Showing posts with label Reverse Due Diligence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reverse Due Diligence. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 14, 2017

7 Fundamentals to Due Diligence You Need to Know | Divestopedia

By  , 
Takeaway: Being open about your business practices and financial statements can lead to a better takeaway for both the buyer and seller.
7 Fundamentals to Due Diligence You Need to Know
Source: Info40555/Dreamstime.com
According to Bizbuysell.com, there were a total of 1,840 businesses transactions that took place worldwide during the first quarter of 2016. Businesses were either bought and sold or mergers and acquisitions took place in that first quarter. People buy and sell or merge businesses for different reasons, but whatever the reasons, there are always a wide variety of preliminary activities that must take place prior to closing the deal. In almost all cases, an attorney who is fluent in due diligence for mergers and acquisitions is required to ensure that the transaction takes place based on the laws that have been put into place by FINRA or other regulatory agencies.

1. Historic and Projected Financial Information

Historic Information

The seller should be providing financial documents for the past three years. The buyer will need to perform due diligence concerning the company’s historical financial information and supporting documentation.
The seller will need to provide documents for the buyer to perform an assessment of the company’s financial statements so they can make note of any financial trends, spikes or decreases in sales and revenue, consistencies or inconsistencies in cash flow activity, the company’s current debt, receivables and other assets, as well as all other aspects of the company's financial performance.

Projected Information

In addition to performing due diligence on the historical financial information, the buyer will also need to perform due diligence on any future financial activity as well. Carefully checking to ensure reasonable financial projections of the company’s future performance were made. Some of those areas involve whether or not the projections are based on reasonable assumptions whereby a clear path to achieving those results is laid out and linked to the actual financial activity in a practical, succinct manner.
  • Is the projected financial information sound and believable?
  • Were the documents succinct?
  • How much working capital is necessary to continue running the business beyond its current state?
  • Are there additional capital expenditures or other required investments that need to take place to ensure the future growth of the business?

2. Technology Developments and Intellectual Property

The seller will need to provide the buyer's attorney with information about any current or pending intellectual property, technology developments, copyright and patent ownerships that the company may have.
If the company has patent applications and potential trademarks, the buyer should ensure that the appropriate registration has taken place. When materials are used in marketing or technological advances, the company must have the rights and control the copyright, or risk lawsuits. If they haven't, it could be a risk for the buyer who will take on any liability based on prior violations.
Trade secrets are vital to the success of some companies, so as the seller, you'll need to ensure that the secrets have been preserved appropriately and other companies' secrets have not been infringed by your company and be able to prove that to the buyer.

3. Customers and Revenue Streams

Before purchase, the seller will have to detail the various revenue streams of the business. This includes the company's satisfied customers, and what they purchase. The buyer should have a grasp of who the customers are as well as how revenue is generated by these customers especially the top 20 percent who will account for much of the business.
Another consideration is the satisfaction of the customers after a change in ownership. Are there going to be problems with new ownership that will impact the business' revenue going forward?
Along with evaluating customer loyalty and spending habits, the seller will be giving the buyer information about the backlog of issues. Are there warranty problems that are not being handled properly? Do there seem to be a high level of exchanges and refunds being issued? The seller should already have this information and be able to tell the buyer why there were problems.

4. Contract Agreements and Insurance

A review of all pending and active contracts and agreements should be a part of the due diligence process as well as a review of insurance coverage.
The key areas include some of the following:
  • Outstanding loans, personal guarantors, and note payables
  • Outstanding customer and vendor contracts
  • Partnerships, joint venture, or operating agreements
  • Outstanding or pending Settlement agreements
  • Equipment or vehicle lease agreements
  • Independent contractor and Employment agreements
  • General liability and Worker’s compensation insurance
  • D&O / E&O and Key man insurance
  • Intellectual property insurance
  • Vehicle insurance
  • Health insurance
  • Umbrella policies

5. Staff and Key Management

The buyer will need to perform diligence activity for all staff, independent contractors, and key management. This should include looking into scheduled pay raises, equity shares, profit distributions, 401(k), commissions, bonuses and other employment related issues. This means the seller will need to have opened their human resource files and be willing to have a buyer comb through the documents.
Along with the functionality of the human resources department regarding compensation, there should be a detailed audit of the history of labor disputes. If there's even been a threat to stop working for any reason, that could be a red flag, but the buyer will need to look into the issues that caused the employees to be disgruntled.

