Showing posts with label venture capital. Show all posts
Showing posts with label venture capital. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 3, 2016

“What I Wish I Knew Before Selling My Business” | Axial

By , Axial | 

Entrepreneur Chad Elms spent most of his childhood in Stephenville, Texas, the self-proclaimed Cowboy Capital of the World, “making things and trying to sell them for money.”

He came from a family of cowboys and business owners — his grandparents started a western wear store in the 1950s that his parents later took over. Chad got his start in business fashioning braided key chains and leather decorations for cowboy boots festooned with beads and conchos and silver — “things you’d never see anywhere but the country.”
But when he grew up, he decided to go into physical therapy, in part to keep his cowboy relatives healthy, he says, only half-joking. Still, “that entrepreneurial spirit was always there.”
When Chad was first entering the world of PT, he watched as one of his mentors started his own company. “I didn’t know until then that you could have a service-oriented business and be self-employed. I thought that was so cool. He had a number of outpatient clinics, and was able to make his own decisions and guide the company as he felt best.”
As he entered PT school, “I always had starting my own company in my mind as a goal.”

Considering Capital

Fast forward a few years, and Chad and his business partner at the time had founded Momentum Physical Therapy & Sports Rehab in a suburb outside San Antonio, Texas. Despite “not knowing anything about running a business,” they bootstrapped their way to impressive growth, taking out small lines of credit at local banks and paying them back as quickly as possible. They opened another location, then another. After the third, they started financing their growth through cash flow. Before Chad knew it, he had been running the business for a dozen years and Momentum had expanded to 10 locations in the San Antonio area.
The team started thinking about raising capital to grow more quickly. “We were exploring all the different options on the table — traditional lenders, banks, PE groups, VCs, and we weren’t finding the right fit. At the point, the idea of being purchased wasn’t on the table.” Still, people were reaching out to them, especially as they began to be recognized nationally for their success — Momentum was on the Inc. 5000 list of America’s fastest growing companies two out of three years in a row.
“We kept pushing people off, saying that we weren’t interested,” says Chad. He started using Axial with the intent to find a private equity group, but instead got in touch with a strategic acquirer that had expertise and knowledge in their field, Houston-based U.S. Physical Therapy Inc. “They could provide more robust systems, and help us grow the right way. We decided that maybe it did make sense to shift gears a bit and bring on a strategic partner to help achieve our vision.”
Eventually, U.S. Physical Therapy Inc. bought 60% of Momentum for $7.2 million.

