Showing posts with label data room. Show all posts
Showing posts with label data room. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 31, 2017

Article Review: Timing an Exit | Diverstopedia

 ,   

Key Takeaway: Early exit planning is both necessary and invaluable. Take these steps to ensure you are putting yourself int he best position possible when it comes time to leave your business.
Timing an Exit
Source: turk-stock-photographer/iStock

Takeaways:


  • Day-to-day operations take precedence for the owner and exit / succession planning is often an afterthought.
  • An effective plan begins long before an actual exit.
  • Important elements of a plan to maximize value:
    • Be able to demonstrate long-term relationships with customers/clients.
    • Have a solid management team in place (remove owner dependency).
    • Review your strategy and operational plans (niche > too diversified with no strategy).
    • Clean up your financial statements.
    • Track key performance metrics.
    • Establish a message around QOE and performance and anticipate buyer questions.
    • Identify the ideal buyer(s), estimate their valuation and what would drive it higher.
    • Be honest about the strengths and weaknesses of your business.

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com. To search for Florida Businesses for Sale: CLICK HERE

Tuesday, March 14, 2017

7 Fundamentals to Due Diligence You Need to Know | Divestopedia

By  , 
Takeaway: Being open about your business practices and financial statements can lead to a better takeaway for both the buyer and seller.
7 Fundamentals to Due Diligence You Need to Know
Source: Info40555/Dreamstime.com
According to Bizbuysell.com, there were a total of 1,840 businesses transactions that took place worldwide during the first quarter of 2016. Businesses were either bought and sold or mergers and acquisitions took place in that first quarter. People buy and sell or merge businesses for different reasons, but whatever the reasons, there are always a wide variety of preliminary activities that must take place prior to closing the deal. In almost all cases, an attorney who is fluent in due diligence for mergers and acquisitions is required to ensure that the transaction takes place based on the laws that have been put into place by FINRA or other regulatory agencies.

1. Historic and Projected Financial Information

Historic Information

The seller should be providing financial documents for the past three years. The buyer will need to perform due diligence concerning the company’s historical financial information and supporting documentation.
The seller will need to provide documents for the buyer to perform an assessment of the company’s financial statements so they can make note of any financial trends, spikes or decreases in sales and revenue, consistencies or inconsistencies in cash flow activity, the company’s current debt, receivables and other assets, as well as all other aspects of the company's financial performance.

Projected Information

In addition to performing due diligence on the historical financial information, the buyer will also need to perform due diligence on any future financial activity as well. Carefully checking to ensure reasonable financial projections of the company’s future performance were made. Some of those areas involve whether or not the projections are based on reasonable assumptions whereby a clear path to achieving those results is laid out and linked to the actual financial activity in a practical, succinct manner.
  • Is the projected financial information sound and believable?
  • Were the documents succinct?
  • How much working capital is necessary to continue running the business beyond its current state?
  • Are there additional capital expenditures or other required investments that need to take place to ensure the future growth of the business?

2. Technology Developments and Intellectual Property

The seller will need to provide the buyer's attorney with information about any current or pending intellectual property, technology developments, copyright and patent ownerships that the company may have.
If the company has patent applications and potential trademarks, the buyer should ensure that the appropriate registration has taken place. When materials are used in marketing or technological advances, the company must have the rights and control the copyright, or risk lawsuits. If they haven't, it could be a risk for the buyer who will take on any liability based on prior violations.
Trade secrets are vital to the success of some companies, so as the seller, you'll need to ensure that the secrets have been preserved appropriately and other companies' secrets have not been infringed by your company and be able to prove that to the buyer.

3. Customers and Revenue Streams

Before purchase, the seller will have to detail the various revenue streams of the business. This includes the company's satisfied customers, and what they purchase. The buyer should have a grasp of who the customers are as well as how revenue is generated by these customers especially the top 20 percent who will account for much of the business.
Another consideration is the satisfaction of the customers after a change in ownership. Are there going to be problems with new ownership that will impact the business' revenue going forward?
Along with evaluating customer loyalty and spending habits, the seller will be giving the buyer information about the backlog of issues. Are there warranty problems that are not being handled properly? Do there seem to be a high level of exchanges and refunds being issued? The seller should already have this information and be able to tell the buyer why there were problems.