6. Legal and Compliance

One of the biggest headaches for a buyer can be legal tangles, which include any current, pending or settled litigation, arbitration or other proceedings. Any compliance- or regulation-related issues can be a problem, too. This is where the buyer's attorney should be forecasting the result of the litigation as well as investigating claims and threats against the company. The seller can help by being as forthcoming as possible and talking to their own attorneys about the legal future of any claims.
With detailed due diligence procedures for acquisitions, a seller can avoid serious legal problems in the future by looking at the prior, current, and future potential for legal threats. There might even be matters in arbitration at the moment that could resolve into a problem for the new owner. In some cases, a buyer might come back and sue a seller for fraud if they weren't forthcoming with information regarding fraud.

7. Tax Issues

It’s important to perform a tax due diligence to determine whether the company has any tax liability issues. This process should include a review of tax returns that have been filed within the past five years including the federal, state, and local returns. The buyer's accountants and attorneys should be checking for net operating losses. Credit carryovers should be investigated to ensure that the change in ownership won't impact the relationship with the creditor.
If there have been agreements, waivers or tax communications with the IRS, the new buyer should understand exactly what that means for acquiring the business. If there have been settlement agreements with the IRS or other agencies, the seller will want to let the buyer know that those will not impact the new ownership negatively, and might not carry over to the new buyer.

Final Words

Due diligence in merger and acquisitions requires that a substantial amount of activities take place from both sides prior to making a full commitment to the transaction. It’s a means for the buyer to do some fact-checking, so that he or she is fully aware of what is actually being purchased. By carefully planning these and other related activities for the due diligence in mergers and acquisitions process, the buyer will feel confident in his decision and will be prepared to proceed with the purchase of the business. The seller will be able to say that they provided all the information the buyer needed to make a sound decision.

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com.

Saturday, August 29, 2015

7 Advantages Of Reverse Or Vendor Due Diligence | Divestopedia


 


Files
When a business owner decides to sell their business, the need to objectively assess the current condition of the company can often be overlooked. In failing to do this, the seller weakens their power of negotiation with potential acquirers. The best way to address this is through “reverse,” or “vendor,” due diligence.
Both processes involve having a third party assess the company in the same way that a buyer would, before taking the company to market.
With reverse due diligence, the results of this assessment are presented in a report to prospective buyers. This helps demonstrate that a third party has examined the company’s structure, and reassures buyers that any preliminary due diligence holes have been identified. With reverse due diligence the results are kept confidential by the seller.
Reverse due diligence allows the seller to prepare for issues that frequently arise in the sale process. According to M&A advisory firm Baker Tilly, both processes involve the following:
  1. An assessment of quality of earnings
  2. Quality of assets
  3. Tax due diligence
  4. Commercial due diligence (especially if the future revenue stream of the company is critical to the sale)
  5. Operational due diligence (if the operations are proprietary or otherwise critical to the value of the company)
Reverse due diligence provides the following advantages to sellers and their investment bankers:
  1. Provides the seller an opportunity to fully explain issues or circumstances that could be perceived as flaws by prospective buyers.
  2. Allows the seller to prepare for the questions and document requests that will invariably be part of the buyer’s research.
  3. Identifies potential deal issues for the investment banker, to develop appropriate negotiation strategies.
  4. Provides the investment banker with verified data to include in the Confidential Memorandum (and data room), which can assist in keeping any renegotiations to a minimum.
  5. Minimizes the potential for surprises from the buyer’s due diligence.
  6. Irons out potential kinks, thereby keeping a prospective purchaser in the process longer and extending the “competitive tension,” to maximize the price and structure for the seller.
  7. If reverse due diligence is thorough enough, it can help minimize the exclusivity period. The buyer need only roll forward the data required to validate their investment thesis.
Reverse reverse due diligence is typically the last step performed before selling a business. However, it can also be conducted well in advance, to allow owners adequate time to correct or modify issues prior to exit. And if the end result is a higher business valuation or greater negotiating power, then it’s well worth the investment.
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Tuesday, August 25, 2015