Lessons Learned

Chad acknowledges that letting go of control of the company he had worked so hard to build wasn’t easy, and says he learned a few hard lessons along the way. Here’s the advice he has for fellow CEOs considering M&A.
1. Make sure you’re emotionally ready for a change.
“When you’ve worked 12 or 13 years to build something, it’s scary to think about selling a majority share,” says Chad. “The number one piece of advice we got from mentors and people who had done it before was to make sure you’re mentally and emotionally ready for things to change, because they will change. Your role won’t be the same.”
Says Chad, before the sale, “I had a lot of involvement with our executive team, providing leadership and strategic planning, but I was also the guy that handled all the financial planning and budgeting and spreadsheets — I was basically the comptroller. That was a huge thing to give up when we were acquired — a lot of the detail stuff I was doing got rolled up under the corporate umbrella, and that was a big change.”
2. You have to have a team.
“Neither my business partner nor I had any idea how detail-oriented the process would be, how many documents we would have to compile,” says Chad. “It was very, very labor intensive.”
He says that one of the most important pieces of advice their advisor gave was to build a deal team. “You’ve got to have people on your team helping you compile this info — you can’t do it alone. You can’t take the eye off the ball of running your business this long to get things done or operations will really start to trail off.”
It’s crucial “to either have a team in place that can continue to drive the operations and growth of the business while you focus and pour yourself into all that preparation and time that goes into getting a merger done, or have a team that’s dedicated to the M&A process, so that you’re not draining from existing resources.”
Chad tells the story of a friend who was looking to sell a tech company without a deal team in place. “When he first started the conversation about M&A and potential sale, the value that they were talking about was really high — a nice value. He spent the next 12 months getting the deal to the point where they were ready to sign.
“But then the acquiring company came back to him and said, ‘We can’t pay what we first talking about because the performance of your business has gone down.’ The value had taken a nosedive because the owner was investing all his time into the transaction.”
“The value had taken a nosedive because the owner was investing all his time into the transaction.”
3. Don’t overlook culture.
“One of the things that made me want to go into business for myself in the first place was to build a culture where we were more like family, a close-knit community that delivered unparalleled care,” says Chad.
Working with an advisor helped him understand how important a cultural fit was when searching for a partner, as did watching others go through mergers. “I think we made the right decision, but I’ve seen others that have sold their companies and stayed on as an employee afterwards — they ended up having to make an ugly exit from this company that they had built and grown.”
4. Don’t underestimate the complexity of integration.
Integration can be the most difficult part of an inherently challenging process. “Knowing we were like-minded with our new partners, and sharing such similarities of culture and vision and all those things,” Chad says, may have led him to assume the transition from two companies to one would be an easy one. “It has been really good for the most part, but we did underestimate the number of changes. Even though it was mostly for the better, it’s still a change.” In particular, Chad regrets the uncertainty the changes caused for his staff.
“What I would have done differently is to communicate more with our partner. There were some things in the fog of the changeover that fell through the cracks. We thought they were taking care of it, they thought we were taking care of it.” A detailed calendar of dates and timelines and responsibilities would have allayed some of those concerns and made the transition more seamless for both sides.
5. Find an advisor you trust.
“I honestly can’t say enough about how helpful our broker was throughout the process,” says Chad. “I can’t imagine trying to go through the process on our own.”
Before engaging Martin Healthcare Advisors through Axial, he had already received a few offers for the business. “We really thought, ‘We’ve got this wrapped up, we don’t need to bring anyone in at this point.’ We thought we were standing at the 95-yard line with 5 yards to go.” After bringing in an advisor, though, “it became apparent that we were standing at the 5-yard line with 95 to go. They helped us to see that this would be a marathon, not a sprint.”
Chad says the offers the company received before engaging Martin Healthcare “were half of what we received after we brought them in.”
The offers the company received before engaging an advisor “were half of what we received after we brought them in.”
In addition to helping maximize their valuation, Chad says that Martin Healthcare’s “knowledge and experience in negotiating multitudes of previous M&A deals gave us insight on some of the other intangibles we needed to negotiate. Everyone thinks about the initial buy-out price, but not a lot of people put much thought into details like employment contracts, your specific role after the merger, earn-outs, etc. Having a trusted advisor was invaluable for us in knowing what things we should be paying attention to, as well as what things were usual and customary to ask for throughout the negotiations.”
Martin Healthcare was also crucial when it came to preparing marketing materials and preparing for meetings with potential buyers. They “coached us on the right questions we should be asking, in order to ensure we were ultimately picking in the right partner.”
Chad says his biggest piece of advice to “make sure that you’re working with a broker that represents your best interests. Bigger companies are in the mode of doing mergers and acquisitions all the time — they’re good at it. No matter how ethical they are, they’re going to work out the deal in a way that keeps their company’s best interests top of mind. You need somebody fighting for yours too.”
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Sunday, May 29, 2016

The Ins and Outs of Spins | Axial Forum

Eric's comments:  Having executed several spin-offs, without question, they can be a great way to unlock hidden value and maximize your return.  Specifically:
  1. The spin-off and remaining company likely have different strategic buyers.
  2. The remaining company often has little value to the spin-offs strategic buyer, i.e., there is added cost to them to carry or eventually spin-off that portion of the company in the future.
  3. The remaining company's value is enhanced through contractual obligations with the spin-off's buyer and greater clarity from it's eventual buyer.
By  | 

For strategic buyers and private equity funds in search of quality targets, acquiring only a portion of a company through a spin-off can end up being a good proposition. Spin-offs are independent businesses created through a sale or a distribution of new shares of a parent company’s existing division (for main street and lower middle-market companies, spin-offs can also be executed as asset sales).