4. Contract Agreements and Insurance

A review of all pending and active contracts and agreements should be a part of the due diligence process as well as a review of insurance coverage.
The key areas include some of the following:
  • Outstanding loans, personal guarantors, and note payables
  • Outstanding customer and vendor contracts
  • Partnerships, joint venture, or operating agreements
  • Outstanding or pending Settlement agreements
  • Equipment or vehicle lease agreements
  • Independent contractor and Employment agreements
  • General liability and Worker’s compensation insurance
  • D&O / E&O and Key man insurance
  • Intellectual property insurance
  • Vehicle insurance
  • Health insurance
  • Umbrella policies

5. Staff and Key Management

The buyer will need to perform diligence activity for all staff, independent contractors, and key management. This should include looking into scheduled pay raises, equity shares, profit distributions, 401(k), commissions, bonuses and other employment related issues. This means the seller will need to have opened their human resource files and be willing to have a buyer comb through the documents.
Along with the functionality of the human resources department regarding compensation, there should be a detailed audit of the history of labor disputes. If there's even been a threat to stop working for any reason, that could be a red flag, but the buyer will need to look into the issues that caused the employees to be disgruntled.

6. Legal and Compliance

One of the biggest headaches for a buyer can be legal tangles, which include any current, pending or settled litigation, arbitration or other proceedings. Any compliance- or regulation-related issues can be a problem, too. This is where the buyer's attorney should be forecasting the result of the litigation as well as investigating claims and threats against the company. The seller can help by being as forthcoming as possible and talking to their own attorneys about the legal future of any claims.
With detailed due diligence procedures for acquisitions, a seller can avoid serious legal problems in the future by looking at the prior, current, and future potential for legal threats. There might even be matters in arbitration at the moment that could resolve into a problem for the new owner. In some cases, a buyer might come back and sue a seller for fraud if they weren't forthcoming with information regarding fraud.

7. Tax Issues

It’s important to perform a tax due diligence to determine whether the company has any tax liability issues. This process should include a review of tax returns that have been filed within the past five years including the federal, state, and local returns. The buyer's accountants and attorneys should be checking for net operating losses. Credit carryovers should be investigated to ensure that the change in ownership won't impact the relationship with the creditor.
If there have been agreements, waivers or tax communications with the IRS, the new buyer should understand exactly what that means for acquiring the business. If there have been settlement agreements with the IRS or other agencies, the seller will want to let the buyer know that those will not impact the new ownership negatively, and might not carry over to the new buyer.

Final Words

Due diligence in merger and acquisitions requires that a substantial amount of activities take place from both sides prior to making a full commitment to the transaction. It’s a means for the buyer to do some fact-checking, so that he or she is fully aware of what is actually being purchased. By carefully planning these and other related activities for the due diligence in mergers and acquisitions process, the buyer will feel confident in his decision and will be prepared to proceed with the purchase of the business. The seller will be able to say that they provided all the information the buyer needed to make a sound decision.

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com.

Monday, February 29, 2016

9 Critical Areas for Effective Due Diligence | Divestopedia

By  , 

Takeaway: Part 2 of a two part article discusses what constitutes an effective operations due diligence and nine critical areas of focus.
9 Critical Areas for Effective Due Diligence
Source: flickr/ImagesofMoney
In Part 1 of this article, I described the need for both investors and business owners to perform an operations due diligence and the role of these assessments. In Part 2 we will discuss what constitutes an effective operations due diligence.

When I was writing my book "Operations Due Diligence - An M&A Guide for Investors and Business" I didn’t realize what a radical idea this would be for some people. Over the past year I have had very few people who acknowledged that an effective due diligence included the need to perform an enterprise risk/operations assessment… until the benefit was explicitly pointed out to them. This is the point when I see the twinkle of understanding come into the faces of my audiences and they have a moment of understanding, "of course I knew that"… but it’s clear they had never actually made the connection of performing an enterprise wide assessment as part of their due diligence. And here is how I know they had not thought of it as an enterprise wide assessment.