The Window of Vulnerability in an M&A Transaction | Divestopedia

English: Window in Hukvaldy castle
Window (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

By ,  

Takeaway: In every sale transaction, there is a “window of vulnerability” for the seller that starts with the initiation of sale discussions with a potential buyer and ends with the closing of the sale. Three key risks present themselves during this window.
From the moment you make initial contact with any potential bidder to the time you close a sale transaction, you and your business are at risk. If you’re considering selling your business, you’re likely concerned about ensuring:
  1. an acceptable valuation for your business,
  2. that utmost confidentiality is maintained, and
  3. that you don’t waste time, effort and money on a failed negotiation.
Should a sale negotiation fail to result in a closed transaction, in certain respects, the window of vulnerability doesn’t close, prolonging these apparent risks. A key objective of any effective sale process is to shorten this window of vulnerability as much as possible.
This article discusses three inevitable risks that a seller will encounter in an M&A transaction.

Inevitable Risk No. 1 - Completion Risk

Greater than 75% of private business sale processes fail. Completion risk, like the other key risk areas, is present in every transaction and increases the longer a business is exposed to potential bidders. During a protracted process, fatigue sets in for both the seller’s and potential buyers’ teams, confidence and trust erode and expenses on all sides accumulate.
Market Conditions Deteriorate
While industry conditions applicable to a seller’s business clearly impact completion risk, macroeconomic conditions, financing markets and market valuations have a profound impact on M&A activity. Even if market conditions are robust, market windows can close suddenly and in unforeseen ways. I can attest to the impact that the 2008-09 financial crisis had on the M&A market. Scores of transaction negotiations were shelved indefinitely. I was involved in both an acquisition and a sale that were in the market as the crisis unfolded.
One acquirer was forced to raise exorbitantly expensive financing to close their acquisition in a debt market that had completely seized up. The result: their share price dropped from the mid-20’s in June 2008 to under $3 by March 2009.
A stable business with a leading market position that was worth well in excess of $1 billion when we launched our sale process in the summer of 2008, received bids for approximately 40% less a few weeks later. The bidders in the process told us that the distressed selling resulting from the crisis flooded them with lower risk investment opportunities that would provide better returns than buying our client’s business at a pre-crisis valuation.
Business Performance Falls Short
Operating a business is inherently risky and there are often surprises. A key member of your team could leave, you could lose a large customer or a large order, market prices and/or demand may suddenly collapse, etc. A business sale process is intense and demanding, which makes it harder to fight fires. Of course, the longer the sale process continues, the greater the likelihood that the business will have a negative surprise and until the transaction closes, the seller bears the full performance risk.
As an example, we recently saw a situation with an energy services business owner that had retained an advisor to sell their business. The owner moved very slowly to provide the advisor with the information required to launch the sale process. It took several months to provide materials that should have taken a few weeks. After the process was eventually launched and the bidders neared completion of their due diligence, the oil price collapsed. Shortly thereafter, their largest customer cancelled a major project, dealing the negotiated valuation a mortal blow. The process was terminated with no prospect of revival.
Business risk is unavoidable. It’s best to shift that risk to a buyer as quickly as possible by facilitating a short process. If this process had moved more quickly, the project cancellation could have been the buyer’s problem, not the seller’s.
The Buyer’s Problems Are Your Problems
A business owner’s main concerns during negotiations are typically with their stakeholders and business performance. The buyer’s objectives in pursing a sale, by contrast, are as follows:
  • Minimizing completion risk
  • Minimizing time investment
  • Minimizing due diligence and legal expenses
  • Acquiring a clean, low-risk target company
Most entrepreneurs don’t concern themselves with factors that impact the buyer. Ultimately, in reaching a successful transaction with a given party, the buyer’s problem is also the seller’s problem. Here are a few situations we’ve encountered:
  • Failed processes damage careers: Acquirers can expend significant time and resources to complete an acquisition. A private equity fund will typically spend $100,000 to $250,000 to complete the due diligence, legal work and secure the financing commitments required to table a binding bid. Their decision to engage in an acquisition process is based on their assessment of their completion risk and the cost of their foregone opportunities to pursue other acquisitions. It follows then, that when a seller undermines the acquiror’s confidence that they can successfully complete a transaction in a timely an efficient manner, the acquirer will likely disengage. Sellers that conduct themselves in a manner that shows inexperience, unresponsiveness, non-market expectations or erratic behavior risk scaring otherwise qualified bidders away.
  • The acquirer’s priorities change: Current acquisition projects being derailed by urgent, higher-priority acquisition opportunities is a common occurrence. We were once retained by the platform company of a private equity client to assist them with acquiring several smaller private companies in the HVAC industry. Dialogue had started with a few companies and was subsequently put on hold for six months because the company had to shift its focus to filing for their initial public offering. Such a loss of momentum is often fatal to a sale negotiation.
  • Financing pressures: Like it or not, the bank is often a significant constituency in a deal negotiation. Credit facilities are commonly required to provide at least some of the funding needed to close the transaction. To satisfy any experienced seller, a buyer must demonstrate they have committed financing. When the banks commit this financing, that money is spoken for and cannot be committed elsewhere. As a result, the banks will resist extending these financing commitments for an extended period of time without charging standby fees to the potential acquirer, increasing their deal costs and risk of the financing being withdrawn.
  • Deal costs mount: The buyer, who is also paying for financial and legal advisors, may be dissuaded from continuing to pursue a long, expensive transaction.
This is far from an exhaustive list. Suffice it to say, there are several factors that can impact a potential buyer’s participation in a sale process.