These deals are on the rise. Equity research firm The Edge expects $1.5 trillion worth of global parent companies to 
execute spin-offs in 2015, over double 2014’s figure. Furthermore, the firm projects the value of these global transactions to reach $3 trillion by 2016.

Domestically, The Edge expects an 18% increase in spin-off transactions, with around 40 to 42 US parent companies spinning off this year. This is compared to 34 transactions by U.S. parents last year.

What’s behind this upward momentum? Many companies and investors have realized that businesses can garner higher valuations if they are independently owned. Shareholder activists have also been exerting pressure on parent companies to maximize their worth through these transactions.

Going It Alone and Flourishing

Recent successful spin-offs have also boosted their appeal. Consider retail bank holding company Citizens Financial Group, which spun off from parent company the Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS). Before its separation, the regulatory pressures and subprime fallout that RBS was undergoing reportedly hindered Citizen’s growth. But after Citizens’ September 2014 initial public offering, the bank has been expanding its commercial lending and other businesses.

Taking Shareholders for a Spin

Spin-offs have also become a popular way for companies to increase shareholder value. The current low interest rate environment has motivated many firms to spin off income-producing assets. “This is particularly evident in the energy sector, where companies have routinely spun off assets into master limited partnerships (MLPs), and for companies with substantial real estate holdings as they have spun off assets into real estate investment trusts (REITs),” said Shaival Patel, a director in event driven equities at The Spin-Off Report, a publication authored by Horizon Kinetics and PCS Research Services.

A recent example from the energy sector is California-based Sempra Energy’s plan to separate its liquefied natural gas business into an MLP called Sempra Partners. In healthcare, Ventas has spun off most of its skilled nursing and rehabilitation facilities into a new REIT named Care Capital Properties.

It’s All About the Margins

On top of increasing shareholder value, buyers can also look forward to rising profits when they acquire a spin-off.

According to Patel, margin growth usually becomes part of the new company’s overall strategy, and there are often opportunities for shareholders to purchase a low-margin business, with margin expansion being a key part of the growth story.

For instance, when military shipbuilder Huntington Ingalls Industries was spun off from security firm Northrop Grumman, it had 6% operating margins; it was able to grow those margins to upwards of 8% in a relatively short time.

Running a Tight Ship

Aside from the promise of higher margins, a spin-off’s independence is a key advantage for investors seeking to acquire a well-run target. As a streamlined firm with established leadership, a spin-off allows management to have a laser focus on a single business area.
“In buying a spin-off, there is a greater probability that the company has been ‘polished up’ and gained credibility since an enhanced and ‘public company ready’ leadership team will have been put in place and things like contracts and key processes tidied up,“ said George Budden, a partner at Deloitte.

Not All Hunky-Dory

However, the process of buying spin-offs is not always easy, specifically for smaller-cap firms.

Challenges include retaining employees used to working in a larger organization that offers brand prestige and more career mobility. Adapting information technology to a smaller firm that has basic systems might also present problems. Additionally, the new company’s back office infrastructure might not be ready for independence from the previous owner.
Getting in Early

Despite these setbacks, there are things investors can do to make the acquisition process more seamless. For instance, when buying a spin-off, get in early.

“A good time to buy a business is just before it is spun off as the buyer can get involved in the cleanup process and avoid the added cost of having a new, heavyweight board; unwinding the stock exchange listing; and experiencing shareholder issues that might come up post spin,” Deloitte’s Budden said.

Taking initiative is also is key. Smaller buyers in particular have a better chance of landing a desired acquisition if they proactively engage companies that own assets they are interested in. “Small-cap firms can use a spin-off idea as a way to open a discussion about a division they want to acquire,” Budden said.

Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Thursday, April 21, 2016

Start-Up Firm Needing a Valuation? Get Your “Prophecy to the Future” | Ahuja & Clark PLLC


 By 


crystalball2The valuation of any company, whether it is an established company, or a start-up new venture, requires forecasts and predictions about the future. Hence, in this regard, business valuation is commonly referred to as a “Prophecy to the Future”, in technical literature.
A company’s value is based on its ability to produce economic benefits, in the form of future cash flows, profits and other returns, to its owners and investors. Hence, this is why fair market value is commonly defined as the amount at which property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, when neither party is under any compulsion to buy or sell, and both parties have reasonable knowledge of relevant facts.
A company with a history of revenues and profits enables a business valuation analyst to predict future financial performance based on better objective assumptions and greater confidence. A venture start up firm, that lacks a history of revenues and financial performance, presents unique challenges for valuation. However, this does not mean that such a start-up venture firm does not have a value. What this means is the valuation of a start-up firm is more difficult to perform due to information constraints and potentially the use of more subjective assumptions during the valuation process. Nonetheless, the fundamental principles of valuation are applicable to the valuation of a start-up firm.
Fundamentally, the valuation of a start-up firm should be based and supported on the present value of future expected cash flows from its operations. The valuation of a start up firm generally requires a shift in focus, which means that a valuation analysis of a startup firm requires the valuation analyst to focus on valuing the startup firm for what it wants to be in the future, and yet apply fundamental principles of valuation.
Estimating the Level of Risk
Generally speaking, buyers and investors will view the prospects of a startup firm for ultimately achieving projected revenues and earnings with greater risk, and to compensate for higher risks, investors and buyers will demand greater rates of returns, which translates into lower values. Given the fact that the probability of failure for a startup firm may be high in the first year, it is of paramount importance to assess risk based on reasonable assumptions. This requires business valuation analysts to examine a number of factors to project a startup’s future performance and to estimate the level of risk involved. Such factors may include, but are not limited to, the quality and reputation of the company’s management team, and the demand, uniqueness and differentiation of the product or service to be provided. Additionally, the business plan and financial projections constitute critical factors for valuation of startup firms.
Although the valuation analyst may need to discount internal projections or forecasts to reflect management’s natural optimism, no one knows the company’s products and services better than the business’s founders and senior executives. The valuation analyst will ultimately use management’s projections, and may extend such projections further into the future, based on realistic and reasonable assumptions. Additionally, valuation analysts review the experience and value of comparable companies, industry, and market statistics, as well as the value of intellectual property or other assets that may give the company sustainable competitive advantages.
Other Critical Valuation Factors
Another critical factor in valuation of startup firms is time. Generally speaking, the shorter the time frame for the startup firm to be profitable, the more valuable the company. This is because the lesser the time to achieve profitability, the lower the risk for the startup firm, and the buyer or investor does not need to wait a long time to achieve an exit value.
Another related critical factor is liquidity. Since a startup does not generate profits immediately, it must have sufficient working capital and liquid assets to fund current operations and absorb short term losses.
Still another related critical factor is the startup stage of development. A startup that is in its earliest stages, with little more than an idea, will be less valuable, than a startup with will developed products and services and financing from venture capitalists and investors.
Valuation Approaches:
Discounted Cash Flow Analysis
As previously mentioned, the fundamental principles of business valuation apply when valuing startup firms. This means that the value of a startup firm should be based on its capacity to generate future cash flows from its operations. Hence, the discounted cash flow method (DCF) that is commonly used to value established firms can also be applied to value a startup firm. Like for established firms, the framework for valuation analysis of a startup firm shall involve an assessment of the business environment and industry in which the startup will operate, as well as an assessment as to where the startup stands in relation to potential competitors. This will include a critical evaluation as to whether the startup has sustainable competitive advantages that will enable it to generate revenues and cash flows in the future.
Another step in the process of the application of the DCF method is to estimate revenue growth to project revenues into the future. Because a startup firm does not have a history of revenues and earnings to make revenue projections, critical factors to determine a revenue growth rate shall include, but are not limited to, determining the projected growth rate of the industry in which the startup operates, the sustainable competitive advantages of the startup, and estimations of market share to be captured by the startup firm. Additionally, the application of the DCF method will also require estimation of sustainable operating margins for the startup. The ultimate goal in the application of the DCF method to value a startup firm, is to develop adequate revenue projections into the future to arrive at free cash flows to the firm, and discount those cash flows to arrive at the present value of the startup firm. This present value may be adjusted for the estimated probability of survival of the firm, and a discount for illiquidity, to arrive at a final estimate of value.
Relative Valuation
The use of relative valuation methods constitute a very valuable approach to value startup firms, and can be used in combination with a discounted cash flow analysis. Relative valuation is a market approach to valuation that estimates the value of the firm, based on how much the market values similar firms.
Relative valuation involves the use of public company multiples to value private companies; and the use of relative valuation constitutes a useful good practice to value startup firms. Fundamentally, the process involves the use of forecasted revenues and earnings, the compilation of relevant public company multiples, and the application of such multiples to a forecasted metric (e.g. revenues, EBITDA) to arrive at an expected value, to then discount the expected value at the estimated discount rate for the firm, to arrive at the present value of the expected value. A discount for illiquidity may be adjusted to the expected value to arrive at a final estimate of value under relative valuation.
Predicting the Future with Facts
As evidenced by this information, it is easy to see how valuation of start-ups require a business valuation analyst who understands the nuances of this particular type of valuation. Regardless of the reason for needing a valuation, it is preferable to work with a team that has the experience to provide the most accurate information available. The Ahuja & Clark team has this experience and can support your business valuation needs, start-up or otherwise. Contact us to learn more about how your organization would benefit from a professional business valuation analyst. Also, consider signing up for our newsletter to receive professional tips and information regarding your organization’s financial opportunities.
Article LINK
For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Saturday, May 2, 2015