Generally, when their hands went up in response to my question about what should be assessed beyond legal and financial due diligence and the "Ooo, Ooo, Ooo… started I found most people picked one particular operations area they felt needed to be assessed. Without the principals of law or accounting to guide them, the requirements of an effective operations due diligence have not previously been very well defined. Some investors look at the management team or the sales pipeline or, if it’s a software company for instance, they have an engineer look at the code. Unlike legal or financial due diligence an operations due diligence needs to covers a lot of potential risk areas. Most investors perform their operations assessment in an ad hoc manner assessing random areas based on who they currently have on staff or looking just in places where they have had past problems. They send an engineer to look at the source code or a department manager to speak with the management team. This team has rarely been trained to perform a true enterprise risk assessment. Generally they are asked for their opinion of one particular business function or another. When they are asked, universally these investors believe they have performed an operations due diligence. Universally, they have failed and this failure to perform an effective operations due diligence that spans the entire operations infrastructure of the business (the enterprise) is one of the leading causes of M&A failures. An effective operations due diligence should be performed by a Business Analyst with enterprise risk assessment experience whose goal is to assess the operations infrastructure of the business.

To quote one bright young MBA graduate, "OMG, that’s a lot of stuff!" Yes it is and I am often asked if it can be cut back. Yes it can but you risk (there’s that pesky risk word again) the opportunity to discover a latent risk or opportunity that could impact the future sustainability of the business. If you are going to bet a large sum of money, maybe it’s worth the time to perform an effective assessment. In our practice we recommend assessing the following nine operations infrastructure areas:

CUSTOMER SATISFACTION: The customer satisfaction infrastructure has to be designed as an integral part of the business and not simply included like a facade over the front door. The customer satisfaction infrastructure defines the role of functions such as product support, requirements definition, and quality assurance.

PRODUCTION/SERVICES: The production/services infrastructure defines the methods that will be used for the delivery of all products and services and ensure that this is being done in a safe, compliant, and consistent manner capable of bringing all products and services fully to market.

INFORMATION MANAGEMENT: It would be a tremendous understatement to say that all businesses today are information intensive. The information management infrastructure defines the methods for protecting all business data, the electronic tools that form the backbone of the business, printed material and all media that is used to support the business. All personal privacy and security controls need to be assessed here.

SALES AND MARKETING: The sales and marketing infrastructure defines the methods used for everything from pricing and lead flow needed to support the sales pipeline to the methods used to develop new products and markets including the use of competitive and strategic analysis as assessment tools.

ORGANIZATIONAL: The definition of the organizational infrastructure includes the formal and informal structure of the business. It includes the organization chart that forms the command and control structure plus the informal structure that becomes the culture of the business.

PERSONNEL: The personnel infrastructure defines the working relationship between the business and its employees and between employees including the roles and authority of the management team. It defines the benefit strategy and compensation plan plus the procedures for hiring, firing and everything in between.

FINANCIAL OPERATIONS: The financial operations infrastructure forms the framework for all financial operations of the business. It defines all financial authority and controls including AP/AR, payroll, cost account and project management, plus the definition of methods to be used for budgeting and projections.

LEGAL OPERATIONS: The legal operations infrastructure forms the framework for all legal operations of the business. It defines all legal authority, professional licensing and controls needed to support the business on a continuing basis. It defines all activities used to protect the business from legal risk and liabilities and to ensure the compliant operation of the business.

INSTITUTIONALIZED PROCESSES: The institutionalized processes infrastructure includes the definition of all formalized policies, procedures and methods that guide the businesses operations. Methods such as ISO, CMMI, Six Sigma, Enterprise Risk Management (ERM), Lean or Quality Management Systems (QMS) and any areas where the business needs certification to qualify for a market driven process are defined.

Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Tuesday, February 2, 2016

22 Mistakes Made by Sellers in M&A Transactions | All Business


By  | In: Buying a Business, M&A Transactions, Selling a Business


World-Business-teamwork-puzzle-pieces

Selling a company is often difficult and time consuming. The mergers and acquisitions (M&A) process is one that requires careful planning, competent professionals assisting the target company, and an understanding of the deal dynamics involved in the negotiations. CEOs and companies that have not been engaged in many M&A transactions frequently make mistakes that can result in a less favorable price or terms that would have otherwise been obtainable —or even kill the deal altogether.
The following is a list of common mistakes made by private companies attempting to sell themselves:
1. Not being prepared for the extensive effort and time the deal will take. Successful exits through M&A are not easy. They are time consuming, involve significant due diligence by the buyer, and require both a great deal of advance preparation as well as a substantial resource commitment by the seller. Acquisitions can often take 6 to 12 months or more to complete.
2. Failing to create a competitive sales process. The best deals for sellers usually occur when there are multiple potential bidders and leverage of the competitive situation can be used to obtain a higher price, better deal terms, or both. Negotiating with only one bidder (particularly where the bidder knows it’s the only potential buyer) frequently puts the selling company at a significant disadvantage. Sellers must try to set up an auction or competitive bidding process to avoid being boxed in by a demand for exclusivity by a bidder. By having multiple bidders, each bidder can be played off against the other bidders to arrive at a favorable deal. Even the perception that there are multiple interested parties can help in the negotiations.
3. Not having an appropriate NDA. A well-drafted nondisclosure agreement (NDA) is essential to protect the company’s secrets and proprietary information, particularly when the bidders are strategic competitors. While it is not necessary when first contacting a buyer with basic information about the selling company, it will be a mistake to engage in extensive disclosure during an M&A process without an NDA in place, one that includes special M&A-related protections for the seller. The NDA will require the potential buyer to not disclose or use confidential information of the seller and restrict the buyer’s ability to contact employees, customers, and suppliers. The NDA also should prohibit the buyer from soliciting or hiring any employees of the seller if a deal is not consummated, for a designated period of time.
4. Not having a complete online data room. An online data room contains all of the key information and documents that a bidder will want to review. This will include key contracts, patents, financial statements, employee information, and much more. An online data room is extremely time consuming to put together, but is essential to successful completion of a deal. A properly populated data room established early in the M&A process will not only allow buyers to complete their due diligence more quickly, but also will enable the seller and its advisors to expeditiously prepare the disclosure schedule, a critical document in the M&A process. But almost every seller underestimates how important this is, and how time consuming it is to get complete and correct.
5. Hiring the wrong legal counsel. You shouldn’t have a general practitioner or general corporate lawyer guide the seller through the M&A process or negotiate and draft the acquisition documents. You must have a lawyer who primarily or exclusively handles mergers and acquisitions. There are many difficult and complicated issues in structuring M&A deals, putting together acquisition agreements, and executing the transaction. You want a lawyer who understands the issues thoroughly, understands customary market terms, understands the M&A legal landscape, is responsive with a sense of urgency, and who has done numerous acquisitions.
6. Not hiring a great financial advisor or investment banker. In many situations, a financial advisor or an investment banker experienced in M&A can bring value to the table by doing the following:
  • Assisting the seller and its legal counsel in developing an optimal sale process
  • Helping to prepare an executive summary and confidential information memorandum for potential buyers
  • Surfacing up and contacting prospective buyers
  • Coordinating meetings with potential buyers
  • Coordinating signing of NDAs
  • Assisting the seller in properly populating the online data room
  • Coordinating the seller’s responses to buyer due diligence requests
  • Prepping the management team for presentations to the potential buyers
  • Assisting in the negotiations on deal terms and price
  • Advising on market comparable valuations
One tip prior to hiring a financial advisor or an investment banker: have them give you a list of likely buyers, with annotations listing their relationships with senior executives of those buyers. You want an advisor that has strong relationships with the likely buyers and can get their attention.
7. Not negotiating the terms of the financial advisor or investment banker engagement letter. The first draft of an engagement letter is generally one-sided in favor of the financial advisor or investment banker. Companies that just sign or minimally negotiate such letters are making a huge mistake. These letters are negotiable, and savvy legal counsel/deal professionals typically negotiate on the following issues, among others:
