Showing posts with label Process Documentation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Process Documentation. Show all posts

Sunday, June 19, 2016

The Single Most Important Lever Driving Corporate Value | Divestopedia

By ,  

Takeaway: There are many drivers that can increase the value of a business, but one is more important than any other.
The Single Most Important Lever Driving Corporate Value





















I was recently asked what single lever I would pick if I could pick only one in an attempt to promote growth in corporate value. Without hesitation I said, "Corporate governance" – much to the surprise of the person asking the question who afterward told me he thought I was going to pick EBITDA, free cash flow, market share, or some other individual company metric.

What is Corporate Governance?

The term, corporate governance, means different things to different people. For me, corporate governance is an umbrella term that encompasses all of the things that drive business value and its growth – ownership behavior, the make-up of the board of directors, strategy, providing direction to management and continually measuring management performance, and so on.
In simple terms, corporate governance refers to the system of mechanisms and processes by which a business is controlled and directed. Broadly, a corporate governance system:
  1. Consists of rules, practices and processes that establishes, monitors and ensures the achievement of a company’s objectives;
  2. Sets out the rules and procedures for making business decisions;
  3. Details the rights and responsibilities of participants in the business, including owners, directors, managers and employees; and
  4. Monitors all of those things on an ongoing basis to ensure they are complied with.

The Role of Governance in Business Transitions

In successful generational business transitions, there is an evident evolution from an entrepreneurial business model to what an extreme can be thought of as a quasi-public company corporate governance model. This is where the family company has both family member and independent directors, often non-family, non-director business advisors with industry-specific operating experience, and where non-family member (arm’s length) executives head one or more businesses in a business model where the family holding company owns diversified businesses, each with its own different risk profile.
It has been my experience for more than 45 years of interaction with business families that the ones who succeed in multi-generational business transition are the ones that embrace and implement good corporate governance practices. This is where, increasingly over time, their family separates the transition of business ownership from the transition of business management, and where the family business:
  1. Evolves from being operated as a pure entrepreneurial business model to become a business model that supports entrepreneurism while bringing systematic order and stability to their ever larger and more complex business;
  2. Recognizes the importance of internally managing the generational transition process;
  3. Accepts as a first principle that their business is not part of the family per se, but rather a family asset distinct from the family itself; and
  4. Integrates non-family (1) corporate directors, (2) senior executives, and (3) in some cases, advisory boards into their family business.

Keys to Successful Governance

A recent Boston Consulting article titled, "Governance for Family Business: Sustaining the 'Magic' for Generations to Come," addresses governance in family-owned businesses. Suffice to say, the following things are seen by its authors as key success factors in private company growth and successful generational business transition:
  1. As a starting point, having a clear vision for the business’ strategy, and documenting and articulating that strategy as a basis for management, understanding of both objectives and a formalized methodology for investment planning;
  2. Having a long-term perspective where private company owners do not have the short-term performance drivers that influence public company boards and management;
  3. Family members having a firm grip on management where an ability to make important decisions rapidly enables quick and effective reactions to changing conditions;
  4. Maintaining entrepreneurial spirit and core skills;
  5. Gaining and maintaining employee loyalty;
  6. Acceptance of the importance of a board of directors comprised of both family and non-family members selected on the basis of ownership, independence, and/or industry or business function expertise;
  7. Building and maintaining a robust management platform;
  8. Developing and continually using a performance management system;
  9. Continually working on competitive-advantage initiatives while simultaneously working toward ever more structured management; and
  10. Ensuring the business governance system is easy to understand and flexible such that it can be changed as the needs of the family business and business family evolve.
I suggest the Boston Consulting article is one that all private business owners and their transition advisors ought to read and think about if they are in the throes of, or contemplating, generational business transition.
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Thursday, May 26, 2016

In a Business Sale, the Buyer Has the Upper Hand (Part 3) | Divestopedia

By  ,  

Takeaway: This is part three of a three-part series that identifies the natural advantages that business buyers bring to the table before the transaction process even starts.
In a Business Sale, the Buyer Has the Upper Hand (Part 3)
Source: Bowie15 - Dreamstime.com















In parts one and two of this article series, we discussed the natural experiential advantages that a business buyer's team would bring to the table in a business sale transaction; identified buyer attacks on the transaction value during the negotiation and LOI process; and offered approaches you can use to hold your ground against this formidable opponent in regards to the working capital adjustment, benchmarks and earnouts. In this article, we continue to view this negotiation process like a fencing match; buyer thrust, seller parry.

