Showing posts with label Cash flow statement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cash flow statement. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 22, 2017

When EBITDA Is Just a Number: The Limitations of EBITDA | Axial

Karen Sibayan | January 20, 2016
Experts agree that EBITDA has limitations and should be taken in the context of other factors in the transaction. Buyers seriously interested in your company will also conduct in-depth due diligence processes to examine your company’s financials over a longer period of time. This is essential for buyers to get a proper assessment of a business’s worth.
“EBITDA is only the starting point and due diligence should result in the discovery of whatever operational issues there are in the financial reporting and EBITDA,” says John Weld, managing director at Strategic Value Advisors.
The due diligence can either happen before or after the letter of intent (LOI). There is no set practice for when due diligence is conducted — many buyers already conduct rigorous due diligence before they submit an LOI or have a more intensive process after the LOI. An M&A advisor can provide you with more information about the due diligence process and timeline.
The norm is for buyers to examine a minimum of three years of financial statements and tax returns — with many of them looking at five years — to determine a target’s profitability trends. “They look at a firm’s tax returns and compare them to its financial accounting reports because these returns may tell something about the business’ expense structure as well as the quality of a company’s profitability that might not be apparent from the financial statements,” Weld says.
Beyond this, buyers will look at a target company’s balance sheet history as a means of discovering existing or potential cash flow issues. “Thus, reported EBITDA is important, but is not, by any means, all that a buyer looks at to determine value of a target,” he says.
Conducting a quality of earnings review by looking at three- to five- years of EBITDA will allow buyers to see whether the metric has gone up or down or if it has shown consistency over that period. This gives a sense of a business’ predictability.
Through due diligence, investors are looking for “growth and an indication of whether a company will continue to grow in the future,” says Adams Price, a managing director at the Forbes M&A Group. “The more important things are consistency and quality of earnings.”
Among other factors, what buyers seek “is EBITDA consistently growing over time,” Price says. “Looking at a longer period of time is always better — certainly a period near an economic cycle, which would give a good indication of performance.” Companies that still had predictable earnings or that had not gone down during the downturn in 2009-2010 are particularly attractive.

The Limitations of EBITDA

EBITDA is a reliable number that the industry cannot ignore. However, investors have to use a variety of measurements when buying a company — including, as demonstrated above, testing for the quality of earnings as part of their due diligence.

“While EBITDA is a good measure especially when comparing investments, it is not a catch-all metric that can completely capture a company’s worth,” says Craig Dickens, founder and CEO of the Merit Harbor Group. “Many owners have become fixated on multiples of earnings or multiples of EBITDA. That can leave significant value on the table.”  This is especially true, he says, as intangibles are increasingly becoming a larger part of a company’s overall value.
Intangibles — non-physical assets like intellectual property (i.e. patents and trademarks) and brand recognition — “are receiving more and greater importance in deals and, ultimately, multiples,” Dickens says. Building a company’s value through intangibles can significantly increase its value over time.
The case of intangibles is clearly a situation where EBITDA plays a smaller part in valuing a company. “Especially at early stages of operations of such companies, EBITDA might not provide a sound basis for determining the real value of the enterprise,” says Strategic Value’s Weld.
The warning here is — “don’t just stop at looking at EBITDA as a proxy for value. Great bankers can help owners monetize the intangibles as well,” Dickens says. “As with many things, the total value of a company cannot be reduced to just one number.”
He encourages acquirers to factor in the following as part of their analysis:
  •   Growth rates
  •   Size
  •   Intangibles
  •   Quality of earnings
  •   Intellectual property
  •   Barriers to entry
  •   Recurring revenue
  •   Customer concentration issues
These are “on par or even more important than EBITDA,” Dickens says. For a business owner considering sale, it’s important to focus on and account for each of these factors of interest.
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Thursday, December 29, 2016

How Using Adjusted EBITDA Can Make Your Business More Attractive to Buyers | Axial

English: Table 6: Example of a cash flow calcu...
Example of a cash flow calculation. The Organic Business Guide. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
By Karen Sibayan | January 18, 2016