  • The compensation payable to the advisor is typically a success fee, based as a percentage of the ultimate sales price. What is often negotiated is the percentage (for example, the bankers will want 2% or more, the company will want a fee closer to 1% but possibly increasing if certain sales price thresholds are met). The calculation of the fee owed should also exclude various items, such as any portion of the purchase price attributable to the cash that the company has on its balance sheet at the closing, or contingent purchase price payments that may never be made.
  • Whether there is a minimum fee payable on a sale regardless of the purchase price (companies want to avoid this, but bankers want to make sure they are getting adequately compensated for their efforts).
  • How long and under what situations a “tail” applies (when a fee will be due after the engagement letter is terminated but the company subsequently is sold). Companies try to limit this tail to 6 to 9 months and only for potential buyers that signed an NDA with the company during the terms of the engagement letter.
  • The amount of any upfront retainer payable to the banker (it is common that the retainer is waived and the advisor or banker is paid nothing unless a transaction is successfully completed).
  • The amount of any expenses reimbursable to the investment banker (usually a cap is negotiated with a requirement that any amounts expended must be “reasonable”).
  • The circumstances where the engagement letter can be terminated without any liability and without a tail applying (for example, if the key banker departs from the banking firm or the banker breaches the engagement letter).
  • Whether the banker will deliver a fairness opinion and the fee for such opinion.
  • The scope of indemnification protection to the banker.
  • An outside termination date when the engagement letter will automatically expire.
  • A restriction/representation and warranty regarding any conflicts of interest by the banker.
8. Having an inadequate understanding of competitors and market comparables. A well-informed seller will have a deep understanding of the competitive landscape, as the buyer will be asking many questions about how the seller is differentiated in the marketplace. To avoid having unrealistic selling price expectations, the seller needs to understand how other comparable companies are being valued in the marketplace. If your competitors have sold for multiples of 5 times revenues or 10 times EBITDA, you will need a compelling rationale why you should be valued much higher (for example, you have greater growth, better technology, etc.)
9. Having incomplete books, records, and contracts. Due diligence investigations by buyers frequently find problems in the seller’s historical documentation process, including some or all of the following problems:
  • Contracts not signed by both parties
  • Contracts that have been amended but without the amendment terms signed
  • Missing or unsigned Board minutes or resolutions
  • Missing or unsigned stockholder minutes or resolutions
  • Board or stockholder minutes/resolutions missing referenced exhibits
  • Incomplete/unsigned employee-related documents, such as stock option agreements or invention assignment agreements
Deficiencies of this kind may be so important to a buyer that the buyer will require certain matters to be remedied as a condition to closing. That can sometimes be problematic, such as instances where a buyer insists that ex-employees be located and required to sign invention assignment agreements.
10. Not having a complete disclosure schedule far in advance. A disclosure schedule is the document attached to the acquisition agreement setting forth a great deal of required disclosures relating to outstanding key contracts, intellectual property, related party transactions, employee information, pending litigation, insurance, and much more. A well-prepared disclosure schedule is critical to ensuring that the seller will not breach its representations and warranties in the acquisition agreement.
Accordingly, this is an extremely important document to have ready quickly, and it is very time consuming to get correct. But virtually every company gets this wrong, requiring multiple drafts that potentially delay a deal. And disclosure schedules prepared at the last minute are more likely to be poorly prepared, creating unnecessary risks for the seller and its stockholders.
11. Not negotiating the key terms of the deal in a letter of intent. This is one of the biggest mistakes made by sellers. A selling company’s bargaining power is greatest prior to signing a letter of intent. As Richard Vernon Smith, an M&A partner at Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe in San Francisco, has said: “The letter of intent in an M&A deal is extremely important for ensuring the likelihood of a favorable deal for a seller. Once the letter of intent is signed, the leverage typically swings to the buyer.” This is because the buyer will typically require a “no shop” clause or exclusivity provision prohibiting the seller from talking to any other bidders for a period of time. The key terms to negotiate in the letter of intent include the following:
  • The price, and whether it will be paid all cash up front, all stock (including the type of stock), or part promissory notes.
  • Any adjustments to the price and how these adjustments will be calculated (such as for working capital adjustments at the closing or for a “cash free/debt free” deal).
  • The scope and length of any exclusivity/ no shop provision (which is always in the best interests of the seller to keep this as short as possible, such as 14 to 21 days).
  • The non-binding nature of the terms (excluding with respect to confidentiality and exclusivity).
  • The amount of any escrow and a provision stating that the escrow will be the exclusive remedy for breaches of the agreement (and any exceptions from this exclusive remedy, such as for breaches of “fundamental representations”).
  • The length of any escrow.