    Inevitable Risk No 2. - Valuation Risk

    Whether or not it is explicitly stated, a buyer’s perception of the value of a business is based on the simple multiplication of [Valuation Metric] x [Valuation Multiple]. As a potential acquirer conducts their due diligence and negotiates the definitive agreement, they may adjust one or both of these to reflect new information attained through the process. More cynically, they may engage in what is commonly referred to as the “Due Diligence Grind”.
    As with completion risk, changes in the business during the sale process can impact a potential buyer’s perception of value. When value expectations diverge like this, there is a very real chance for the deal to ultimately fall apart. A lengthier due diligence and negotiation process increases this risk.

    Inevitable Risk No. 3 - Disruptions to Ongoing Operations

    Leaks that impact your business relationships
    The longer the window of vulnerability, the greater the risk of leaks that a company is in sale discussions. Leaks and speculation about an impending sale have the potential to undermine the confidence of customers, triggering concerns about whether the same standards for service and attentiveness will be upheld during transition of ownership. Further, suppliers might take the news of an impending sale to mean that a business is in financial distress. As a result they may review whether they should continue to extend credit and revise payment terms. An information breach can also have undesirable effects on employee morale, eliciting feelings of mistrust, anxiety, vulnerability or apathy surrounding performance.
    Opportunities for competitors to use private information
    Despite executing standard non-disclosure agreements, strategic acquirers and competitors may use and distribute, whether intentionally or accidentally, confidential information gained from the process for their own marketplace advantage. A lengthy sale process provides time for information to reach a wider, potentially unregulated network, especially if your documentation isn’t subject to professional confidentially protocols, properly encoded, and watermarked. Competitors may use your intellectual property in their business, or take advantage of your market intelligence to gain a competitive edge.
    Distractions from regular business operations
    Rumours surrounding a business sale may lead to undesirable consequences. Otherwise loyal customers who perceive financial distress may take their business elsewhere, and employees may fear for their job security and begin seeking other opportunities. For management, it can be challenging to maintain business operations up to standard while also navigating the demands of negotiating a sale.
    Article LINK

    For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.