The Due Diligence Surprise

Thrust - "We noticed that your average billing per customer is smaller than our average billing rate, we are going to have to adjust our value."
Parry - "What about the memorandum, the detailed customer lists, the monthly billing report that you reviewed prior to executing the LOI didn't you understand? Our price is firm. If you want to adjust, we are cancelling the LOI and we are back on the market."
Thrust - "We noticed that you had a spike in this particular type of revenue which is unusually profitable. We do not believe that this is sustainable and are going to have to adjust our bid to account for that."
Parry - If you analyze it correctly, last year was pretty much the norm for this type of revenue. The year prior was actually the outlier and much lower than average. Secondly, if you truly allocated corporate overhead to this income category, you would find it about the same level of profitability as our other lines of business. No adjustment is warranted."
Okay, we held our own during that round. Now it is just a formality to get the purchase agreements signed and provide our wire transfer instructions. Not yet, pick up your sword.

Unreasonable Reps and Warranties

Thrust - You receive the definitive purchase agreement from the buyer's attorney and it looks like you have to rep and warranty your first born in order to get the deal signed. All of a sudden you see escrows and holdbacks, and guarantees that were not mentioned in the LOI. Much of that is pretty standard stuff, although it will be very slanted to the benefit of the buyer.
Parry - No material changes to the deal economics allowed. "We signed the LOI and provided you a no-shop in order to allow you to perform due diligence. We were very detailed in our LOI in order to compare your bid with others that were very close. Without any legitimate finding of misinformation in the due diligence process, the economics remain the same."
As for the scary reps and warranties, holdbacks and escrows, we let our lawyers talk with their lawyers. It is almost like they have the lawyers' secret pinky handshake and they carve through this language with clarity and precision. What it usually boils down to is what is reasonable and customary in transactions that are similar to this one. If there are any remaining issues, they identify them and ask the seller and his/her advisor to work them out with the buyer. By this stage, these final points are settled constructively.

Delayed Closing Date

Thrust - "Oh, just one more thing, you are going to throw in the floor mats and the undercoating at no charge." We tell our clients to expect this because it is just the nature of the buyers. Here is how it is manifested in a business sale transaction. The closing date is set for September 30, month end. "We want to move the closing date back to October 7 so we can take a look at your month end numbers. Do you have any concerns?" No, we just want to make sure things are on track.
Parry - Not much we can do about this one but try to anticipate what they may be looking at for that final attack on value and to prepare our counter attack. This one is a little trickier, however, because in prior attacks we had the luxury of time in order to strategize and craft our response. This one is usually real time where emotions are on the jagged edge. We ask our client to prepare a response to our anticipated last minute objection and then we, as their advisors, take the first attack. We want to have the client stay above the fray and preserve their relationship for the upcoming partnership together. If that effort is not accepted and the buyer insists on an adjustment based on, "It looks like you are not tracking to hit your first year earnout target," we prepare the seller with, "You know that we put in the earnout in order to align your interests with ours going forward. I have a good deal of transaction value tied to hitting our targets and I would not have signed this agreement unless I was fully confident that I would collect every dollar of that earnout."

Stalemate

Unfortunately, in spite of my best efforts, I view a stalemate as the best outcome we can hope for once we are off the market. As you can see, the leverage totally shifts to the buyer. The price is never increased during due diligence and contract negotiation. There is pressure to even keep the business flat during this process because a good deal of the owner's attention and emotions are going to be focused on the process of selling his/her business as opposed to just running his/her business. So our process is to make it evident that there are several qualified buyers that are very close in their offers to the winning offer. If there is buyer bad behavior we can simply plug in the next best bidder. The other major strategy we employ is to recommend our client execute a very detailed-, formula- and example-driven LOI.
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Wednesday, May 25, 2016