Getting a better valuation is one of the most important considerations when selling a business. Using an adjusted EBITDA calculation can help enhance your company’s attractiveness by providing the buyer an accurate depiction of future cash flow. (For more on the basics, see What Is EBITDA, and Why Do Investors Care About It?).
The adjusted EBITDA calculation takes into account certain items that have no bearing on a firm’s actual operational costs including non-recurring or one-time expenses.
Due to the way private companies account for these items, the use of adjusted EBITDA is more typical of private deals.
“A private company’s expense structure may not reflect market compensation rates, and often are not reported in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) standards,” says John Weld, a managing director of Strategic Value Advisors. “In publicly traded companies, which are subject to GAAP accounting, such anomalies aren’t as prevalent.”
Aside from distinctions in size, the items that are included in the adjusted EBITDA calculation varies for every company depending on its payment structure and expenses.
Using the adjusted EBITDA calculation, companies can take out an extraordinary item including one-time litigation expenses or not factor that into a company’s ongoing expenses.
They can also take into account certain add-backs. “The adjusted EBITDA number is different due to certain add-backs, indicating what companies have to pay above the line to get to profitability,” says James Cassel, chairman of Cassel Salpeter & Co.
He explains that to get to net profits from EBITDA, companies have to add back the taxes, depreciation, amortization, and interest. For example, in the case of a family-owned business, the salary of a family member who is not active in the business might be added back in an adjusted EBITDA figure.  

Another potential add-back is cost savings based on expenses that can be eliminated after a merger happens and upon integration. These add-backs can be viewed as synergies in an M&A deal. For instance, a buyer might already have an accounting department. Or Cassel cites selling a widget software business that has its own CFO or has excess capacity. “As investment bankers, we try to show that, due to synergies, there are X dollars of savings,” Cassel says.
But, the problem lies in who gets the benefit of the saving. For CEOs, this might mean convincing buyers to pay for those synergies with the help of their advisors. Having to use powers of persuasion can happen in cases where the buyer might not want to pay for those synergies. Cassel cites an instance where a buyer’s analysis shows that the synergies reduce the purchase price from paying 7X EBITDA to a lower multiple.
There are no set rules as to which of these items need to be removed or added back into the adjusted EBITDA calculation. Thus it is important for sellers to work closely with their advisors to determine what goes into the computation to get the best price and valuation for their companies in an M&A deal.
“When it comes to adjusted EBITDA, this is often a matter of negotiation as to which items can be added back to the operating expenses of the company and which items are discretionary, extraordinary or non-recurring,” says Craig Dickens, CEO and founder of Merit Harbor Group.
“A good investment banker will construct a defensible rationale for add-backs and negotiate vigorously around these items; however, the best defense is to it’s best to run as clean an operation as possible leading up to a sale.”
Keeping a clean operation is a good rule of thumb for CEOs to remember — this means the less discretionary add-backs to EBITDA, the better it is for acquirer confidence.
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.

Wednesday, December 28, 2016

Separating the Sale of a Multi-Unit Office Building from a Business Sale | Edison Avenue

By Eric J. Gall, Managing Partner, Edison Avenue
December 28, 2016

Oftentimes business owners would like to sell their commercial property with their business.  A recent "failed" transaction I was involved in on the buy-side involved the sale of a business and commercial property with an additional layer of complexity to the sale:  The Seller's commercial property included several leased office spaces in addition to the Seller's primary business, i.e., there are two very separate and distinct businesses for sale:


  1. The Seller's income producing property.
  2. The Seller's primary business.


VALUING THE INCOME PRODUCING PROPERTY

The first step in the valuation process is to value the property.

The value of commercial office space is largely derived from an income approach appraisal based on a simple formula for valuing commercial real estate:

Present Market Value = Net Operating Income / Capitalization Rate

NOI (Net Operating Income) is calculated by summing gross rents and other income generated by the property, then subtracting all operating expenses. Operating expenses include required management and upkeep expenses such as:


  • Property Management
  • Repairs and Maintenance
  • Landscaping
  • Marketing
  • Taxes
  • Insurance


Debt service/loan payments are not considered an operating expense. This is because each buyer will choose their own unique debt structures to finance and purchase the property based on their goals, objectives and credit worthiness. This choice influences net cash flow to the buyer, but does not impact the property’s value.