Looking to Sell Your Business? Think About it Like This | Entrepreneur

Sand Hill Road sign from 280 north. "KTVC...
Photo credit: Wikipedia

Every company engages in negotiations -- they're the nuts and bolts of business. But not every deal is built the same, and what's important to one company may be incidental to another.
When it comes to major deals in particular, they're usually "major" to the selling party only -- they'll lose out if the deal falls through. If, for example, Company A wants to buy Company B, Company B may be in real trouble if the deal doesn’t close, whereas the odds are good that nothing will happen to Company A.
The same is true for an investment: A venture capital firm will likely continue to thrive if it refrains from funding a project, but the startup running that project may truly suffer.
By definition, every deal has any number of potential areas of conflict that require negotiation, even when both parties act in good faith toward closing. Major deals usually take between six to nine months to complete -- even up to as much as a year for more complicated acquisitions. In addition to the due diligence process, the negotiation of the deal terms and the definitive agreement take time to hammer out.
While the acquiring company usually has an M&A team that will handle this process, from the startup's side, the CEO, with input from the board, is the one who leads and conducts the negotiations.
Threats to the startup
From the perspective of a startup company, several elements of deal negotiation threaten its well-being:
  • CEOs’ involvement in securing investments/selling the company may distract them from the usual work of running the company (management, strategic development, etc.)
  • Company slow-down, for any reason
The CEOs of startup companies usually play a dominant role in all facets of the business, and the fact that he or she is now focused on the negotiation process means defocusing on the usual work -- including operating the business, securing partnerships and strategic planning.
The next threat is something that all startups -- not just those going through a potential acquisition process -- are always concerned about: a slowdown in productivity for whatever reason. Startup companies usually have limited budgets, and if time goes by and they don’t move forward, they can be in a situation where funds will dry up, or the fledgling venture will be forced to raise funds at a less-than-ideal point and compromise on their valuation to survive.
In my own experiences, maintaining company productivity was essential. A healthy KitLocate was more valuable and more attractive to our potential acquirers, making the negotiating process easier for me as well as providing the security that should the deal break down, I still had a functioning company that was continuing to ship code, update our product and build partnerships.