In a Business Sale, the Buyer Has the Upper Hand (Part 2) | Divestopeida

By  ,  

Takeaway: This is part two of a three-part series that identifies the natural advantages that business buyers bring to the table before the transaction process even starts.
In a Business Sale, the Buyer Has the Upper Hand (Part 2)
Source: Bowie15 - Dreamstime.com















In part one of this article series, we discussed the natural experiential advantages that a business buyer's team would bring to the table in a business sale transaction. The seller is usually embarking on their first business sale, whereas the buyer has often completed dozens of prior transactions. So, from the start, the seller is subject to a process that greatly favors the business buyer. This article will identify in the negotiation and LOI process, buyer attacks on the transaction value and approaches you can use to hold your ground against this formidable opponent. Several subtle and seemingly harmless clauses in the LOI can result in swings in actual transaction value of hundreds of thousands of dollars. It may be helpful to look at this negotiation like a fencing match; buyer thrust, seller parry.

Thrust and Parry

Thrust - a buyer getting you off the market with a loosely worded LOI that allows him/her to "interpret the terms" in his/her favor deep into the due diligence process. This is the number one seller error in the process and results in either the deal blowing up or the seller taking an unnecessary hair cut.
Parry - a seller not counter-signing the LOI until terms are defined. There are several key terms of the LOI, so we will give each one their own "Thrust" and "Parry."

Working Capital Adjustment

Thrust - A buyer-attempted treatment of working capital. Most buyers attempt initial language for working capital in the LOI that looks something like this:
Working Capital Adjustment: There shall be a typical working capital adjustment to accommodate for changes to the working capital balance, including cash, accounts receivable and accounts payable, as of the day of closing. During due diligence, the purchaser will set a working capital target by determining a normal and customary level of current assets, including a positive cash balance. There shall be sufficient working capital, including a cash balance which shall be sufficient to operate the business on an ongoing day-to-day basis and the buyer will not need to fund working capital simply to operate the business immediately after the transaction.
Parry - Not so fast, Zorro! This seems like a perfectly reasonable treatment and, unfortunately, many unsuspecting sellers will counter-sign an LOI with this language in place. The result of this is either he/she is going to get taken to the cleaners on the level the buyer decides on, deep into the due diligence process, or the seller will blow up the deal deep into the process. Neither a good result, and the sad part is that it could easily be prevented. The first rule of LOIs is to not take your company off the market with a very important term not defined up front. This language enables their team of experts to calculate their own opinion of "reasonable and customary" while you have no negotiating leverage. You have already taken your company off the market as a buyer requirement to enable due diligence with a no-shop clause.

Missing Benchmarks

The second very important mistake is that by leaving that term undefined, you have not really benchmarked the proposed transaction value against other bids. We had a client that kept a net working capital surplus far greater than what was normally required to run the business. Let's say that they kept a surplus of $400,000 when their normal monthly business expenses were $100,000. So, the level could be set as a surplus of $100,000.
Now the buyers bring in their experts and look at your last 12 months' balance sheets and proclaim that your historical level of $400,000 is what they need, then you may have just sacrificed $300,000 of transaction value. If you have one buyer that bids $3,000,000 for your company with a net working capital surplus requirement of $100,000 and you close with $400,000 surplus, $300,000 is returned to you as transaction value. This makes the total transaction value $3,300,000. If the undefined working capital surplus buyer bids $3,100,000 and calculates, after the LOI, that his requirement is $400,000, then his transaction value is short the other bid by $200,000!
This can all be prevented by the seller insisting that the LOI include a net working capital level commitment with the calculation methodology spelled out. Each buyer may have their own opinion of what that number should be, but this exercise will allow you to equalize the bids and determine which one is truly superior. Unfortunately, the buyers try to leave this vague in their LOI so that 90 days into the due diligence process, they render their buyer favorable opinion and count on the seller suffering from deal fatigue and just caving in on this meaningful loss in value. The buyers know that they do damage to your future chances if you put your company back on the market with the stigma of the previous deal blowing up during due diligence. It usually results in a market discount being applied to your company the second time around.