Present Market Value Calculation:

Income:
Seller's business Rent:  $68,000/year
Tenant #1 Rent:  $18,000/year  
Tenant #2 Rent:  $18,000/year 
Tenant #3 Rent:  $18,000/year 
Total Income:  $122,000/year

Expenses:
Property Management:  $1,200/year
Repairs & Maintenance:  $4,800/year
Landscaping:  $4,800/year
Marketing:  $1,200/year
Taxes:  $4,800/year
Insurance:  $3,600/year
Total Expenses:  $20,400/year

NOI (Net Operating Income) = Total Income - Total Expenses = $122,000 - $20,400 = $101,600

The next step is determining a fair capitalization rate (Cap Rate) for the market where the property is located. Commercial real estate lenders, brokers, and appraisers should have this information, especially for markets they service.

A market cap rate is determined by averaging the cap rates for similar properties in the market's geographic region. Each property will have its own cap rate at the time of sale and is calculated using the following formula:

Cap Rate = NOI / Purchase Price. 

Let's say the market's Cap Rate for multi-unit office properties for the example region is 8%.  With this Cap Rate, we can simply to determine the property’s value by taking the NOI and divide it by the cap rate.

Value = Cap Rate / NOI = $101,600 / 8% = $1,270,000

The building's value is $1,270,000.


VALUING THE BUSINESS

Valuing a business can be a very complicated process.  There are many acceptable methods to value a business; however, none are perfect as variables such as size, type, reason for sale, quality of financial statements, owner involvement, etc. all impact the business value.  Typically, a good estimate of business value can be completed by looking at historical sales of similar businesses.  

The first step is to gather your financial statements:  income (P&L), cash flow, and balance sheet. Next, with help of your business broker or CPA, recast the income statement to estimate the Seller's Discretionary Earnings (SDE).  To calculate SDE, net income is supplemented by "adding-back" the non-cash expenses such as depreciation and amortization; personal expenses such as the Seller's interest payments for business loans; the Seller's salary and personal payroll taxes; Seller's health and life insurance; Seller's personal non-business expenses such as an auto, auto insurance and cell phones; and special cause expenses such as purchase of equipment (Section 179 expense).  

KEY ITEMS OF NOTE REGARDING THE PROPERTY AND BUSINESS:
  

  1. Rental incomes from the office-units were included in the property valuation.  Rental incomes are not part of the business operations; therefore, they cannot be included in the revenue in the business financial statements.  If they are, they must be subtracted from the business revenue line.
  2. Property management and upkeep expenses were included in the property valuation.  These expenses are not part of the business operations; therefore, they cannot be included in the expenses on the business financial statements.  If they are, they must be added-back to calculate SDE.
  3. The business is expected to pay a fair market rent.  If the tenants are paying $10/square foot in rent, the Seller's business should be expected to pay $10/square foot in rent.  If the Seller is giving him/herself a rent discount, then the difference between fair market rent and the rent the Seller is paying must be added to the Seller's expenses to create a fair valuation of both the property and the business.


Fair Market Rent Calculation:

Let's assume the Fair Market Rent is $10/square foot and each tenant is expected to pay $10/square foot.

Rent = Fair Market Rent x Square Footage

Hence, 

Square Footage = Rent / Fair Market Rent

Square Footage (Tenant) = $18,000 / $10 = 1,800 square feet.

Square Footage (Seller) = $68,000 / $10 = 6,800 square feet.

Let's say the seller is giving him/herself a discount by only paying $48,000/year in rent, or a $20,000 discount.  We've already used the full $68,000 in the valuation of the property, so no change would need to be made to the property value.  However, the $20,000 in additional fair market rent must be added as an expense and the net income of the business reduced accordingly.  


Calculation of Business revenue and SDE:

Income Statement Including Property:
Revenue including Rent:  $775,000
Expenses including Building:  $665,000
Net Income:  $775,000 - $665,000 = $110,000

Adjustments:
Removal of Rental Income from Business Revenue:  $775,000 - $122,000 = $653,000
Removal of Property Expenses from Business Expense:  $665,000 - 20,400 = 644,600
Business Net Income:  $653,000 - 644,600 = $8,400

The key item of note is the actual business revenue is $653,000, not $775,000.