Case in point

Several months ago, I received an offer to buy KitLocate, and I had to decide with the board under which terms we were willing to sell. I was afraid of the threats described above, so I insisted that we manage the process by the following rules:
  1. The CEO leads the deal and is the only one involved in the details -- updating the board when relevant and consulting when needed
  2. The company’s co-founders (who take active management roles in the company, in addition to being board members) agree to keep their distance from the details of the sale, lest their involvement pressure and distract the CEO or unfocus them
  3. The company’s co-founders agree to support their co-founder and CEO to the extent that they're able
  4. We should negotiate and come to agreement on all the major terms before signing the term-sheet (and not keep major parts to the definitive agreement)
  5. The deal is to be treated with secrecy, so that general employees remain ignorant of the deal and its terms, allowing them to more easily focus on their work
  6. Except for me, as CEO, everyone else in the company was to continue working as if the deal was not happening
The trust that my co-founders and the board placed in me to carry out the negotiations was integral -- and very unusual. As the nature of deal negotiation brews the potential for stress, having “peace at home” (where I was left to work without feeling additional pressure) was very important.
We managed to stick to all of the above and more importantly, we continued growing our customer base, hiring staff and building our technology and products. Business-as-usual may well have made the startup appealing to the buyer. It certainly facilitated the process when it came time to close the deal. We also completed the transaction as fast as was possible, so that if something had gone wrong, the company would have suffered minimal damage.
If you're in a position to sell your own company, consider this approach and see the benefits throughout the ongoing, day-to-day, constructive functioning of the company.
Article:  Link

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Saturday, December 28, 2013

Retiring boomer biz owners look to invest in what they know: Business | Crain's Detroit Business

I need help setting something like this up in Southwest Florida, i.e., setting up a fund to purchase and operate businesses that are underachieving.  Contact me if interested.  Eric at 239-738-6227.

"Jason Brinks has set up more than a few retirement portfolios for baby boomer business owners who've sold their companies.

Brinks, managing director of Oxford Financial's Grand Rapids office, often sets up the newly liquid, former business owners with a mix of traditional investments, such as stocks, bonds and mutual funds, to support their lifestyles as they head into their golden years.

Lately, though, a number of his clients have voiced interest in mixing in a few alternatives, such as private equity, venture capital and even direct investment in local startups and closely held companies, Brinks said.

He and other local wealth managers are seeing an increase these days in clients who fit the same profile: They have been successful in business, came to a point in life where they decided to sell, and want to put part of their new wealth that was previously tied up in the business to work elsewhere."

Read more at:

Retiring boomer biz owners look to invest in what they know: Business | Crain's Detroit Business:

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at info@buysellflbiz.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Florida Business Exchange website at www.fbxbrokers.com and my personal website at www.buysellflbiz.com.

Saturday, March 3, 2012

Ready to Hustle on the Tampa StartUpBus

Ready to Hustle on the Tampa StartUpBus
Bonita Springs, FL, March 3, 2012

Eric J. Gall, an Estero resident, will join a Florida team vying with teams from nine other cities across the country trying to develop a business during a 72-hour bus ride to Austin, Texas.

Eric, a Business Intermediary with Florida Business Exchange and a Managing Partner of the local broadband start-up C3 Connect, will be part of a national competition called StartupBus. Each bus consists of a group of strangers who will team up on their way to the South by Southwest Interactive Festival. The teams will have 72 hours to conceive, build and launch a business.

Once the buses reach Austin, multiple teams on each bus will pitch their business concepts to venture capitalists and investors. The winning team is guaranteed a $1M investment.

More information about the competition is available at startupbus.com. The bus is described as “a community of hackers, hustlers and hipsters passionate about startups.” In technical terms, a hacker is a computer programmer or coder, a hustler is a business development person and a hipster is a web, print or video designer. Gall expects to use his 25 plus years of business experience as a hustler, i.e., business development to assist with building, promoting and launching the business plan for either an idea of his own or another team's idea he believes has a better shot at winning.

About Eric J. Gall
Eric manages the Southwest Florida Office of Florida Business Exchange, Inc. and is a Managing Partner of wireless broadband startup C3 Connect. Eric has over 25 years of business management and ownership experience in Michigan and Florida. He has intermediated or participated in numerous small, family-owned business transactions as well as mergers, acquisitions, joint ventures, spin-outs and divestitures of multi-million dollar operations.