The 'All or Nothing' Earnout Clause

Thrust - An earnout clause with punitive "all or nothing" language. In the realm of SMB mergers and acquisitions, an earnout is a common practice and a perfectly reasonable component of a business sale transaction. It is often an effective way to bridge the valuation gap between the buyer and seller, and to align the interests of the buyer and seller for post-acquisition business performance. But like other components here, there is good earnout language and there is earnout language that is one-sided in favor of the buyer.
An example of earnout language from a buyer LOI is: The total earnout shall be paid over three years. The total possible payout amount is $1.5 million, based on growing EBITDA by 5% per year over last year's rate of $1,250,000.
The target EBITDA in year one is $1,312,500, year two is $1,378,125, and year three is $1,447,031. If the target is hit, the payout will be $500,000 for the year. If the achievement is between 85% - 99% of the target, the payout will be that percentage attainment X $500,000. If the attainment is less than 85% of the target, no earnout payment will be made.
Parry - In general, we recommend that earnouts be based on a number that cannot be easily manipulated by the buying company. So measures like net profit and EBITDA are less favorable. Here they can insert some expense items like "corporate overhead," which are out of your control. We prefer tying earnouts to measures such as total sales or gross profit margin; far more difficult to leave up to interpretation.
Next, we never recommend an "all or nothing" earnout clause. Normally, earnouts are a meaningful percentage of the overall transaction value and, if an unforeseen event takes you below their cut-off target, you have sacrificed some serious value. Our argument is that if there is a big shortfall, the percent of that shortfall in their earnout payment is enough to keep buyer and seller interests aligned post-acquisition.
If there is a downside adjustment in the earnout calculation (there always is) then we like to have the corresponding upside for surpassing target performance. In other words, if you miss your target by 10% then you only receive 90% of that year's earnout payment target. If you hit 110% of your target, your earnout payment should be 110% of that target.
We also recommend that the earnout be formula-driven and include an example calculation as shown here. The earnout total would be $1,500,000 and be paid in the first three years after the closing within 30 days of the anniversary date. The earnout would be based on the trailing twelve months' revenues and a target to grow those revenues by 5% per year over the first three years following closing. So, the target for year one (again using the prior year end as the example) would be $5,000,000 X 1.05 = $5,250,000. For year two, another 5% growth would result in a target of $5,512,500. And for year three, another 5% growth would result in a target of $5,788,125, for a three-year total of $15,550,625. Dividing this by the total earnout payment at target ($1,500,000) results in an earnout payment of 9.06% of revenues for the first three years. The payment would be made annually within 30 days of closing of the company's books for 12, 24 and 36 months following closing.
For each year's earnout payment, the actual payout amount would be calculated by applying the payout percentage rate of 9.06% X the actual revenues. As an example, if the revenue for year three came in at $5,000,000 that would be multiplied by 9.06% and result in an earnout payment of $453,000. If the year three revenues came in at $6,000,000, the earnout payment would be $546,600.
Great, we have handled each thrust with our skillful parry. Match over, right? Keep that face protector on, the match is just heating up. Continue reading part three here.
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Friday, September 11, 2015

The Initial Price May Not Be Real | Divestopedia

By ,  

Takeaway: “The Due Diligence Grind” is often practiced by sophisticated acquirers to reduce the purchase price of a business, by citing negative findings during due diligence. This article takes a closer look at the ways a prospective buyer may try to grind down the price in an M&A transaction.
The Initial Price May Not Be Real
The initial dollar figure presented as a purchase price for a business, whether written on a napkin over coffee, or floated in a conversation, is not a binding offer. Any potential acquirer will need to conduct a due diligence investigation before they can enter into a definitive agreement to buy your business. Initial indications can be tactically inflated to ensure the acquirer gains access to your confidential information after which this price is systematically reduced, citing negative findings during due diligence – also known as “The Due Diligence Grind”. The most effective antidotes are preparation and competitive tension. Let's take a closer look at how a prospective buyer can grind down the purchase price.

Due Diligence becomes a Reactive Process for the Seller

Whether you have received a preliminary proposal from a single party who approached you or you’ve received several non-binding bids through a structured auction process, the nature of the process changes from proactive to reactive as due diligence progresses. Ultimately, each bidder will have different due diligence requirements and the onus is on the seller to satisfy those requirements (or not). The due diligence stage is the acquirer’s opportunity to investigate the business from top to bottom. Although difficult, it is essential to maintain control of the process, despite your reactive position during this phase of the process.