Add-Backs:
Seller's Salary and Tax Benefits:  $100,000
Seller's interest:  $25,000
Depreciation and Amortization:  $40,000
Seller's Health and Life Insurance:  $25,000
Seller's Other Personal Benefits:  $18,000
Total Add-Backs:  $208,000

Business Net Income:  $8,400
Total Add-Backs:  $208,000
SDE:  $216,400

Let's say that either looking at historical sales of similar businesses or the published industry multiples, we find the revenue multiple is 0.90 times annual revenue and 2.5 times the SDE.  Using these multiples, the valuation calculations would be:

Revenue:  $653,000 x 0.90 = $587,700
SDE:  $216,400 x 2.5 = $541,000

Therefore, the business value would be somewhere around $541,000 to $587,700.  For simplicity, let's assume $562,500.

The total value for the business and property would be (estimated*):

Total Value = Property Value + Business Value = $1,270,000 + $562,500 = $1,832,500.


CONCLUSION:

Separating the property financial statements from the business financial statements is critical to valuing both the property and the business separately and equitably.  Failure to do so creates incorrect valuations, possibly unrealistic expectations from the Seller, and in my most recent case, considerably wasted time on a lost deal by both the buyer and myself.    

* Note:  Valuations are opinions and may very on numerous additional factors not considered in this analysis including quality of assets, quality of financial records, seller involvement and customer concentration among many others.

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com.

Monday, May 4, 2015

What is Supply Chain Financing | Axial

English: An illustration of a company's supply...
An illustration of a company's supply chain  (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
By  , Axial | 
Supply chain financing is the process by which buyers and sellers manage their liquidity and cash flows at any link in the supply chain. It is typically based around selling invoices at a discount in order to improve liquidity on either side of the chain. Buyers with strong credit have the most power in supply chain finance.
Supply chain financing has developed significantly since the credit crisis. It was previously viewed as being an option for small to medium-sized business who were in distress, however, an increasing number of healthy businesses, including blue-chip multinationals, are using supply chain financing to build stronger relationships with suppliers, decrease currency risk and ultimately improve liquidity.
There are several major ways that companies can approach their supply chain finance strategy. Here we cover the five most common ways, as well as their pros and cons.
TypeProsCons
Factoring: When a supplier sells their accounts receivables at a discount to a financial counterparty in order to get cash today so they can finance part of their ongoing operations.The counterparty is only evaluating the likelihood that you will get paid, so you often don’t need a credit check. Also, you can get cash in less than 10 days, and often in as little as 1 or 2 days.Financing costs on factoring can easily exceed 20% of the value of receivables. There are often high minimums on receivables and high late fees, which puts the borrower at risk for lost margins if their customers are late in paying.
Trade Credit: A type of credit sellers extend to buyers, allowing the latter to purchase goods from the former without immediate payment.From the perspective of the creditor, is should induce more sales because purchases can made without the cash. For the buyer, it allows for cash flow freedom and easier response to demand.If the creditor never gets paid, they will eventually have to write that off as bad debt, which lowers profits. If buyers use a lot of trade credit, they can end up paying more for inventory because sellers often offer discounts for quick payments.
Invoice Discounting: When a supplier gets loans from a creditor using discounted accounts receivable, somewhat like factoring, as collateral.Same pros as factoring, except you manage your own receivables so your buyers will never know that you are cash strapped.Same cons as factoring.
Supplier Subsidies: When a manufacturer uses their own funds to offer lower rate financing options for suppliers, instead of relying on their suppliers to get outside financing.No financial institutions need to be involved, which allows the manufacturer to issue more credit to suppliers than they would otherwise get and thus ramp up production and revenues. The manufacturer also makes an interest rate on the loaned funds.This can be risky for the manufacturer, as they are essentially acting as creditors. For example, GE was owed millions in the credit crunch of 2008 and is only now fully recovering.
Reverse Factoring:Somewhat like traditional factoring where a supplier gets a loan from an outside financier based on accounts receivable, except that in this case the buyer is committing to pay the creditor on the set date.As with factoring, the supplier gets immediate cash, however, the buyer has agreed to be ultimately liable and the interest rates are based on the credit of the buyer, and as such are often lower.Credit availability for the supplier can fluctuate with credit of the buyer. It is also a complicated approval process subject to differing laws in various regulatory jurisdictions.
Article LINK

For additional information regarding Florida business sales, acquisitions and valuations, please contact Eric J. Gall at Eric@EdisonAvenue.com or 239.738.6227. Also, visit our Edison Avenue website at www.EdisonAvenue.com or my personal website at www.BuySellFLbiz.com.