This be Prevented?

In the case at hand, the share purchase agreement contained your most basic earnout clause, which is common, especially on smaller transactions,because neither the buyer’s nor the seller’s budget permits the drafting of a more comprehensive earnout clause. Some things that a seller (Mr. B in this case) can do to minimize the likelihood of getting burned on an earnout include:

Post-Closing Covenants

The first option is to include more comprehensive earnout language in the share purchase agreement and impose post-closing covenants with the buyer. These post-closing covenants would seek to restrict the way in which the buyer can operate the business during the earnout period. These types of post-closing covenants might include, but are not limited to, the following:
  • Restricting the buyer from conducting the business in such a manner that it is reasonably foreseeable that the business could be negatively impacted in a material way (such as shifting resources in the manner set out in the example above).
  • Restricting the buyer from permitting any material change to the business or its financial or accounting methods (such as by combining financial reporting with an affiliate company).
  • Restricting the buyer’s ability to strip assets or divisions out of OPCO (such as by transferring the operations of one division to an affiliate company).
  • Restricting the buyer's ability to terminate the employment of any key employees.
  • Requiring the buyer to continue to operate the business in the ordinary course of business.

Reverse Earnout

Draft the earnout as a reverse earnout. In contrast to a regular earnout where the payment of the earnout amount is deferred to the end of the earnout period, with a reverse earnout the amount is paid to the seller on closing and then adjusted downward if OPCO doesn't meet its revenue targets. The benefit of a reverse earnout is that it places the burden on the buyer to pursue the seller for a refund of the earnout amount. If the seller has any legitimate defenses to this, such as the buyer breaching its post-closing earnout covenants, it will make it the buyer's responsibility to take further steps (e.g. court action) to recover this amount. Depending on how comprehensively the provisions are drafted, a standalone earnout agreement might better serve your purposes.

In Conclusion, It's Always Best to Get Some Advice

As you can see, there are ways to protect yourself if you are a seller that is subject to an earnout piece of your selling price. Retaining legal counsel that is experienced in these types of transactions will benefit you tremendously by ensuring that your earnout language protects you as much as possible from the scenario above and the many other scenarios where the buyer intentionally or inadvertently fails to meet its revenue targets.

Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Sunday, September 6, 2015

Minimizing Inevitable Risks in the Sale Process | Divestopedia

English: Medal For diligence 1 st (Ministry of...
Medal For diligence
(Photo credit: Wikipedia)
By ,  
Takeaway: To ensure that the window of vulnerability is as short as possible, it’s critical to thoroughly prepare for a structured, competitive transaction process.
From the moment you make initial contact with any potential bidder to the time you close a sale transaction there is a window of vulnerability where you and your business are exposed to three inevitable risks:
  • Completion Risk
  • Valuation Risk
  • Damage to Your Business by Potential Bidders
A key objective of any effective sale process is to shorten this window of vulnerability as much as possible. The following outlines effective strategies to mitigate all three of these risks and execute an M&A process that exposes your business to potential bidders for the shortest length of time possible.

Ensure your business is prepared for due diligence

Whether your business will be considered by multiple bidders simultaneously or a single bidder, it’s critical that you prepare comprehensive due diligence information in way that can be easily reviewed by bidders’ due diligence teams. If the information provided is incomplete, incoherent or internally inconsistent, you will quickly find yourself and your team overwhelmed with additional information requests to provide clarifications. As a result, the information preparation can become disorganized and reactive. Although you can’t predict everything that a bidder may request a priority, take care to prepare and compile comprehensive due diligence documentation. Host it with a reputable VDR provider to ensure secure and efficient dissemination of information to bidders. Attending to this in detail before the sale process is launched will accelerate due diligence and effectively minimize your window of vulnerability.
It’s also important to ensure your team is equipped with the necessary bench strength for efficient turnaround of requested information. In spite of your best efforts, a potential acquirer will inevitably ask for information that wasn’t compiled previously, so make sure your company’s point of contact can provide these deliverables.

Create competitive tension

Competitive tension among multiple bidders gives you leverage in the form of strategic choice, while diversifying buyer-specific completion risk. Value, after all, is in the eye of the beholder, and there are often one or two outliers in a competitive process who see more value in a business than others. A controlled, competitive process surfaces the best potential acquirers and instills a sense of urgency for them to move quickly and win the auction over a competitor. The benefit is twofold: you reap a greater value for your business and enjoy an accelerated transaction process that is propelled by competitive pressure.

Set deadlines and provide clear instructions to bidders

While it is not advisable to provide bidders with a timeline that maps the process from start to close, to maintain the pace of the process and minimize wasted time due to miscommunications, it is critical to set our clear next steps for bidders a few weeks out. This includes setting realistic deadlines and enforcing them. It also means making the process requirements clear, particularly the communications protocols and providing a comprehensive process letter that clearly states what each bid must contain to be considered.

Cull the herd

A well-designed process has multiple hurdles for bidders to clear, staging the flow of information so that only the most serious parties receive your most sensitive information. This culling process also has positive effects on the speed of the most labor-intensive aspects of the due diligence process. The slowest, and potentially problematic, parties will struggle with deadlines and be eliminated from the process as a result.

Find somebody who has done it before

Having access to someone who is experienced in the sale process, particularly in private equity transactions, will prove invaluable. Whether this is a trusted friend, a colleague or a professional advisor, access to somebody who has “seen this movie before” will minimize transaction risk from the start. They can lend important insights about how to reach the right potential buyers while minimizing execution risks and potential information leaks. A trusted expert can also facilitate an efficient transaction process by identifying potential deal issues ahead of time and developing mitigation strategies for each.
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.