  • Other key terms to be included in the acquisition agreement (discussed in the next section below).
12. Failing to negotiate and agree upon a favorable acquisition agreement. One key to a successful sale of a company is having a well-drafted acquisition agreement protecting the seller as much as possible. To the extent feasible and depending on the leverage the seller has, you want your counsel to prepare the first draft of the acquisition agreement. Here are some of the key provisions included in the acquisition agreement:
  • Amount of the escrow holdback for indemnification claims by the buyer and the period of the escrow/holdback (the typical ideal scenario for a seller is 5 to 10 percent of the purchase price for 9 to 12 months). In some deals it may be possible to negotiate for no post-closing indemnification by the buyer and no escrow/holdback.
  • The exclusive nature of the escrow/holdback for breaches of the acquisition agreement (except perhaps for breaches of certain fundamental representations, such as capitalization and organization of the company).
  • The conditions to closing (a seller will ideally want to limit these to ensure that it can actually close the transaction quickly).
  • The adjustments to the price (a seller ideally wants to avoid downward adjustment mechanisms based on working capital adjustments, employee issues, etc.).
  • The triggers for earnouts or contingent purchase price payments.
  • Where stock is to be issued to the selling stockholders, the extent of rights and restrictions on that stock (such as registration rights, co-sale rights, rights of first refusal, Board of Director representation, etc.).
  • The nature of the representations and warranties (a seller wants these qualified to the greatest extent possible with materiality and knowledge qualifiers). Intellectual property, financial and liability representations and warranties merit particular focus.
  • The nature of the covenants applicable between signing and closing (a seller wants these to be limited and reasonable, with the ability of the company to get consents if changes are needed, with the consent not to be unreasonably withheld, delayed, or conditioned).
  • The scope of and exclusions to the indemnity (baskets, caps, carve outs from the indemnity all being important issues).
  • The treatment of employee options
  • The terms of any employee hiring by the acquirer
  • Provisions for termination of the acquisition agreement
  • The treatment of any litigation against the seller
  • The cost for obtaining any consents and governmental approvals
  • The allocation of risk, especially concerning unknown liabilities
As David Lipkin, an M&A partner at the law firm of Morrison & Foerster in San Francisco, has said, “A well-drafted M&A agreement will reduce the risks of not closing the deal, mitigate the potential post-closing risks, and ensure that the expectations of the target company and its stockholders are met. One of the worst mistakes a seller can make is to assume that a ‘middle of the road’ approach to each issue will offer it appropriate protection.”
13. Not appreciating that time is the enemy of all deals. The longer an M&A process drags on, the higher the likelihood that the deal will not happen or the terms will get worse. The seller and the seller’s lawyer must have a sense of urgency in getting things done, responding to due diligence requests, turning around markups of documents, and the like. It is also essential that one seller representative is delegated authority to make quick decisions on negotiating issues so that the deal momentum can be maintained.
14. Not having an experienced M&A negotiator lead the negotiations. It’s critical to have an experienced M&A negotiator leading the negotiations. That can be the CEO if he or she has relevant M&A experience. But you need someone who is a match for the buyer’s sophisticated lawyers or corporate development team. Often though, the smart CEO will want to avoid being seen as difficult in the negotiation when the buyer will be expecting the CEO to stay on after the acquisition. And the savvy CEO will be aware of the conflicts of interest that will arise. The selling company wants to avoid acrimonious negotiations, as this could eventually kill a deal if the buyer determines that there won’t be a cultural fit. The CEO or the Board may then determine that it will be more appropriate for the lead negotiator to be a representative from the Board, an M&A Committee of the Board, or a representative from a major shareholder in collaboration with experienced M&A counsel.
15. Negotiating the deal without regard to tax considerations. The tax structuring implications of a deal can have a significant impact on the net economic return to the stockholders. Buyers often prefer to do asset purchase deals as those can provide a “step up” in tax basis (and may mitigate the potential of taking on unknown liabilities of the seller). But sellers will usually prefer a stock sale or engaging in a reverse triangular merger, as this eliminates the risk of “double taxation” present in many asset deals, and enables the seller to avoid the burden and expense of winding up the company’s remaining assets and liabilities.
16. Neglecting the day-to-day operation of the business during the M&A process. The process of selling a company will be hugely distracting and time consuming. Nevertheless, management must keep its eye on the ball and ensure that the business continues to grow and operate efficiently in line with projections given to the buyer. One of the worst things that can happen in an M&A process is for the selling company’s financial situation to deteriorate during the process. This may kill the deal or result in the buyer renegotiating price and terms.