How Due Diligence Increases Transaction Risk and Impacts Valuation

The purpose of due diligence is for the acquirer to conduct his or her own assessment of the value of your business and to confirm their initial assumptions. As you submit information about your business to a potential acquirer, they will investigate potential risks, including validating information that may have been presented to them earlier in the process. Due diligence is an essential step for the acquirer to make a binding commitment to a price and to inform the negotiation of the definitive agreement. However, savvy acquirers are skillful at gaming this process to their advantage.
Potential acquirers can by cynical. A key due diligence objective is lowering the price of the business by focusing on its flaws – Imagine a customer listing a litany of complaints or deficiencies about your product or service as you are presenting your case for a routine pricing increase. Potential acquirers may attempt to reduce the value of the business either explicitly, by reducing the headline price, or indirectly, by revealing transaction terms that erode the value you receive.

Headline Price Adjustments via Valuation Metrics

Private businesses are routinely valued as a multiple of a particular financial metric. One of the more commonly used metrics is Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation and Amortization (EBITDA). Adjustments are commonly applied to normalize EBITDA for what it would be in the hands of the new owner. These metrics are reported as part of the preliminary documentation and are scrutinized heavily during the due diligence process. The acquirer will typically seek to expose weaknesses in the information and rationale for the normalization adjustments to make a case that the metric is inflated. A few examples include:
  • Accounting Policies: Suggesting accounting policies, such as revenue recognition, allowance for doubtful accounts or capitalization policy are too aggressive.
  • Normalization Adjustments: Suggesting that non-recurring normalization adjustments really are normal-course business, that market value of the owner’s compensation is understated, that certain expense savings really are buyer synergies that are not appropriate for stand-alone valuation.
  • Budgets and Forecasts: Often the valuation is based on a forward metric, such as forecast EBITDA. The seller’s forecast assumptions may be deemed too optimistic, or as we Canadians like to describe it, a “hockey stick forecast”, where projected growth is out of line with historical growth.
Given that the headline value is simply the product of the valuation metric and the valuation multiple, a reduction in the metric will have a proportionate impact on the headline price.

Headline Price Adjustments via the Multiple

Though less common that a negative revision to the metric, a bidder may suggest they have justification to reduce the multiple they have applied in their initial valuation assumptions because of newly identified/revised risks that they claim they were not aware of earlier. There are generally four reasons the valuation multiple may be reduced, the first three of which are specific to the business:
    1. Greater business risk, such as poor quality of earnings;
    2. Lower expected growth as a result of improperly supported growth forecasts;
    3. Reduced free cash flow conversion expectations, such as higher than expected capital expenditure or working capital requirements; or
    4. Deterioration in market conditions, such as a drop in capital markets valuations or tightening credit

Adjustments to the Transaction Terms

Negative revisions can also manifest in the deal terms. This can be more difficult to control because such details are usually ignored as part of the “business deal” and left for the lawyers. The acquirer may claim due diligence findings that require terms that either erode the value of the headline price or significantly shift risk to the seller. Examples include:
  • Shifting Risk to the Seller: Out-of-market representations and warranties, indemnities or hold-backs. For example, an acquirer may agree on the ‘price tag’ of the deal, but add a condition that if the seller misses the five-year forecast by one dollar, the price paid will be reduced by 50%.
  • Changing the form of Consideration: That firm cash price may become payable in IOU’s and store coupons. A portion of the price may become contingent on performance of the business post-closing, i.e. as an earnout.
  • Working Capital: This one is a favorite! Instead of delivering the business with a level of working capital appropriate to operate the business in the normal course, you are presented with a convoluted adjustment mechanism that suggests the business should be delivered with more working capital than needed, resulting in a negative price revision for you post-closing. Or the most egregious of working capital manipulation, the cash dam.
  • Effective Date: Seems innocent enough. Let’s make the effective date at the beginning of this year. The problem is that all of that free cash flow from the effective date until closing now belongs to the acquirer. Another effective reduction in the purchase price.

For more discussion on strategies for taking control of the due diligence process and negating the due diligence grind click here.

Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.