17. Failing to communicate the vision and strategic fit. The selling company’s CEO must be able to effectively communicate to bidders the company’s vision and significant growth prospects. Regardless of the company’s current performance, unless the buyer is excited that the company will continue to scale and be significantly more valuable to the buyer in the future, a deal at an attractive price will not happen. If the buyer is a strategic buyer, you have to be able to articulate the synergies and strategic fit of combining with the acquirer.
18. Absence of credible financial projections. The buyer will expend a great deal of time doing diligence on the company’s current financials and future projections. Having unreasonable projections or unrealistic assumptions will adversely affect the credibility of the management team. If the management team does not know the company’s key metrics cold and lacks the ability to convincingly demonstrate the reasonableness of the projections, this will give the buyer pause.
19. Not considering change of control provisions in key contracts. If the selling company has key contracts, licenses, or leases that require consents from third parties in connection with a change in control of the company, it is critical that these consent requirements be identified early on in the process. The same holds true with respect to important governmental permits. Counsel will need to be deeply involved in identifying and evaluating these requirements. Then a plan should be adopted to obtain those consents in a timely manner. A buyer may insist that those consents be obtained prior to a closing of the sale.
20. Not adequately taking into account employee-related issues. Transactions will typically include a number of employee issues. The questions that frequently arise in M&A transactions are the following:
  • What is the acquirer’s plan for retention and motivation of the company’s employees?
  • How will the company’s stock options be dealt with? (From the seller’s perspective, it is desirable to have the acquirer assume all the options but count only the vested options toward the purchase price.)
  • Do any options accelerate by their terms as a result of the deal? Some options may be a “single trigger” (accelerate by reason of the deal closing) and others may be “double trigger” (accelerate following the closing only if employment is terminated within a defined period of time). The option plan and related option grant agreements must be carefully reviewed to anticipate any problems.
  • Does the company need to establish a “carve out” to pay employees at the closing, or a change in control bonus payment to motivate management to sell the company?
  • How do the investors make sure that the buyer’s incentive arrangements to the management team do not adversely affect the price payable to the shareholders?
  • Will payouts to employees related to the deal trigger the excise tax provisions of Internal Revenue Code Section 280G (the so-called “golden parachute” tax)? If so, the seller needs to obtain a special stockholder vote to avoid application of this tax liability.
21. Not understanding the negotiation dynamics. All M&A negotiations require a number of compromises. It is critical to understand which party has the leverage in the negotiations. Who wants the deal more—the buyer or the seller? Are there multiple bidders that can be played against each other? Can you negotiate key non-financial terms in exchange for a concession on price? Is the deal price sufficiently attractive that the seller is willing to live with indemnification obligations that are less than optimal? It’s important to establish a rapport with the lead negotiator on the other side and it’s never good to let negotiations get heated or antagonistic. All negotiations should be conducted with courtesy and professionalism.
22. Not carefully negotiating earn-out provisions. An earn-out arrangement provides a selling company or its stockholders the potential to recover an additional payment following the closing, dependent on the financial performance of the business or achievement of designated milestones. The inclusion of an earn-out provision in an acquisition agreement can be useful in bridging the valuation gap between a seller and a buyer. But earn-out provisions frequently lead to disputes and even litigation unless carefully and thoughtfully drafted. Here are the key points to negotiate:
  • What are the realistic financial milestones to be achieved before the earn-out is payable? Buyers tend to prefer profit or EBITDA metrics, whereas sellers prefer metrics that have less chance to be manipulated, such as gross revenues. Usually, metrics which are easy to measure and verify are beneficial to the seller.
  • What overhead and extraordinary liabilities will be excluded from the calculation if the milestones are based on profit or EBITDA?
  • What is the timetable for the earn-out? Over one year or several years?
  • What payments are required as milestones are achieved?
  • Is the earn-out payable in a lump sum or sliding scale?
  • Is there a cap on the earn-out payments?
  • What protections does the seller get to ensure that the buyer will take reasonable best efforts to operate the business in a way that won’t artificially decrease the earn-out? (for example, will the buyer promise to adequately fund the business post-closing?)
  • What happens if the buyer itself is subsequently sold? Does that buyer then assume the earn-out obligation or are the earn-out payments then accelerated?
  • How will disputes be resolved? (Arbitration is typically more desirable for a seller.)
  • Can the buyer offset indemnification claims against the earn-out?
  • What information, auditing, and inspection rights will the seller get?
It’s important to understand that earn-out provisions are fully negotiable and the likelihood of getting paid is significantly dependent on how well the provision is drafted.
 Copyright © Richard D. Harroch. All Rights Reserved.
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.